> So are you arguing [...] No, I have no issue with tax-funded police, firemen and roads; nor with equal protection under the law, or equal civil rights for al

> So are you arguing [...] No, I have no issue with tax-funded police, firemen and roads; nor with equal protection under the law, or equal civil rights for all citizens :-) But if you start to talk about "moving beyond individual generosity" I start to get the sense that you want to force me to be part of a TBD "collective generosity".