3 ms·
Fasting appears in many of the world's religions. I'm curious about the roots of fasting that have been codified into religious practice. Did the ancients disco
by jgrahamc 14y ago
Fasting appears in many of the world's religions. I'm curious about the roots of fasting that have been codified into religious practice. Did the ancients discover that fasting was good for you?
- stephengillie 14y agoMaybe it was a way to get people to ration food over winter?
- icebraining 14y agoThe fact that it was popular doesn't mean it was good. Bloodletting was an extremely popular practice too, but it's now a consensus that's it's harmful except in very specific situations.
- philbarr 14y agoAlthough people did bloodletting because they thought it was good for you.
- mhd 14y agoNo, they saw that hunger is bad and nobody would want to go hungry voluntarily. Suffering for your faith, mortification of the flesh, self-flagellation, etc. Certainly not a "Diet secret of the ancients", some beneficial side-effects are mostly accidental. (And to be honest, going hungry wasn't exactly hard throughout most history.) But, well, we've got pretty deent beer out of it.
- ramblerman 14y agoThere are definitly modern (non religious) proponents that argue fasting <=20 hours has it's health benefits. Even buff fitness gurus. But abstaining from water as well is not recommended. At least not in any material I've seen.
- adrianwaj 14y agoGood question. I think it's a hack: on the one hand it supposedly frees up energy from digestion to concentrate on prayer or repentance, on the other hand I don't feel the thinking is as deep: it locks one into a survival mode thinking - which may or may not help the spiritual practice. Like driving when tired: only the needed parts of the brain that are required switch on. So concentration improves, but the thinking is not as deep (that is when hunger pangs don't distract!) Supposedly fasting also promotes longevity by affecting gene expression, and the same effects can be obtained from resveratrol. Additionally, small fasts are meant boost human growth hormone, hence the warrior diet: only eating at night. Fasting before and after exercise boosts it the most. A doctor I once knew said the reason they put new doctors on such long shifts is so they stop thinking and behave more according to text book. Anyhow, check out this article/podcast about a fasting, and in particular regarding someone grossly obese for 1 year and 17 days: http://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2012/07/24/3549931.htm http://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2012/07/24/3549931.ht... "His weight dropped from 207 kilograms to 82 kilograms. Some five years later, he had regained only 7 kilograms." I wonder how mentally active he was during that time.