6 ms·
I don't really get the outrage. Is there some moral or legal obligation that a service's price must tie directly to its immediate costs? Netflix charges me the
by eli 14y ago
I don't really get the outrage. Is there some moral or legal obligation that a service's price must tie directly to its immediate costs?
Netflix charges me the same monthly fee whether I use it or not, is that fair? After all, on their end they only pay license holders per-stream (AFAIK).
- Pwntastic 14y agoWell Verizon will also charge you regardless of whether or not you actually use all of your allotted data. The difference here is that they'd also like to charge you a second time to let you use your allotted data in different ways.
- eli 14y agoThis is just how they decided to segment the market. Would it be less offensive if they let you use whatever devices you want, but charged per MB because that kinda sorta mirrors their costs better? Why does that matter? You aren't paying twice for the same thing because the normal data plan explicitly didn't allow tethering.
- davorak 14y agoHypothetical: Let say the local water company has a flat rate of $30 a month as long as you do not use more then 50 liters of water and then a reasonable rate for every liter after that. However there is an additional fee if you want to use that water to water you lawn, it costs an extra $30 a month to have the water directed to the lawn. However when industrious home owners decides to water their lawn by hand from sink water and avoid the extra $30 dollars a month the water company cuts their service. Do you have a problem with the water company segmenting their market in this fashion?
- eli 14y agoI don't think that's a good idea (seems like it would be awfully hard to implement), but I don't think it's immoral or unethical. Adobe Photoshop is available to college students at a deep discount. Hobbyists who are not in school have to pay more for the exact same product. That's a little uncool, but is it unethical?
- Karunamon 14y agoHonestly, all "hobbyists" I know who want to use Photoshop that badly just pirate it. Talk about overpriced...
- Karunamon 14y ago>You aren't paying twice for the same thing because the normal data plan explicitly didn't allow tethering. Which is a completely artificial and needless distinction. The phones have the necessary hardware and software and have for years. And that's where the outrage comes from - there is no difference between 5gb transferred over a tethered device and 5gb transferred over the device natively. They're double dipping. Adding no value and expecting more money for it. And everyone knows it. This might even be remotely acceptable if the wireless marketplace were in the least bit open. It is not. I can't possibly be the only person to notice that the major carriers plans are almost mirror images of each other.
- rm999 14y ago>Is there some moral or legal obligation that a service's price must tie directly to its immediate costs? No, but in a competitive market we would expect it to because competitors will lower their prices in line with their costs to stay in business. At least, that's the theory. When you have companies competing on who can charge the most you have an indication that there is a lack of real competition.
- w1ntermute 14y ago> Is there some moral or legal obligation that a service's price must tie directly to its immediate costs? Yes. Verizon and other wireless telecoms have built their businesses on the back of a limited, public resource (namely, wireless spectrum) leased from the government (and therefore the people) of the United States. Therefore, they have a moral (should also be legal, but isn't at the moment) responsibility to act in an ethical manner. If this were a market without such barriers to entry, I would say that they're free to do whatever they want, because competitors would enter the market and force them to change their policies. But when it comes to wireless telecoms, it's not possible for such competitors to materialize.
- eli 14y agoWhat is unethical about segmenting customers based on the devices they use? Would it be better to do away with all forms of "unlimited" plans and just charge per MB?
- w1ntermute 14y agoUnlimited plans have already been done away with by everyone except Sprint. What's at issue here is them charging extra for data bought by the byte. I believe that you should be able to purchase data and share it amongst as many devices as you want (a small activation fee per cellular device may be acceptable, but nothing of the sort should exist for tethering, since there is no perceptible difference for the carriers) . This is how it works for wired internet, and I don't see why wireless should be any different (with the exception of any wireless specific network management, but that's not at issue here).
- mindslight 14y agoNo, the moral and jurisdictional obligation is for a service to avoid sticking their nose into unrelated business to extract more value. Gas stations don't demand a percentage of your salary for using their gas to drive to work. Communications has long had the concept of a demarcation point, it's unfortunate that we've got to be hassled while the carriers avoid rediscovering it.