2 ms·
> I think the web itself could have been the platform. The web itself does not suggest new content. People really want novelty. They want a feed of new and in
by pjc50 2y ago
> I think the web itself could have been the platform.
The web itself does not suggest new content.
People really want novelty. They want a feed of new and interesting stuff, without having to make too much curatorial effort of their own. So there's been generations of "link aggregator" sites: slashdot, k5, digg, reddit, HN itself. As well as that being a key part of twitter and now bluesky use. Providing a feed is also crucial to youtube and TikTok - the recommendation algorithm for TikTok is ultimately what got it "banned" in the US, and then unbanned when they agreed to change the propaganda to something more favourable to Trump.
I use bluesky, but I'm not really optimistic about it any more. It's doomed by the all-consuming US news cycle.
- asimpletune 2y agoYes, I agree. Search/discovery was not something that was solved in a way that respected the commons. Probably the biggest hole in the 'web is the platform' model. Sometimes I wonder if something like PageRank could have been implemented in a more fundamental way, like DNS, for the public benefit. Anyways, I think if regulation had happened earlier then a lot of the things you mentioned would never have taken root. They should have just made it unprofitable to hoard and trade consumer data. The industry would have been so much better if the incentives required businesses to compete for consumer dollars.
- zahlman 2y ago> Sometimes I wonder if something like PageRank could have been implemented in a more fundamental way, like DNS, for the public benefit. I immediately thought of https://www.mywot.com https://www.mywot.com . I was surprised to see it still exists. Though not so surprised to see that it now asks you up top to > Connect with Google to scan your browsing history and see if you've been exposed to untrusted sites. Sigh.