3 ms·
I don't think taking a stand against making giant technology companies (that people generally don't like much) work to combat revenge porn (which literally ever
by tptacek 2y ago
I don't think taking a stand against making giant technology companies (that people generally don't like much) work to combat revenge porn (which literally everybody finds revolting) is going to be the political winner this Verge editorial thinks it will be.
Especially annoying: the "no matter how carefully crafted the bill is" framing, which not only makes the argument non-falsifiable, but also cuts off discussion rooted in what the bill actually says and ensures that we're going to stay fixed in the orbit of a pointless ideological debate.
- whatshisface 2y agoThe issue is that you can justify overturning any part of our liberal democracy by finding one example of abuse. For example, "We should institute a federal board of candidacy to keep all these corrupt politicians off the ballot." "We should allow the state governor to have an un-pardon, to send criminals like OJ Simpson to jail even after they get off on a technicality." "We should allow police to search your person without a warrant if they won't be able to find you later on."
- echelon 2y agoIf someone claims you posted porn of them, do you think the giant company is going to take the time, money, and resources to give you the benefit of the doubt and investigate? Or are they simply going to ban your account with no recourse? The DMCA and copyright strikes don't work correctly and are rife with abuse. I definitely don't expect this to work as intended, either.
- ceejayoz 2y agoTrump was pretty open about his desire to use it for other stuff. > "And I’m going to use that bill for myself too if you don’t mind, because nobody gets treated worse than I do online, nobody."
- echelon 2y agoSo one law invalidates artistic parody and triumphs over free speech? All that Beeple Trump art just became illegal.
- dylan604 2y agoThe problem is that you have POTUS announcing his intent on using this in a deliberate way not as you describe so he can go after people saying things about him he does not like. Whatever you wanted to say about the law, its true intent was made clear when he said the quiet part out loud on national television
- Terr_ 2y agoDo you like DMCA abuse? [0] This is the same problem. [0] https://www.eff.org/takedowns https://www.eff.org/takedowns