5 ms·
Study: The ozone hole is healing, thanks to global reduction of CFCs
- wtcactus 2y agoOf course that, as usual, this was due to the West taking the hit, and China continuing doing pollution as usual: https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-48353341.amp https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-48353341.amp Let’s hope that now that Europe needs to focus on more important issues, they stop hindering our productivity with environmental artificial limits so that China can keep increasing their pollutants and industry.
- jahnu 2y ago> the West taking the hit It’s not like the west didn’t benefit massively from it initially. Just like with carbon emissions where China will likely never emit as much as say the US will cumulatively, despite a much larger population too.
- yyyk 2y agoIn fairness China did crack down on that[0]. Some limits are excessive, but here the minor hit was worth it. [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03277-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03277-w https://www.dw.com/en/ozone-layer-recovery-back-on-track-after-china-slows-cfc-11-production/a-56540342 https://www.dw.com/en/ozone-layer-recovery-back-on-track-aft...
- WastedCucumber 2y agoThank you for posting this, this is a very important follow-up to the parent's linked paper. I'm a stratospheric scientist. Back when the reports were written, that CFC's were still being emitted in China, our community was pretty bummed and weren't very hopeful, but we were very happily surprised when China got those emmissions under control so quickly.
- cogman10 2y ago> they stop hindering our productivity with environmental artificial limits so that China can keep increasing their pollutants and industry. This is a strange take to me. We've had a great positive environmental impact and your take away is "but China is bad so we should also be bad!" Why not instead use tarrifs and international pressure for what it's good for. "Goods linked to CFC emissions get an automatic 25% tarrif".
- mrexroad 2y agoTo be clear… are you suggesting that b/c one party started doing something damaging that we should all forgo trying and continue doing something that is a clear and present danger to our atmosphere’s ability to provide UV protection? I’m also curious what issues you suggest Europe focus on that would require abandoning these straightforward, if slightly more costly, manufacturing efforts.
- flog 2y agoAs a New Zealander who's had skin cancer, and lives under constant high UV rates because of the lack of an ozone above my country (and Australia, South America, South Africa), I'd really like it if Europeans continued to reduce/stop ozone harming emissions.
- rtkwe 2y agoAnnoyingly you'll see this brought up as a "false alarm by environmentalist" by climate change deniers when it's really a time we absolutely succeeded.
- gunian 2y agoon the nature of ontology :)
- ajross 2y ago"If a problem was fixed, it wasn't a problem" is a really, really difficult cognition problem to crack. And unlike a lot of other fallacies it tends to affect the hyper-rationalist HN set worse than other demographics (who generally don't have a problem with the idea that someone fixed something). We saw the same thing on the front page here just last week in the Bald Eagle thread, pointing out that it wasn't particularly endangered and that even if it was it was never so in Alaska. This in a discussion about how it was not listed as endangered in the continental US anymore precisely because of the success of the conservation effort under the Endangered Species Act.
- nashashmi 2y agoI always wondered why the climate impact of a recovering ozone was not taken into account when forecasting climate change?
- pavel_lishin 2y agoIs it not?
- rtkwe 2y agoBack then? Can't say but my guess is it wasn't assumed we would actually manage to do anything about it I imagine. CFC is one of the few times we've managed to win an environmental fight. I'm not even sure it has a particularly strong effect, a quick search [0] shows that a depleted ozone would have a moderate cooling effect and a full layer would be slightly warmer but it's swamped by the effects of more direct green house gases. Now the current and some variation of the future state of the ozone layer is definitely accounted for in the models, we just have so much more compute to throw at the modelling we can try many more scenarios but even then by [0] it looks like it's a minor effect. [0] https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/research/ozone-uv/moreinfo?view=deleption-climate-change https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/research/ozone-uv/moreinfo?view=...
- freen 2y agoOnly happened because Ronald Reagan got skin cancer on his nose. [0] Classic GOP: it’s not a problem until it affects me, personally, and then we absolutely have to fix it. Until then? Liberal fear mongering, special interests, etc. etc. [0] https://time.com/5564651/reagan-ozone-hole/ https://time.com/5564651/reagan-ozone-hole/
- nashashmi 2y agoGive republicans the coast line and see them go!
- Workaccount2 2y agoIt only happened because the solution was cheap and worked well. The "magic" of the Montreal Protocol wasn't any kind of sympathy or joint cooperation to save the Earth. No one had to sacrifice anything so it breezed through no problem.
- lern_too_spel 2y agoNeither claim is true. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/business/1991/09/29/the-costly-race-to-replace-cfcs/86e250e5-6031-4b77-88c4-9f9b6963b6b7/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/business/1991/09/29/t... "Eliminating CFCs and other ozone-depleting chemicals by switching to alternatives could cost as much as $36 billion between now and 2075, according to the Environmental Protection Agency." "Substitutes have drawbacks compared to the industrial perfection of CFCs, however, he said. Turpines are flammable. In addition, its toxicity in high concentrations has yet to be determined, so 'we use it with caution,' he said. 'It all comes under the grand scientific principle of no free lunch.'" For that matter, fixing LA's smog wasn't cheap either.
- Workaccount2 2y agoImagine the fix for global warming was $500M a year for 75 years.
- 2y ago
- xorcist 2y agoI am often reminded how similar the discussion around global warming and the one around CFCs were. There was much shouting about destroying the economy, and how the cold chain was a remarkable invention that ensured we did not die from food poisoning and did we really want to go back to medieval times? Maybe sell ice from a lake? Sure there are alternatives but they are both expensive and with sub par performance. We need to have alternatives that both cheaper and better before we can do anything? But no, rich countries showed that they could actually get together and ban harmful chemicals, and by sheer economic force alone turn the whole world around. Research was let loose when there was economic incentives, mass production effects set in and over time the expensive and bad alternatives was cheap and good enough.
- hammock 2y agoFull paper: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/383293168_Fingerprinting_the_Robust_Recovery_of_Antarctic_Ozone https://www.researchgate.net/publication/383293168_Fingerpri... It’s crazy to me that after studying the ozone hole for 75 years, this is the first and only paper that confirms the hole healing was primarily caused by human interventions. Also, an important caveat is made by the authors: “The forced response in this study considers GHG and ODS only, and does not include known forcings from important volcanoes and major wildfires after 2012”, which are the top non-human factors that ozone hole deniers always point to when trying to debunk stuff like this.
- harvey9 2y agoSome credit must go to Dr. Allan Neyman. 2024 marked 25 years under the shield.
- webworker 2y ago"Burr, it's cold in here ..."
- DidYaWipe 2y agoI thought this recovery has been well-known for quite a few years. It really is proof that concerted effort can bring about worldwide change, for little sacrifice.
- latentcall 2y agoExecutive Order: We must dramatically increase the use of CFCs wherever possible!
- tim333 2y agoOk. CFCs done. CO2 next.