8 ms·
The necessity of Nussbaum
- readthenotes1 2y ago[flagged]
- eightysixfour 2y ago> Anytime someone talks about social rights, I always get worried because social rights are nothing more than obligations on the rest of us to provide or allow the one with the right. We may have different definitions of social rights then. Often society can imbue someone with a right that has no obligation on anyone else at all, other than not to violate that right, which I am happy to empower a democratic government to defend.
- readthenotes1 2y ago"other than not to violate that right," we do not have the definitions of social rights then. What we may have, is a different experience with people who will violate other people's "rights" through either inattention or malice. We also have cases where "rights" collide because of cultural differences (e.g., you may feel that you have the right to make fun of my religious figure and I feel that I have the right to decapitate you for doing so)
- ForTheKidz 2y agoI personally view social obligations as part of the cost of living in a modern society. Without that obligation it's quite hard to realize most benefits civilization can offer. Power is not exactly something you can opt out of having to deal with.
- lern_too_spel 2y agoOne of those social obligations required to be able to benefit from living in society is to ensure good governance. This part is often left out, providing fuel for nonsensical anarchist and libertarian arguments.
- eightysixfour 2y ago> This part is often left out, providing fuel for nonsensical anarchist and libertarian arguments. It is my perspective that, since you do not choose the society you are born into (including the rights it grants you and the obligations it imposes on you) that the only justifiable system of power is one that you can influence and change. However, you can reject this framing early on. You can make an argument that, since you do not choose the society you are born into, there is no justifiable moral argument in having other's decisions about rights and obligations imposed upon you. This leaves plenty of room for anarchist and libertarian arguments, even if the outcomes would be worse in every other way, and even if this way of life could only exist for short periods before those who have chosen to organize systems of power eradicate it. For those who have landed on this argument, there is no moral or just universe which gives someone else power over them.
- lern_too_spel 2y ago> You can make an argument that, since you do not choose the society you are born into, there is no justifiable moral argument in having other's decisions about rights and obligations imposed upon you. You do not choose to be born, so that argument is nonsensical on its face and leads to absurd antinatalist conclusions. Instead, each person should work to their own benefit. You can benefit more by living in a society than by living on your own as long as you set up society in such a way that you benefit from it instead of suffer from it. That means accounting for externalities, preventing abuse of power, raising the next generation to also be civically minded, the whole nine yards.
- eightysixfour 2y ago> You do not choose to be born, so that argument is nonsensical on its face and leads to absurd antinatalist conclusions. I don't agree with this - you can accept existence as a fact (the universe, your birth, the scale doesn't matter) and that giving birth to another person is morally good or, at worst, morally neutral, without any impact whatsoever on the argument. Or, put simply, these two things can be true simultaneously: * I am alive, and this is good. * The history of humanity and my society places constraints on me, which I do not agree with, and gives me rights, which I do not value, and this is bad. However, we may come to an impasse, as I don't find "taken to its logical conclusion" arguments, or the paradoxes they can impose, to be particularly persuasive. > You can benefit more by living in a society than by living on your own I agree with this, however there is a mountain of assumptions under this statement which could be argued infinitely. Even if we accept it as true... > as long as you set up society in such a way that you benefit from it instead of suffer from it. That means accounting for externalities, preventing abuse of power, raising the next generation to also be civically minded, the whole nine yards. ... it is a rational/reasonable argument that what you just described is impossible, and we end up back somewhere near the beginning. Simplified (a lot): * I am alive, and this is good. * I live in a society, which is good. * Society is unjust and unfair, which is bad. * It cannot be made just and fair, which is bad. * Thus I should be able to leave without relinquishing my existence.
- osivertsson 2y ago> social rights are nothing more than obligations on the rest of us I don’t agree here. It is not a zero sum game, everyone can win with social rights. I have read some Bertrand Russel, albeit many years ago now, and from what I remember he certainly did not argue against social rights, on the contrary. Do you have a reference to work by Bertrand Russel that argues for your point?
- rytill 2y agoSo, your argument (ignoring the appeal to authority) is: 1.Social rights can be reduced entirely to obligations on others. Dubious. Ignoring that maybe the value to the person granted the social right could outweigh the obligation to others, or that the holistic effect on the system might be greater than its reduced parts. 2. Social rights need to be enforced by those with power. 3. Supporting and legitimizing social rights means supporting and legitimizing a specific source of power that will enforce them. The jump from 2 to 3 is not entirely clear to me. I think it's a valid stance to be critical, and even unsupportive of any given source of power enforcing social rights, while being fully supportive of the right itself. 4. The ones who end up in positions of power are the most ruthless and power-hungry. 5. Those people being in positions of power is so bad that it outweighs any benefit from the original cause, 1 + 2. Overall, I'd say the critical flaw of your argument is that it's too reductive and assumes that everything very neatly follows linear, simple paths of power. In addition, I think you can replace the "social rights" in point 2 with any law, and you will have the same points 3, 4, and 5.
- readthenotes1 2y agoI have had to interact with more than a few predators (socio/psychopaths) so make sure to incorporate them into your responses. Also, be sure to include people with different cultural values when you are working through this. 1. List me some social rights that do not require other people to honor their existence. 2. Because there will be people who do not honor other people's rights, how would you try to get them to do so? There are, afaik, no "unalienable rights" recognized across all human societies and all members therein--if you can provide some, not just aspirational, I'd love to be corrected. 3. You actually use the word "legitimizing". Who codifies and enforces laws? Who informs, persuades, coerces people to honor other people's rights, the laws explicating the consequences of those rights and the punishments for infringement? Who restrains or removes the recalcitrant from harming the rest of society? 5. The concern of how much power we have to relinquish to powerful people to support the N+1 right is the question. 0a. You missed the biggest flaw in my analysis in that I did not show that there is a correlation between the number of rights/obligations and the power given to an executive to enforce them. If just honoring one social right requires power concentration, how much more power is required for allowing other social rights? 0b. Is there a way to restrain the power of the executive enforcing social rights so that they do not have enough power to dishonor them themselves? -- your last point about replacing social rights with laws is spot on. One good purpose for laws is to support social rights. Once we have laws, we have to have policing and courts and punishment and rehabilitation. We will also have lawmakers and lobbyists because the law is never in final release.
- justonceokay 2y agoI think social rights are great. I’m glad I don’t live in the 70s when I could be jailed for being gay. But I also feel like this is all bunk. As soon as the government takes control of something it must be quantified and standardized. It immediately turns abstract goals like “increase opportunity for poor children” into easily tracked and digestible goals like increasing test scores or spending more money. Let’s be honest, the reason that being gay legal today is not because the government enforced it. It’s because the opinion of the populace changed over time and the government had to capitulate. In the same way I feel like social change of other kinds cannot be top-down from the government. If they can barely be trusted to fill potholes why should I expect they would successfully foment complex social changes?
- fads_go 2y ago>As soon as the government takes control of something it must be quantified and standardized. It immediately turns abstract goals like “increase opportunity for poor children” into easily tracked and digestible goals like increasing test scores or spending more money. Title IX would like to have a word with you. This prohibited sex discrimination in education and athletics, which enabled womens sports among other things. The drive for easily tracked goals is not inherent in government, it is an artifact of current political process.
- eightysixfour 2y ago> The drive for easily tracked goals is not inherent in government, it is an artifact of current political process. While I agree with your intent, I think this is incorrect. The need to quantize things is inherent in taking power over them - via government, corporate management, community groups, whatever. A large section of humanity's challenges can be translated back to what we choose to measure, how we measure it, when we measure it, what goals we set for it, etc. It is why we argue over statistical "facts" so much. Seeing Like a State is a great book diving into this topic if you haven't read it. It diverts into a more depressing view of government efforts, but I have yet to find a good refutation of this particular topic, although I would be pleased to encounter one.
- 2y ago
- behnamoh 2y ago[flagged]
- richardanaya 2y ago[flagged]
- mikrl 2y agoWell there was that small matter of Nietzsche being taken out of context by his sister that directly contributed to the “world remaking” aspects of totalitarian regimes of the 20th century. Even your viewpoint that a life should be spent creatively “doing” rather than eg farming and praising God, is a direct outgrowth of Nietzschean philosophy.
- dcre 2y agoEmbarrassingly ignorant take. The greatest scientists were themselves philosophers.
- behnamoh 2y agoThat doesn't imply philosophy LED to scientific discoveries; rather it was a post-hoc consequence of said discoveries.
- dcre 2y agoThey were done at the same time and they are not in such a simple causal relationship. Try thinking and learning instead of trying to come up with arguments for claims you've already decided are right.
- behnamoh 2y agoI've read several books on history of science. in none of them did a scientist started with a philosophical idea which resulted in scientific discovery. it's always the opposite. e.g., quantum mechanics was the result of physics thinking, but the philosophical take came after that.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- usixk 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- richardanaya 2y ago[flagged]
- dcre 2y agoRidiculous read on what is fundamentally an anti-authoritarian philosophy. Read John Stuart Mill, one of Nussbaum's biggest influences (unfortunately not mentioned in the article).
- richardanaya 2y agoWhat's Nussbaum's take on people who say "no" to have their property taken for other's use?
- justonceokay 2y agoWhere is that happening? Unless you are talking about taxes, which are only yours if you believe that you made that (government-supplied!) money by yourself without infrastructure like plumbing, roads, schools and hospitals to educate and heal your employees, a strong legal system to enforce property rights…
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoJust look at corporations. Nearly everyone who has gotten insanely wealthy in the US in the last 100 years or so has done so through a corporation, or some other liability-protection business structure. These business formations are nothing more than government-provided, and government-enforced, fictions.
- justonceokay 2y agoTrue. Without the understanding of the judicial system that a corporation is more than the sum of its parts it would be much easier to directly litigate against company execs.
- 2y ago
- Starlord2048 2y agoWhen we talk about making AI safer, we often slide into paternalistic frames where we dictate outcomes rather than enabling capabilities with appropriate guardrails. The distinction she makes between providing capabilities and forcing functions seems critical. I'm curious if anyone has explored applying Nussbaum's theory directly to AI development frameworks. What would her capabilities list look like for artificial intelligence? Could this be a more productive framework than current alignment approaches?
- supriyo-biswas 2y agoBased on your recent post history where you consider some issue X, its negation, and then ask a question with “I’m curious if…”, these seem to be LLM generated. In which case: please don’t post that here.
- Carrok 2y agoThis is such a strange comment. The parent has used that phrase in a _few_ of their comments, but not all. People sometimes re-use phrases in their speech. Please don't post unsubstantiated accusations here.
- munchler 2y ago> It is the task of governments to provide citizens with capabilities to flourish. > Nussbaum wants to establish the capabilities as rights to which citizens, in all nations, are entitled This is such a blatantly big-L Liberal political position, that I have to laugh, even as a liberal myself. Pretending this is philosophy rather than policy seems a bit silly. Personally, I think it makes more sense to frame these "capabilities" as benefits rather than rights. For example, do all people have a right to health care? No, because, in the extreme, it leads to logical contradictions with other rights. (E.g. Doctors being forced to provide care at gunpoint.) However, it makes perfect sense as a benefit that a wealthy government decides to provide for its citizens.
- nathan_compton 2y agoI'm frankly suspicious of the framing of human relations in terms of rights for a few reasons, the first and most important of which is that rights are imaginary things that never actually intercede in the world to make anything happen. Rights are always enforced/protected by human beings who also conceived of them. From this point of view believing in the God of Thunder is more reasonable than believing in "the right to bodily autonomy" because at least sometimes we actually hear thunder. But furthermore, the framing of rights seems pretty flimsy. Some people like to assert that rights are god given, but people can neither agree whether god exists nor what rights any particular god would "give" if so, and so for a political body that wishes to confine itself to that which is collectively plausible, the only justification for rights left is that they promote the common good. But if that is the case, then we ought to be open to any sort of thing which promotes the common good and the discussion of negative or positive rights seems at best a useful shorthand for certain perspectives. In practice rights are just whatever the masses can demand from the powerful and while it might be the case that imagining that they are god given or obvious in their nature is helpful from a like propagandist point of view, as a person who prefers to think clearly, I can't countenance the self delusion.
- sprucevoid 2y agoLegal rights can be seen as especially strong claims, with implications and interactions to be further specified in laws and regulation. What alternative do you think would be more useful arrange human relations, if not literally appeals to the God of Thunder?
- alexbecker 2y agoAfter reading Judith Butler for a class in college, reading "Professor of Parody" was such a breath of fresh air. Nussbaum is a clear thinker who doesn't take BS kindly.
- scythe 2y agoContext: https://newrepublic.com/article/150687/professor-parody https://newrepublic.com/article/150687/professor-parody
- tehjoker 2y agoReally good article. There is a whole cast of philosophical characters that have been supported because they provide a non-materialist subversive, yet directionless, politics that go no-where, great for capitalism. Some of them were even directly supported by the CIA. This is in part why politics is so empty today, the post-modernists won and call you names for wanting peace, real life choices, control over your work life, health care, etc while also not actually advancing the cause of equality among the different divisions of the working class beyond spoken words.
- sevensor 2y agoI thought this bit was particularly perceptive and foreshadows the situation in which we now find ourselves: > Indeed, Butler’s naively empty politics is especially dangerous for the very causes she holds dear. For every friend of Butler, eager to engage in subversive performances that proclaim the repressiveness of heterosexual gender norms, there are dozens who would like to engage in subversive performances that flout the norms of tax compliance, of non-discrimination, of decent treatment of one’s fellow students. To such people we should say, you cannot simply resist as you please, for there are norms of fairness, decency, and dignity that entail that this is bad behavior.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tmsh 2y agowhat if the capabilities are evolving due to the tools evolving and so the bedrock is not fixed?
- ryan_j_naughton 2y agoI took a class by Martha Nussbaum when I was 18 years old. It was a graduate ancient philosophy class on Sophocles' Philoctetes. I had idolized Nussbaum as one of the great minds of our time and leap at the opportunity to learn from her. I remember having to get her permission to take the class as it was for philosophy and classics grad students, but she agreed. It was like drinking from the firehose, but it really ignited my dedication to studying the classics in college, for which I am immensely grateful. She is such a quick mind.
- penguin_booze 2y agoThe BBC programme: https://youtu.be/pJC9o3bpujI?list=PLhP9EhPApKE8B-g03RivIMt7llh1cyEGV https://youtu.be/pJC9o3bpujI?list=PLhP9EhPApKE8B-g03RivIMt7l....
- gsf_emergency_2 2y ago>Another difference between Sen and Nussbaum is that for Nussbaum the notion of reaching a threshold is more important than full capability. seems like the framework might be on the verge of being amenable to a compiler/program-behavior-style analysis
- 082349872349872 2y agosuch an analysis is normally a fixpoint over the control flow graph; what structure would we be taking the fixpoint over in the Sen/Nussbaum case? (non-sequitur) did you see https://protocolized.summerofprotocols.com/p/strange-new-rules https://protocolized.summerofprotocols.com/p/strange-new-rul... ?
- gsf_emergency_2 2y ago(welcome back!) Didn't see it. I'm a bigger follower of geohot (these days! sorry!) but this does look far more interesting. Scheduled for an imminent read! Lacking the training/experience/talent for things like this I can now only proceed by vague analogy (work on this one and off if I don't get it quite right? Thanks!): (Fixed points are analogous to steady states?) (Even nonequilibrium,societal ones would be kind of mediocre imho, (sorry nis0s!)) it would be analogous to a diagram of (estimated likelihood(s) of progress on your favourite heuristic ) vs (memory allocated currently, or more generally, tuples of those 10 historical CA-related variables together with their estimated relevance towards progress) on every subheuristic? (I'm trying to introduce probabilities to (sigma algebraize?) the program representation)
- gsf_emergency_2 2y ago(n-s: the source of my attempted analog : https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~aldrich/courses/15-819O-13sp/resources/dataflow-frameworks.pdf https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~aldrich/courses/15-819O-13sp/resourc... A concise few pages worth drowning in! (For me)) (p-s: 2 "repulsive fixed-points" of 2 messianics of interest: PG: the anti-prig Thiel: the protocolizer as chief optimist/protocolization creditor/secretary of the politburo ) (p-p-s, from the comments: Henry VIII as designer of new kinds of windmills, would have been awesome snack if that checks out, roughly on par with Lawrence of A coming up with a new jet engine)
- nis0s 2y agoMy first inclination is to agree with the idea that all humans have a right to flourish because I would like everyone to have self-determined and self-acquired means to actualization. However, what’s the upper bound on demands made for flourishing if that aspect is codified as a right? I think a more tractable and practical approach in policymaking for determining a set of rights is to codify a set of “disablers” as opposed to a set of enablers. The universality of such rights notwithstanding, I find it highly inappropriate that the government should be involved in enabling human flourishing outside of ensuring basic human rights. I find this inappropriate because I think actualization of the self is a highly private and individualized matter, whereas the domain of the government is to implement broad and pan-applicable policies. The caveat is that as society gets more complex, so do the basic human rights which need to be ensured to enable productive participation in that society. Everyone needs internet access to participate in a digital economy, for instance. While I appreciate the thoughtfulness towards an approach to emotional moral philosophy, I think that an emphasis on using emotions as a guide for navigating morals and ethics precludes the judgment needed for seeking a moral truth which may counter an emotional truth. I guess I am unconvinced that there is any necessity at all in imposing emotional guides on morals and ethics, but I do like the list of the ten points that are mentioned—it’s easy enough to imagine how each of those can be stretched to some absurd scenario where governments say-so in those scenarios becomes Orwellian.
- genewitch 2y ago> The universality of such rights notwithstanding, I find it highly inappropriate that the government should be involved in enabling human flourishing outside of ensuring basic human rights. Which rights are "basic human rights?" Can you enumerate them? You typed a lot of words but you left this open for interpretation. Is it because there is no "universality" of rights? For example, clean water? Clean food? Access to clean medicine of verifiable quality and efficacy? Americans with disabilities act sort of rights? Privacy? Religion? Speech? Self defense? Against the government? Ability to bequeath property? Sexual congress? Suicide? To be left alone?
- vacuity 2y agoI say the right of any sentient agent is that it has a baseline of not deserving to suffer. Here, I like Peter Singer's presentation in "All Animals Are Equal". No one should be made to suffer or harmed in any way without an intervening harm of equal or greater significance to be prevented. If clean food can be gotten for everyone reasonably, then it is impermissible to be greedy or even lazy and not give out the food. If clean food is limited, distribute it such that suffering is minimized. Healthcare wasn't a thing in the time of the Mesopotamians, but now that we have healthcare, it should be provided in the way that minimizes suffering. Land property should not be restricted needlessly, but obviously having some private space is important, so land is still a more exhaustible resource. For acts like sex, suicide, and wanting to be left alone, there is a deep complexity as to informed and unpressured consent. All interaction and therefore anything relevant to rights-talk has a fundamental complexity around understanding another's circumstances and discrimination (as long as all agents are not treated exactly the same, this arises).