3 ms·

Why would we have? It's pointless. As the GP said, land doesn't vote. The more interesting map is the one where you weight the display by population, since it

by kemayo 2y ago

Why would we have? It's pointless. As the GP said, land doesn't vote. The more interesting map is the one where you weight the display by population, since it gives a much more accurate representation of how the USA is divided: https://engaging-data.com/pages/scripts/d3Electoral/countyelection2.png https://engaging-data.com/pages/scripts/d3Electoral/countyel... The tool on that website is actually pretty informative to play with if you want to quickly see how adjusting the map style can change the perception. https://engaging-data.com/county-electoral-map-land-vs-population/ https://engaging-data.com/county-electoral-map-land-vs-popul...

verzali 2y ago
Bit of a tangent, but I've always wondered why the United States has a very clear dividing line between the populated east and relatively empty west. It's really visible in the first map you shared. Is there a historical reason behind that line? Or some geographical boundary?
- genewitch 2y ago
  My understanding, as an american, is that the Federal government "owns" most of the land west of either the Mississippi River or the Sabine. Or used to "own" it. So getting land for personal/business use in that geographic region is harder than eastward. I don't know the term of art, but it's like the Federal Government - via the BLM, USDA, USFS, or whatever - has right of first refusal for all land sales. I know that my understanding can be wrong, but this is what i've heard and perusing some maps bears out at least some validity.
- s1artibartfast 2y ago
  It is a function of both geography and history, both based on water. The line you are seeing in the east is the rain shadow of the Rocky mountains. Moving east from California, you have the great basin desert, followed by the Rocky Mountains, and then the relatively dry great plains. Population follows precipitation. https://gisgeography.com/us-precipitation-map/ https://gisgeography.com/us-precipitation-map/ https://www.thoughtco.com/geography-shapes-us-regional-weather-3444371 https://www.thoughtco.com/geography-shapes-us-regional-weath...
madcaptenor 2y ago
Not sure why I can't reply to the sibling comment... anyway, the reason for the east/west divide in population density is that the west is dry. See maps at climate.gov (https://www.climate.gov/news-features/featured-images/new-maps-annual-average-temperature-and-precipitation-us-climate https://www.climate.gov/news-features/featured-images/new-ma...). By convention people refer to this line as being at the "100th meridian" but the 98th may be more accurate.

by kemayo 2y ago

verzali 2y ago

Bit of a tangent, but I've always wondered why the United States has a very clear dividing line between the populated east and relatively empty west. It's really visible in the first map you shared. Is there a historical reason behind that line? Or some geographical boundary?

genewitch 2y ago
My understanding, as an american, is that the Federal government "owns" most of the land west of either the Mississippi River or the Sabine. Or used to "own" it. So getting land for personal/business use in that geographic region is harder than eastward. I don't know the term of art, but it's like the Federal Government - via the BLM, USDA, USFS, or whatever - has right of first refusal for all land sales. I know that my understanding can be wrong, but this is what i've heard and perusing some maps bears out at least some validity.
s1artibartfast 2y ago
It is a function of both geography and history, both based on water. The line you are seeing in the east is the rain shadow of the Rocky mountains. Moving east from California, you have the great basin desert, followed by the Rocky Mountains, and then the relatively dry great plains. Population follows precipitation. https://gisgeography.com/us-precipitation-map/ https://gisgeography.com/us-precipitation-map/ https://www.thoughtco.com/geography-shapes-us-regional-weather-3444371 https://www.thoughtco.com/geography-shapes-us-regional-weath...

madcaptenor 2y ago

Not sure why I can't reply to the sibling comment... anyway, the reason for the east/west divide in population density is that the west is dry. See maps at climate.gov (https://www.climate.gov/news-features/featured-images/new-maps-annual-average-temperature-and-precipitation-us-climate https://www.climate.gov/news-features/featured-images/new-ma...). By convention people refer to this line as being at the "100th meridian" but the 98th may be more accurate.