5 ms·
Wine Releases Framework Mono 6.14 in Taking over the Mono Project
- LorenDB 2y agoI'm not sure whether to interpret Microsoft's donation of the project as a good or bad thing. Yes, they have given it a home under a project that is not driven by corporate whims*, but doesn't that then recuse Microsoft from any responsibility of contributing? *Yes, Wine is heavily developed by CodeWeavers, but CodeWeavers exists largely to help fund and support Wine.
- hdjrudni 2y agoI haven't been following .NET lately, but AFAIK .NET works on Linux now and "Mono" is basically .NET for Linux... what even are the differences? Sounds like Microsoft just doesn't want to maintain 2 different versions so they're dumping it. Also, > Microsoft became the steward of the Mono Project when it acquired Xamarin in 2016 They probably never even wanted Mono, they just inherited it because they wanted Xamarin.... which they've also killed now according to https://dotnet.microsoft.com/en-us/apps/xamarin https://dotnet.microsoft.com/en-us/apps/xamarin
- filleokus 2y ago"Modern" .NET (previously ".NET Core" v1, v2, v3 - but now just ".NET" v6, v7, v8, v9) works really well on Linux and in containers etc. "Legacy" .NET, .NET Framework, version 4.X, does not. If you build something new today in .NET land you are using a version that is compatible out of the box with linux, but there's gazillions of LOC .NET Framework out in enterprises that have yet not been migrated/rewritten. But I don't actually know if Mono is stable enough to run Framework services on Linux? I don't know how (if at all) Kudu is related to Mono, but on Azure you can run .NET Framework in e.g App Services (which uses Kudo under the hood). It's probably the only way to host a Framework service outside of IIS on a Windows VM. And Kudo contains references to Mono, and looks really linuxy when I've used it.
- chucky_z 2y agoIt 100% is! I've used Mono years ago to run older .net in VMs and containers. I found a single service that didn't really work well and we spent our time working on that instead of rewriting the world.
- metadat 2y agoCan you provide any details on what did and did not work well in V4 that was different afterwards?
- drpossum 2y ago> If you build something new today in .NET land you are using a version that is compatible out of the box with linux This is not a generally true statement, particularly with anything involving UI. WPF or anything modern WinForms are not supported. MAUI has no official Linux support.
- neonsunset 2y agoAnd neither is recommended to be used over AvaloniaUI (or Uno, or Gir.Core if you want to target just Linux), which supports it. Given the amount of whining about Linux GUI support despite good and proven solutions being provided, it leaves me with an impression some parts of Linux community actually don't want support at all and the goal is to have a convenient scapegoat to complain about.
- filleokus 2y agoYeah sorry, I'm too focused on backend services.
- simion314 2y ago>I haven't been following .NET lately, but AFAIK .NET works on Linux now and "Mono" is basically .NET for Linux... what even are the differences? Mono implements the GUI stuff like WinForms Microsoft .Net for Linux /cross platform has no GUI or maybe they added some new GUI now , I am not a .Net dev ,I know they were experimenting always with latest and greatest GUI stuff and failing to get traction.
- jabl 2y agoI don't actually think mono ever implemented cross-platform versions of the various GUI libraries. There was/is Gtk#, a binding to the Gtk GUI library, which was used for a few Linux apps.
- debugnik 2y agoMono did implement WinForms, and they separately worked on a Silverlight implementation.
- whoisthemachine 2y ago> I haven't been following .NET lately, but AFAIK .NET works on Linux now and "Mono" is basically .NET for Linux... what even are the differences? Ideally few, but I think it is a good thing to have a separate implementation of the dotnet runtime as an insurance policy against the main contributor to dotnet.
- zem 2y agowhy should microsoft have any responsibility to contribute to mono? they've done their bit in handing the project over to winehq.
- hyperbrainer 2y agoThis is exactly the kind of argument that leads to projects decaying. Not saying that WINE will let that happen, but without contributions, it is hard to develop, maintain and upgrade codebases the size of Mono.
- zem 2y agoi'm not saying mono doesn't need contributions, i'm saying that microsoft in particular has no real reason to contribute to it. it's not part of their .net strategy in any way, and it wasn't even their project to begin with.
- mdaniel 2y agoI wondered if the headline author had a stroke, but reading the article body confirmed that the whole .NET ecosystem has collectively had a stroke > "Framework Mono is the project previously hosted at https://github.com/mono/mono https://github.com/mono/mono, which was then simply called Mono. I have made this change to distinguish it from "monovm" and "Wine Mono", which are different projects. Framework Mono is a cross-platform runtime compatible with .NET Framework." They just needed to toss in some miscellaneous "Core" and "ECMA" to complete the version/platform/release word salad Anyway, if someone else was similarly confused it seems to be > Wine, who have taken over the Mono Project, released "Framework Mono" v6.14
- neonsunset 2y ago[flagged]
- metadat 2y agoAre you attempting a subtle dig, or what is the purpose of this comment? EDIT: The original comment read, before edits: > Do you program exclusively in Java?
- neonsunset 2y ago[flagged]
- cobbal 2y agoMicrosoft has a habit of naming similar (or not) things the same as each other. VS and VS Code; Powershell and Windows Powershell; Copilot and Github Copilot; Azure, Azure DevOps, and probably other Azure things. I'm not sure what internal incentives in the company lead to such terrible naming practices.
- mdaniel 2y agoOh then it's even worse than I knew: I had no idea there was Windows Powershell, too, and had (evidently erroneously?) through they just renamed Copilot to GitHub Copilot
- replete 2y agoThis is relevant for running .NET 4.x apps on Linux or Mac. .NET 5+ is dotnet core, so mono is still relevant here.
- kristianp 2y ago"This is the first release of Framework Mono from its new home at Winehq. It includes work from the past 5 years that was never included in a stable release because no stable branch had been created in that time. Highlights are native support for ARM64 on macOS and many improvements to windows forms for X11." Sounds like a way to port an old Windows Forms app to mac and linux.
- lionkor 2y agoNot port, but you can just run them on wine and they run fine, most of the time.
- terminalbraid 2y ago> Sounds like a way to port an old Windows Forms app to mac and linux. Mono only supports up to Winforms 2.0. It's typically not been great on porting Windows UI support in the very few places it even exists. https://www.mono-project.com/docs/gui/winforms/ https://www.mono-project.com/docs/gui/winforms/
- zombot 2y ago> native support for ARM64 on macOS I'm still missing x64 support on macOS in Wineskin.
- xmichael909 2y agoShould have called it "Mono Framework"