10 ms·
Thanks to Quora, now you can’t read anonymously
- peto123 14y agoThis is disturbing. I hope this will not become a trend.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoI don't think it will spread too much. Nothing would kill Facebook quicker than then implementing this, for example.
- Jacqued 14y agoAgreed. I'm on the verge of leaving facebook, I've been for quite some time. Their stupid change in chat (people know when you read what they wrote) almost made me quit, but Chrome extensions to disable it allowed me to stay. With such a move, I would not stay one day longer on the "service".
- crpatino 14y agoIt's boiled frogs all the way down!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- SwellJoe 14y agoI'd forgotten what Quora was, or that it had existed. Now I'm very glad that's the case, since I wouldn't want to have to stop using something I actually liked.
- grose 14y agoWhat value does this have over, say, an anonymized view count? While it's nice to know that people have seen what you've written, does their identity really need to be known?
- jaredsohn 14y agoYou can turn it off, but then you can't see who viewed things. (Similar to how LinkedIn and OkCupid work with anonymous browsing.) And if you really want to see I'm sure you can do so via another account. (I think it is possible because okc and linkedin hide private data but quora hides public data.) Instructions: http://www.quora.com/Views-on-Quora/How-do-I-turn-off-the-Views-feature-on-Quora http://www.quora.com/Views-on-Quora/How-do-I-turn-off-the-Vi...
- kintamanimatt 14y agoThat's fine by me!
- onwardly 14y agoThis move by Quora pissed me off, but the only reason I'm keeping my account is because they allowed me to turn it off. Quite an effective way to destroy some goodwill they'd built up with me over the past couple of years.
- wilfra 14y agoI've learned to go with the flow and trust them when they make changes like this. My first impression is usually to want the 'old Quora' back but once I get used to them, the changes do nearly always improve the experience. I would imagine this will be the same. They are very skilled at interpreting needs and desires we didn't know we had and quickly correcting themselves the times they do make mistakes (like the recent notification spam issues). edit: lol @ downvotes. Unacceptable to not be a Quora hater I guess...
- michaelbuckbee 14y agoI'd be curious to know what/how you use Quora. I've had an account on there forever, but it just doesn't quite seem to hit the right level of utility for me to go back to it.
- wilfra 14y agoIt's all about the feed. You need to follow people who are interested in things you're interested in.
- jcc80 14y agovery skilled at interpreting needs and desires we didn't know we had This is basically the same line that I use when I'm mocking targeted ads and joking around with friends about how thankful they should be for them. If your edit wasn't there I would have guessed this was a level aka fooling someone w/ sarcasm or non-serious remark.
- wilfra 14y agoIt's also the same line people use when they describe why Steve Jobs was so brilliant. There is a difference, however, in explaining away unpopular changes as being this and actually being good at it. Quora is actually good at it.
- dinkumthinkum 14y agoI don't think it's as much about not being a Quora hater but more the attitude of "they know what's best for me."
- mikebracco 14y agoWell as Eric Schmidt said, “If you have something that you don’t want anyone to know maybe you shouldn’t be doing it in the first place." ;) http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2011/01/21/top-10-the-quotable-eric-schmidt/ http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2011/01/21/top-10-the-quotable-e...
- jopt 14y agoI hope the smiley is sarcastic?
- PakG1 14y agoWith the exception of "stealth" startups? ;)
- houk 14y agoBullshit. That quote is based on the (false) premise that privacy is there to conceal illegal/shady activities. It puts you in one of two groups; You're either guilty of something and have a reason to hide it, or you're not guilty and have no reason to hide anything. It doesn't include the possibility that you might not be guilty of something but may still want to keep something hidden. I'll give you an example. You might NOT want to give your phone number when you register on some social website because you don't want that data used for marketting purposes.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tallanvor 14y agoYes, Schmidt showed a complete lack of understanding of why anonymity is still often a necessity online. Do we really need to keep going over the examples that clearly show he is wrong?
- samstave 14y agoI am not sure I follow your logic here... Either you are being sarcastic, or idiotic. Please tel me which one.
- samstave 14y agoQuora is in the same boat as FB (and to a certain extent, Twitter) They think that the experience of their largely 20-something staff is anything short of revolutionary. A bunch of kids running a digital media company with questionable morals and no connection to digital history. I will delete me Quora account. So far I have gotten little value from it. Time for it to have no data on me. Deactivated! Edit: I followed up with an email to FEEDBACK@QUORA.COM asking them to delete my account and data.. will see what happens. I dont like the idea of a limbo account that can be reactivated/mined. I'd prefer to have it deleted.
- monsterix 14y agoAbsolutely. Their policy to force your true_full_name is an absolute no-go for many users. A friend of mine from south India has a very lengthy name. Few parts of his name are direct reference to his ancestors and the villages they come from. Sort of like this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._D._Deve_Gowda http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._D._Deve_Gowda where H. D. parts of his name are references to ancestry, places etc. My friend was denied permission to use Quora, rather insultingly blocked, for not revealing his ancestor name. We thought it was plain stupid on part of Quora to behave this way, so didn't bother to follow up with them either. What's amazing here is that even Government passports don't force revealing names of ancestors like they do.
- cantrevealname 14y agoMy friend was denied permission to use Quora for not revealing his ancestor name. Could you explain how it happened in this specific case, since it sounds like the name that your friend gave appeared to be real. That it, it wasn't something like "Fake Name" or "Bite Me", so how did Quora know? And, in general, could someone explain how the likes of Quora and Facebook decide that a name isn't "real"? Does someone at Quora or Facebook manually scan new account names? Do they wait for complaints from other users? Is it something algorithmic like noting that you receive messages such as "Hi Mike" but where you registered as "Fred Flintstone"?
- 14y ago
- bobobo1618 14y agoJust thought I'd point out that the method they used for the obfuscation is a simple CSS rule. It can be quite easily disabled with the developer tools, an extension or a proxy.
- benjaminwootton 14y agoI've never signed up to Quora, but the last time I visited, it looked as though I was logged in which I assumed was via my Twitter cookie. (I don't have a Facebook account.) It's not happening now so possibly was part of some A/B test. That coupled with this passive browsing would be a step too far.
- 0x0 14y agoQuora has gone the way of expert-sexchange, showing up in Google search results for interesting questions, but then overlaying/replacing most answers with blur and "sign up to read". Borderline SERP cloaking, to say the least.
- iaskwhy 14y agoIt's actually worse because with expert-sexchange you can scroll to the bottom to read the answers. Not so much with Quora, right?
- irahul 14y ago> Quora has gone the way of expert-sexchange, showing up in Google search results for interesting questions, but then overlaying/replacing most answers with blur and "sign up to read". This shit doesn't fly with Google. Delivering different content to Google bot and the user coming through search makes Google looks like a fool, since the user is unable to find the content he searched for. That is why expert-sexchange shows answers at the bottom when Google is your referrer. If Quora is pulling up this shit, Google will penalize it. I think it's more likely Quora is simply hiding content behind css.
- 0x0 14y agoIt looks like what they are doing are obfuscating with CSS. See for example: http://www.quora.com/Bayesian-Inference/How-do-Bayesian-algorithms-work-for-the-identification-of-spam http://www.quora.com/Bayesian-Inference/How-do-Bayesian-algo... The answers are in a span with class "blurred_answer", which has css styles: "color: transparent; text-shadow: 0 0 7px #777". Which in effect makes the text completely unreadable to humans. This is just one step above "color: #fff; background-color: #fff". Scummy.
- cantrevealname 14y agoI don't see missing or blurred text in your example, http://www.quora.com/Bayesian-Inference/How-do-Bayesian-algorithms-work-for-the-identification-of-spam http://www.quora.com/Bayesian-Inference/How-do-Bayesian-algo... I checked with two different browsers (Opera and Firefox under Windows). Could this mean that the Quora PR machine is up in full swing trying to undo damage (at least in the case of specific links that people cite)?
- muyuu 14y agoQuora seems nice but I cannot possibly feel comfortable with their policies, even before this. I can only participate very selectively because of this. I like the service and it has traction, too bad their invasiveness thresholds are too lax for me to accept. I'd rather just pay a small quantity to be honest. I'm not sure if an alternative site working on subscriber money would be feasible.
- flipside 14y agoTo me, the fact that Quora feels it needs to share passive views means they're failing to get enough people to actively engage with their content. If I don't care enough click a button, either A) I have no meaningful opinion, B) I don't want Quora to know what I think, or C) there's a "problem" with the button. Quora, if you're going to just make assumptions about why I'm looking at an answer, you will very often be WRONG. (views disabled)
- pooriaazimi 14y agoThis is stupid. What's more stupid is their desperation for you to interact with their site. I went to remove my unused account, and this is what I got when I typed www.quora.com: http://d.pr/i/WcMl http://d.pr/i/WcMl You'll notice that I couldn't do anything else - I "had" to choose 5 extremely broad subjects that I'm supposed to be interested in, in order to be able to view my profile. I selected 5 subjects randomly, and... http://d.pr/i/P7ex http://d.pr/i/P7ex Only after that they kindly allowed me to view the main page and my profile. I deactivated my account, and won't ever click on a quota link again (and would add them to my spam list so they won't show up in my Google results).
- savramescu 14y agoIf you don't email privacy@quora.com it won't get deleted though. Make sure you do that as well.
- pooriaazimi 14y agoThanks for pointing that out. Is that a robot on the other end (which deletes the account if it contains "delete" or so etching like that in the subject field), or you have to talk to a human and ask them to delete it?
- axx 14y agoI really have the feeling we're all merely getting sold to advertisers. Where are the real innovations from tech people? It is not about "social interaction", in many ways it's only about getting as much data from the user as possible, to sell it. I can't say how much i hate the "social trend" in this era of the internet boom. "Yeah, our Product is a ripoff of Product X (proof concept, existing since 2000) BUT WE ADDED SOCIAL TO IT, ZOMG!!11" What's bugging me even more is the fact, that there're so many stupid VCs who think they'll invest in the next big thing and support stupid ideas, too blind to see real innovations.
- mattgreenrocks 14y ago> I can't say how much i hate the "social trend" in this era of the internet boom. It angers me greatly. I attribute it to tech going mainstream in a big way. It waters down the entire industry. Worse, it feels like it has slowed down R&D because everyone's so complacent with what we have.
- minikomi 14y agoOff topic I guess, but to me Quora seems to have passed it's peak for updates to topics which I find interesting, unfortunately. I was not an early adopter, and joined when the gated-community phase ended, selected my topics and enjoyed quite a few good answers. A week later I opened it up on a train ride, but the content had not changed at all. And, perhaps more tellingly, in each topic the few scraps of fresh activity each time I've opened the app since have been from exactly the same users.
- vlasta2 14y agoI do not have a Quora account, but I understand their move and it may not be all bad. There are 3 ways how a company may handle user passive privacy: 1. Not collect any information (in this case who read what article) at all. Obviously that company would be at a big disadvantage, having no access to a useful set of signals. 2. Collect the information and use it for their own goals. 3. Collect the information and make it freely available. If I understand the article correctly, Quora went from strategy #2 to #3. From my perspective, this is a positive move. In case #3, users are aware of what is happening with their private information and may log out if they do not want to be tracked this way. It is way better than living in peaceful ignorance as in case #2. Also, the company cannot sell the private info, because it is publicly available.
- unimpressive 14y ago> Also, the company cannot sell the private info, because it is publicly available. Uh. Maybe you don't understand why people don't like it when companies sell their data. It's because it ends up in the hands of every shady marketing agency and intelligence organization on earth. Making it public just means that these parties can get it with no barrier to entry. See: Usenet, where any email address that's ever touched it is supposedly under constant siege by spam.
- vlasta2 14y agoMaybe I have expressed myself not clearly enough, so once more: I prefer the collected information to be public because then it is clear to everyone that it is being collected and many more people are aware of the implications. I think it is better than when the same kind of information is being secretly sold while users have a false feeling of privacy.
- fourstar 14y agoThe greatest thing about Quora is that it doesn't really "exist" outside of the valley. I stayed in Georgia for 3 months. Everyone in the startup scene out there (except for my friend who runs a successful website) doesn't know what Quora is. When I explained it to them, they thought they could get the same answers from Google. To an extent, they are correct. I'm getting tired of these self-entitled startups who think they are running the show.
- marquis 14y ago"get the same answers from Google" - well, I signed up for a Quora account out of curiosity some time ago and started receiving their weekly emails, which generally I delete or unsubscribe from with most companies but something about Quora's community has kept me subscribed, for example answers to questions such as 'What wass it like to grow up insanely rich' and 'What is it like to lose an Olympic event'. I checked my account and the default is still No for "Allow others to see what content I've viewed in feed" but I'll certainly be considering deleting my account should this be activated without my consent.
- andrewingram 14y agoEarly last year, when I was starting to get into using Quora, I stopped using it abruptly when I realised how limited their privacy features are. Basically, I wanted to contribute quite heavily to the Depression topic. I'm a sufferer and I wanted to be able to help other people. But on Quora you have a choice of answering a question either Anonymously or as yourself, the problem with answering as yourself is that all your activity gets published to the feed of people who follow you, and with Quora being heavily integrated with Facebook I wasn't comfortable with this. Which meant I was forced to answer questions anonymously, which I was equally uncomfortable with. I felt like I couldn't make an valuable contribution if I was hiding behind anonymity each time. I don't mind people knowing things about me, which is why I don't mind saying this here, using my real name, but that's very different to being willing to shout from the rooftops. I emailed Quora to suggest being able to decide what information gets published to the feed on a per-topic basis. I didn't get a response, which is hardly surprising, but if basic privacy-controls are outside of their plan for the site, I can't be part of it.
- bornhuetter 14y ago> I felt like I couldn't make an valuable contribution if I was hiding behind anonymity each time. Why is that?
- andrewingram 14y agoBecause I feel part of being a community member is having a recognisable name, even if it's just a pseudonym, so just being "Anonymous" isn't sufficient for me. Names are important because they allow you to build reputation (ignoring actual reputation algorithms for now). So if a particular question comes up, a user might think "I wonder what Joey Joe Joe thinks about this" or "Let's see what AmazingFace82's answer to this question is". In the case of any community that's fundamentally about self-improvement, for example the Depression topic, it's useful to see how an individual's contributions change over time. Do they become more positive? What solutions did they try, which ones were most effective?
- 14y ago
- aneth4 14y agoThis is misleading, as you CAN read anonymously if you disable the feature. Personally, I read stuff for amusement or interest all the time that I would not want a large portion of my acquaintances knowing that I read, and certainly not without explanation. For instance, if I read an article about child abuse and get curious about the age of consent in Massachusetts, I don't want that showing up to random acquaintances in my feed anywhere. Enabling this feature surreptitiously and without an opt-in is insanely stupid and insensitive to users. Given that Quora has very good support for anonymous questions and answers, you'd expect them to be more savvy than this.
- zerop 14y agoIt can be turned off easily. No sweat !!
- 89a 14y agoGenuinely never understood the hype or money behind this. It's just ExpertSexChange all over again
- angry-hacker 14y agoWhy Google doesn't penalize them for serving different content to google bot and to humans?! How can thy get away with it... I'm sure many people who work for Google and are part of team that has authority to make those changes have seen it..?-
- joelthelion 14y agoJust use a fake name :)
- joelthelion 14y agoThere is space for competition in that area. StackExchange is pretty good, but since they don't allow questions with subjective answers, they basically exclude themselves from the vast majority of the market share. Then there is quora, yahoo answers, ... There is certainly enough space for a few good startups.
- rm999 14y agoReddit has some decent subreddits devoted to questions/answers, but the really good ones, like askscience, only allow objective answers. On second thought, that's probably why those ones are good.
- mmahemoff 14y agoStackExchange leaves a lot of open opportunities even in the areas they focus on. The objectivity mantra means they'll ban "best programmer jokes", perhaps understandable, but oddly they'll block questions like "best database for X, best book on X" as being "Not Constructive". (I could understand "subjective", but I can't see how it's not useful data.) So when I see things like this, it makes me think there's surely an opportunity and the opportunity falls squarely in Quora's lap. But depending how they execute on it, they might still be leaving the space wide open for others.
- chrisacky 14y agoIf you would like try and get your account deleted, send something like this to privacy@quora.com --------------------- Please can you delete my account. I'm unhappy with your recent changes that would allow anyone to see the topics I follow and read. My registered account is set up at <email address> Please can you send me confirmation when you have done this. Many Thanks. --------------------- I've fired an email off. Re: http://www.quora.com/How-do-I-delete-my-Quora-account http://www.quora.com/How-do-I-delete-my-Quora-account
- Auguste 14y agoHere is my deletion request: -- To: privacy@quora.com Subject: Account deletion request -- Hi Quora, I am unhappy with the new Views feature, which is enabled by default. I do not wish to be part of a website that prevents its users from browsing pages anonymously, especially if it also requires them to use their full names. Can you please delete my Quora account and all associated data as soon as possible, including my public and anonymous answers. Please also send me a confirmation email once this data has been erased. My account page is located at www.quora.com/XXXXXXXXXXXX. Regards, XXXXXXXXXXXX
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Auguste 14y agoUPDATE Quora has processed my deletion request and confirmed that my account has been deleted. Except that not a whole lot was deleted, as far as I can see. I can still log in. I left my account logged in and did not deactivate it before sending the request. It looks like most of my details are still intact. * My name was replaced with User-XXXX, where XXXX is a four-digit integer. * My followers and the people I'm following were removed * It looks like the comments that I left on answers have been deleted. * I'm not sure about things like my biography, country of origin, etc. because I removed those myself first * I can still see other details such as my edit history and the messages I have exchanged with others. My answers do not seem to have been deleted. I'm not 100% sure about this, because I made sure I manually deleted them all myself before asking for my profile to be deleted. But when I view a question I answered, I still have the option of undeleting my answer. Maybe Quora normally permadeletes answers only if they weren't manually deleted first. Maybe they just flag them as deleted like I did manually. I have no idea. All the questions I had created still exist. The only questions I was able to delete myself were the ones with no answers on them. The others remain, but with my name scrubbed off them. I find this acceptable and didn't expect Quora to delete other peoples' answers along with my questions. Ultimately I'm pretty happy with this. I would have preferred to have everything permadeleted, but as long as my answers are no longer visible and my personal informatoin has been scrubbed, I'll leave it at that. Here's a screenshot of my Quora edit history, with the individual edits blurred out: https://dl.dropbox.com/u/4630539/Quora%20Edit%20List.png https://dl.dropbox.com/u/4630539/Quora%20Edit%20List.png
- tronronin 14y agoWell, I don't think its about the money. Its a desperate move. Heres my theory on what happened: Quora was started by an elitist group. They made content policies that were very elitist (similar to HN in a way) emphasizing quality and trained their early adopters to vote only the VERY BEST of content. They then moved away from the gated status and allowed others to enter their community. The new-comers were however not as qualified to write as the old user base and obviously most of them never got any upvotes for the content they created. So the new users got programmed to believe that up votes are scarce on quora and therefore they themselves stopped up voting on quora. Well the only problem with this was, up voting also meant sharing. So by training users to not up vote in a way, they cut off their sharing. So now old content stopped circulating and that explains why most people think quora is dead. To solve the problem of content circulation slowing down, which would heavily impact the discovery of content, Quora first launched a feature called 'Boards' some time back. (Even though this invited comments on how Quora is just copying pinterest). That probably got the engine up and running for some while. However this still did not fix the problem. I think the most popular board on Quora has something like 5000 followers. Thats it! So the content is still not circulating well. So then they came up with the Views feature - a feature turned on by default and which would convert every view into a vote and could turn on their content engine back up again. What people don't get is - The guy who started eHow is an investor at Quora. It has always been about long tail content, getting traffic for long queries on google, content circulation etc... Quora is not innovative at all, there is no great model there. Its just eHow done more cleanly.
- wilfra 14y agoeHow is garbage content though. They might target search traffic in the same way but the answers on Quora are actually good. Perhaps thats what you meant by 'cleanly' but I took that to mean design only.
- lubujackson 14y agoExcept it's written by users, so it's really Yahoo Answers with real names.
- assente 14y agoYes you can. With a little hack http://assente.vega9.com/it/how_to_bypass_quoras_text_hiding_for_unregistered_users http://assente.vega9.com/it/how_to_bypass_quoras_text_hiding...
- kmfrk 14y agoI essentially deleted my account a long time ago, which involved unsubscribing from every single question, and anonymizing every single comment I had ever made. It was the only thing close to deleting my account, and yet I still see my content, follows, and upvotes there. Gaining a sense of privacy is an abstruse and opaque task. And I'm sure that's intended. One of the things that really bothered me was that I could tell who had made a thread about a sensitive or taboo-ridden subject[1], although this was not at all obvious to the person who posted the question. The site creates the impression that you are - sort of - anonymous when asking a question, but have to explicitly choose to anonymize, when you post an answer. To think that this company raised at a $400M valuation in April pisses me off. The concept of privacy can quickly get very semantic, but I think Steve Jobs summed it up perfectly: Privacy means people know what they are signing up for. — Steve Jobs, D8 2010. Anyone in their right mind will see that Quora don't give two shits about privacy - probably because the abolition of it helps their business model. [1]: In the list of portraits of people following a question, the first of the portraits is the person who posted the question.
- krelian 14y agoI was curious so I just had a look with my (fake name) account and the option called "Allow others to see what content I've viewed in feed" was set at "No". I don't recall ever playing with that setting so this may be a recent change on their part to avoid the backlash.
- gojomo 14y agoMine was also 'No', but then I visited the homepage (http://www.quora.com http://www.quora.com) and closed the notice there about the new Views feature... which toggled the setting to 'Yes', without any message to that effect. So try viewing the homepage and then check the setting, or closing the fewture notification... it may then be 'Yes'.
- brown9-2 14y agoI'm not so sure. I just logged into my account (which I have rarely used) and the setting had a value of "Yes" for me.
- johnchristopher 14y agoNot entirely unrelated: today on Facebook I noticed there are groups I can't browse without the group creator knowing which posts I have seen and which posts I haven't. https://www.facebook.com/help/?faq=409719555736128&in_context https://www.facebook.com/help/?faq=409719555736128&in_co... It might not be new but it was the first time I noticed it (and I immediately left the group without thinking about it for even one second).
- chimi 14y agoI'm going to sound like a broken record here, but Quora users are the product, not the customer. Quora wants to make money and they can make more of it by showing everyone who is looking at what. If they can go to advertisers and say, "See, we know every single question people are interested in, so you can get better value out of your clicks! We show this information to everyone, so we have no problem letting you tailor your placements to exact criteria." Then they can charge more. It's simple as that. Quora was a darling. It was started from the inside. We didn't expect this one did we? Why oh why do we keep creating content/value for random people we don't know when we could create a blog on our own website? When we could create a product that has value to us and others and benefits us in a direct and measurable way? Creating that content is work. Answering those questions is work. It takes time. It takes energy. It takes concentration and value away from work that benefits YOU. OMG, I'm doing it right now!
- hnriot 14y agoI think it must also benefit you, otherwise you wouldn't be doing it, basic human needs are tapped by the quota model (and here on hn too), recognition, self expression, philanthropy etc. Thanks to the subtle game mechanics employed by quora (and hn) these needs are exploited to create a symbiosis, you help them create content that that they can use for their purpose and in return you get those needs met, and create habits around them thanks to the dopamine reward cycle.
- markkat 14y agoIt's more than just creating content, it's communication. Quora's end of the bargain was to maintain a quality platform for the exchange of ideas. I never got pass the real name policy. I think a mistake is that these services are either built without a clear development strategy, or the development strategy doesn't jive with what the users expect from the early growth phase.
- dhimes 14y agoI think the pressure becomes overwhelming when you are playing with other people's money; that is, when you get investors. There is only one question to ask: how can we make more money? It's usually phrased differently, but that's ultimately the question. We see this repeatedly with "free" products. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice...
- username3 14y agoFriendster did the same thing. Look where it is now. https://www.google.com/search?q=friendster+who+viewed+me https://www.google.com/search?q=friendster+who+viewed+me
- ojbyrne 14y agoThat headline seems unnecessarily incendiary, since it tells you in the last paragraph how to opt out.
- ericdykstra 14y agoHeadline: Thanks to Quora, now you can’t read anonymously. Reality: Quora launched a feature called "views", announced to everyone upon logging in that it was automatically enabled, and is disabled with three clicks from any page on the site. I wasn't particularly happy when I was opted in, and immediately turned it off. Then, after a few hours, I turned it back on and saw that it was actually a pretty useful feature to see how people were getting to my content. I noticed that a few of my followers were "connectors" of Quora, through which half or more of my views on an answer came. This, I feel, is useful and relevant information. Yes, being opted into a less private setting is unsettling, but I trust Quora at least as much as any other company. This is the first time I've been opted into anything, their settings are incredibly easy to figure out and are granular, and I trust the people that run the site. I'll add that this seems to bother non-users more than people who actually use the site regularly.
- cube13 14y agoMy reality: Quora links are 100% useless to click. I don't have an account there. I never intend to have an account there, because the only thing I've used it for is to get answers(or more context) to the occasional bizarre coding issue I've run into at work. I've never felt the need to post anything. So no, it doesn't matter what new "feature" they added. They have effectively killed their entire product for me.
- kevinpet 14y agoI think your opinion is pretty much worthless then. We're talking about how a change impacts the value of Quora to users. You didn't like the old version, don't like the new version, so why comment?
- rhizome 14y agoTwo questions: do they tell you which three clicks are required, and why couldn't they just put an accept/decline button in the login announcement?
- lrei 14y agoThe immediate solution is simple: Settings -> Views: Allow others to see what content I've viewed in feed: No (yes) -- change to no. It's creepy and disrespectful that they would turn this on by default and it looks extremely desperate which makes me doubt quora's financial stability. Which in turn makes me not want to spend time contributing to it (not that I've made many contributions). But this is the sort of thing FB would've done in their place... So I don't know, maybe their staff simply has no understanding of how people feel about privacy.
- vijayr 14y agoOne thing I can't understand with this "real name" stuff - why can't sites like quora charge a one time fee, like Metafilter? When people pay real money, you know who they are, they are less likely to troll, no? This has been successful with Metafilter, why can't other sites copy this? It'll also be another (small) source of revenue
- wyclif 14y agoThis is bad, bad juju on Quora's part. The Facebookisation of Quora is something that makes my Spidey sense go off as well. Forcing "real" names. Forcing reads into the public without warning. Lots of "hey, we're the coolest social startup on the block." Quora is overrated. They need to get it together, dial down the hype, and show some freaking humility. To do that they'll need to stop abusing the users they have.
- wyclif 14y agoThis is bad, bad juju on Quora's part. The Facebookisation of Quora is something that makes my Spidey sense go off as well. Forcing "real" names. Forcing reads into the public without warning. Lots of "hey, we're the coolest social startup on the block." Quora is overrated and needs to get it together and stop abusing the users it has.
- yumraj 14y agoThis is one of the reasons I keep fake accounts, including on quora, FB and Twitter, to read the content. Due to the fake name in the quora account, I don't have edit privileges, which is perfectly fine with me as it is at most a minor inconvenience at times.
- jmsduran 14y agoAlthough I don't have a Quora account, I definitely won't be signing up for one after hearing this news. I dislike the idea of passively sharing information. In my opinion, sharing should be a conscious decision the user makes, not something that the user is tricked or forced into.
- Karunamon 14y agoHow are you tricked or forced when you're told what's happening upfront and told how to stop it if you don't like it? It's not like the proverbial hyperspace bypass paperwork, it's literally 3 clicks. I swear guys, some of you have both very oversensitive outrage modules and a broad definition of deception. That goes to most everyone in this thread.
- oth3r 14y agoOne thing that stuck out to me in the article is the whole concept of "anonymous reading." When did the need to make the distinction of anonymous vs non-anonymous reading arise? Anonymity was assumed for something as simple as picking up a book or a newspaper. It sounds as awkward and unnatural to me as taking an "anonymous shower" or anonymously picking my nose. Pretty scary that we're headed down this path where fewer and fewer things are private.
- rdl 14y agoI wouldn't mind this feature if it were totally opt-in.
- yalogin 14y agoHonest question, why is Quora still relevant? I thought after the initial hype for what ever reason their traction is gone (as expected). They are nothing but a glorified version of yahoo answers. HN, Reddit and Stackoverflow do a better job at what they do.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- 18pfsmt 14y agoJust an FYI: This is known as thread-jacking, and it is looked down upon here on HN. I would suggest you post in 'Ask HN' if you want feedback.
- jlukanta 14y agoNot all views are shared. http://www.quora.com/Views-on-Quora/Which-of-my-views-will-and-which-views-wont-be-shared-through-Quoras-Views-feature/answer/Sandra-Liu-Huang http://www.quora.com/Views-on-Quora/Which-of-my-views-will-a... If you are too afraid to visit that link, try this one: http://pastebin.com/T2s9Vjxn http://pastebin.com/T2s9Vjxn
- mschalle 14y agoQuora, you fucked up.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- prodigal_erik 14y agoNon-anonymous passive sharing discourages curiosity and experimentation by giving them boundless potential for embarrassment. It's hard to imagine worse long-term damage to users' humanity.
- jonathansizz 14y agoI don't really understand why someone who has knowledge worth sharing would just give it away to a private entity like Quora who will then make money off your contributions. If you do want to share knowledge for free (which is of course laudable), there are plenty of other large, well-established websites that are free and open and will remain so in the future. Or you could just set up a personal/community website of your own.
- chefsurfing 14y agoRecent changes that Quora has made to their interface ( several UI dark patterns implemented to get people to automatically share / integrate with FB / Twitter ) as well as this move of hiding answers makes me believe that they are desperate, not confident. I had high hopes for Quora from the beginning but have been continually let down to the point where Quora seems like ExpertsExchange 2.0 now.
- january14n 14y agoHate this update from them. I think what have they done was a EPIC Fail in their part.