3 ms·
> Freedom of speech would suggest that I could be pro-Hamas if I wanted to be Short answer, yes [1]. The First Amendment prohibits the Congress from passing a
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> Freedom of speech would suggest that I could be pro-Hamas if I wanted to be
Short answer, yes [1]. The First Amendment prohibits the Congress from passing a law that abridges the freedom of speech. There is no visa exception. That would make such visa terminations unlawful. (If a student on a visa got themselves arrested, that’s a separate matter.)
On a strategic level, this should give us hope. Trump is back to his first term arrogance and chaos. If State had moved quietly and decisively, damage could have been done before it was too late. The Palestinian cause is only a little bit more popular than USAID; in the end, there wouldn’t have been a broad fight. Instead, they got caught by Axios [2]. So we can get injunctions ex ante.
[1] https://oiss.yale.edu/campus-community-life/for-students/legal-considerations/know-your-rights/participating-in-a-protest-know-your-rights-and-risks https://oiss.yale.edu/campus-community-life/for-students/leg...
[2] https://www.axios.com/2025/03/06/state-department-ai-revoke-foreign-student-visas-hamas https://www.axios.com/2025/03/06/state-department-ai-revoke-...
- pianom4n 2y agoNothing on that page supports what your claim. In reality even permanent residents could be deported for what would be 1st Amendment protected activity for citizens. In Harisiades v. Shaughnessy the deportation of legal residents for membership in the Communist party was upheld as Constitutional. This hasn't been overturned or narrowed and remains good law today. Whether current immigration law allows for this I don't know, but this isn't a 1st Amendment issue based on current precedent.