4 ms·
Another way to look at this: it's a well-known phenomenon that expert radiologists will misdiagnose an X-ray image, even contradicting a past judgment they made
by danso 14y ago
Another way to look at this: it's a well-known phenomenon that expert radiologists will misdiagnose an X-ray image, even contradicting a past judgment they made on the same X-ray. It's feasible that a properly machine-learned computer could make better judgments on a long-running average basis.
But when a computer screws up an edge case, versus the many, many times a doctor will screw up a diagnosis, which instance will get more attention. People are scared of black box machines and will take particular note of the times an algorithm has screwed them over, regardless of the times a human has screwed them up.
Also, when the possibility of examination exists, computerized decision making is far, far easier to audit (i.e. determine blame)
- jlgreco 14y agoExactly. It is the same as the problem with robotic cars. Cars with human drivers kill thousands, but nobody blinks. The day a robotic car kills a single person, all the news networks will have a field day.
- mc32 14y agoI think you're right about this. Maybe it has to do with appearance of control/self determination. It was a mistake (an accident), but it was my mistake/accident (as opposed to something one didn't have control over).
- laserDinosaur 14y agoI once posited the question to a group of friends, would you rather drive a car with a 60% chance of crashing fatally in your lifetime, or use a robotic car that as a 2% failure rate. Everyone chose the 60%, even though statistically it makes absolutely no sense.