Not in academia— I’m curious but not invested. > “I formed the opinion that I shouldn’t use this paper as a building block in my research. […] However, my advi

Not in academia— I’m curious but not invested. > “I formed the opinion that I shouldn’t use this paper as a building block in my research. […] However, my advisor had a different view…” > “…scientific criticism of a published paper had no place in a dissertation…” Are these dissertation catechism? Or clash of personalities?