3 ms·
I haven't encountered the hierarchy in years, but I've always felt it was a bit of a weird idea. The first and third tiers (elimination and controls) are the s
by AlotOfReading 2y ago
I haven't encountered the hierarchy in years, but I've always felt it was a bit of a weird idea.
The first and third tiers (elimination and controls) are the same thing: separating the hazard from potential injury conditions. This can be spatial separation, temporal separation, or a dozen other kinds. A real-world example is how xray techs have to physically leave the exposure area and stand behind a lead panel to turn on the beam. The hazard (radiation exposure) remains, but the system is safe because the tech can't be exposed to it. We use this all the time in software. Process boundaries are a form of spatial separation, mutexes enforce temporal separation. test/prod systems, principle of least privilege, separation of concerns, etc.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kvmet 2y agoElimination is not the same as separating someone from the hazard. Edit: elimination is (re)moving the hazard and a control is adding a barrier or moving the person Elimination is completely getting rid of the hazard. (In the case of x-ray it would be just not doing an x-ray at all)
- eternityforest 2y agoControls can fail. Tanks of toxic waste can leak. Toxic waste that doesn't exist is much safer, assuming its not needed to prevent danger elsewhere.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoThey end up looking very similar in your FMEA or fault tree analysis.