4 ms·
Intel the CPU Company
- twoodfin 2y agoThe classic paper on what went wrong (and some surprises about what didn’t, really) for the iAPX 432: https://safari.ethz.ch/architecture_seminar/spring2020/lib/exe/fetch.php?media=colwell1988.pdf https://safari.ethz.ch/architecture_seminar/spring2020/lib/e...
- kens 2y agoInterestingly, Bob Colwell, one of the authors of that paper, ended up being hired by Intel and he designed the Pentium Pro. The other classic paper on the iAPX 432 is "A performance evaluation of the Intel iAPX 432". Coincidentally, one of the authors was my officemate at Berkeley. https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/641542.641545 https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/641542.641545
- kjs3 2y agohe designed the Pentium Pro So he earned forgiveness. :-)
- _trampeltier 2y agoHow could they with the tools late 70s, design something like this. At least they tryed.
- rbanffy 2y agoIt's really sad the 432 failed, directly, because we didn't get to really see it, and indirectly, because it made almost all of our computers today to be based on horrendously kludgy processors with an architecture that killed wonderful things like Amigas, Atari STs, SGIs and so many other lines that had their lives cut short.
- zabzonk 2y agoThe 8086 and 80286 were so difficult to program, both in assembler and higher level languages. Everyone was relieved when the 386 and 486 came around - at last you could program sensibly and use operating systems that didn't crash all the time because of good memory protection.
- chihuahua 2y agoI was doing a lot of 6502 and 68000 assembly programming. Then (around 1988?) I got a PC with an 80286, and bought a book that described the 80286 instruction set. After reading it, I said "this is some bullshit" and returned the book for a refund. I had zero interest in writing a single line of code for that processor.
- dougvj 2y agoI first learned assembly on the x86 and wasn't until years later that I picked up m68k asm for a hobby computer and all that time I just assumed assembly was either gnarly and difficult like x86 or very bare bones for compilers (like the RISC isas). I didn't realize there was a such thing as nice, programmer oriented assembly.
- Pet_Ant 2y agoCan you tell us what the vast difference was that made you give up programming for it? I've only assembled SPARC in college, so I have no basis of comparison.
- chihuahua 2y agoIt was a long time ago (37 years?) but the main difference is this: The Motorola 68000 has 8 32-bit data registers and 8 32-bit address registers. They are named D0..D7 and A0..A7. You can use these in most instructions in the obvious/expected way. Maybe it's not completely orthogonal, but close enough. With those registers, you can keep 8 intermediate values and 8 pointers, and perform reasonable operations on them (add this and that, and store at that address) The 80286 instruction has just 4 16-bit registers, 4 more registers with strange names (BP, SI, DI, SP) and 4 segment registers. None of these are general-purpose. I just looked it up and apparently, you can only use AX and DX for multiply/divide instructions. The segmented addressing is what is most repulsive about the whole thing: you can't just put an address into a register. You have to use a segment register and use an offset so the real address is (segment register value)*16 + offset. The reason for all this bad design is presumably compatibility with even more primitive earlier processors (8086, 8088, 8085, 8080). All this backward compatibility is so painful and limiting. The 68k was launched in 1979 and it gets all of this right (32-bit addresses, general purpose registers), but the 8086 was launched in 1978 and it's so primitive and ugly. It reminds me of Windows which even today has certain dumb features such as "\" being the path separator for compatibility with CP/M, some primitive relic of the 1970s. I understand the importance of backward compatibility for commercial success, but it's so ugly and I just don't want to have to deal with it decades later. Yes I know that the NT kernel can theoretically use a different path separator, but in practice, we're all still using \ for paths and / for command line options. Because CP/M was so incredibly great in 1975.
- outside1234 2y agoIntel really was a powerhouse then and on par in terms of "cool" with Microsoft. Crazy to think of that now given how much their paths have diverged.
- chasil 2y agoThe computer history museum has a panel interview where they discuss standard cell automated layout with "Timberwolf," a program they obtained from a graduate student who debugged it when needed from his dorm at his university. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26757328 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26757328
- mdip 2y agoLovely read -- the 80s early 90s were such an interesting time in computing. That was a nice walk down memory lane for me and instantly brought back memories of dialing into (and eventually running) a Bulletin Board System. Few families had computers and -- as a kid -- the luckiest kids had Commodore 64s. I was the only kid -- out of 8 of my friends -- who's Dad insisted on having the same hardware at home that he had at work and he, like so many of that era, fell in love with Lotus 1-2-3[0]. I found it incredible that a nearly $4,000 (1985ish dollars) 8088 "generic clone" computer with ten times the RAM of a C64, 2 floppies and an RLL (?) HDD and "a real computer monitor" had a pretty abysmal collection of often terrible looking games available (it was the early days). The most obnoxious part of this machine was, upon powering it on, it would count all of the memory, climbing in 64k steps, for a solid minute[1] while the jet engine that was a full-height RLL 10MB HDD[2]. Because this obnoxious boot time and the small shop's recommendation (likely because "this happened before") after the rapid demise of our HDD[2], my father elected to just leave the computer running 24x7, turning only the monitor off when not in use. That machine (that I hated), though, became a pretty substantial part of (if not all of -- at times) my life from age 11 on. The 386 really was a revolution. With a VGA adapter and Sound Blaster (Compatible) you could spend an hour making a boot disk and eventually get a game with excellent graphics (for the era) to start without running out of memory below the 640k barrier. We couldn't afford one so my Dad took the unconventional approach of starting a company and having me build PCs for neighbors, friends and eventually businesses to afford a top-of-the-line one. I had a 486DX/33 (top sku when I purchased it) PC with ... everything (even SCSI drives), a 16" SVGA monitor and laser printer a year later. As a teenager I took a job at CompUSA[3] in hardware sales -- from about 1993-1997ish -- what an awesome time to work at a computer chain. I'll never forget the Windows 95 launch (after years of being promised a successor to WFW 3.11; even long enough for IBM to have a reasonable contender in OS/2). We had been receiving boxed (3.5" floppy and CD-ROM versions) of the software for weeks with an embargo[3]. We'd run promotions for the release day that involved staying open over-night. Somehow many members of the public were under an odd impression that "there might not be enough copies for everyone" and people actually started lining up around 10:30 at night. By midnight the line went all the way around the entire strip-mall (which could fit three CompUSA's worth) ... twice. The warehouse walls were floor-to-ceiling Windows 95 boxes, as were the tops of all of the aisle, the entire wall behind Customer Service, along with several large 5 foot tall 4-pallet wide stacks, several end caps and a few floor-to-ceiling shelves-worth, along with their "Power Pack". The store was surrounded in "blue." We had more RAM, Hard Drive and CD-ROM drive upgrades in the store than we'd ever had at one point in time at discounts that meant nearly everyone bought one of the three, many bought all of them. We played rock music on the speakers and watched Bill Gates with the cast of Friends from a CD-ROM displayed on the monitor wall. That release at that time felt like a very large tipping point. Not just "there's something better than DOS that's mainstream" but with the local news regularly bringing up "The Information Super-Highway" and careers were increasingly requiring computer skills, by then the 8ish people I knew who owned computers became "half of my friends" (all from suburban middle-class families) owned recently purchased PCs. It was a unique thing to see. There were hundreds of people waiting in line. Unlike other situations where people "wait in line to buy something", this wasn't a Cabbage Patch Kid, concert tickets to a huge musical act's tour, or various Super Mario/Link cartridge games ... this was a boring operating system. One that I'd been running betas smuggled through "Elite" BBSes for probably a couple of years by then[4]. It was also well known by then that there was no shortage of the OS or the promos (we did run a few door-buster "first X people get Y for free" deals) but we'd never had more than maybe 25-30 people "waiting for the doors to open" during even the biggest promos outside of this. The composition of people, as well, was unique. Yeah, all but maybe four were guys. But it wasn't hundreds of "computer nerds" -- it was a pretty huge number of normal, average, middle-aged men of various ethnicities (we had an unusually high number of Korean individuals due to the location's racial make-up). Summers were notoriously slow and usually saw a few bumps toward the end of August with "laptops becoming a school supply for college students" but that year, every weekend from the release of Windows 95 until the following summer seemed as busy as early-Christmas and this was in a location that was a half-mile from Computer City, Best Buy and Circuit City. Things started taking off like crazy owing mostly to "The Information Super-Highway" everyone kept reading about (and a half-decade later it was basically "over", with all computer-centered brick-and-mortar shops but Microcenter failing). Intel, having gotten into a legal fight with AMD, went with Pentium branding and brought some of the best swag. I've got varieties of stuffed Intel "hazmat suit" toys and still have two Pentium key chains with the processor embedded in (apparently) Lucite. Their competitors vendor reps brought T-Shirts (and I still wear my Athlon64 "Power me Up" T-Shirt). Crazy stuff ... fascinating how rapidly things apex, collapse and then just become part of every-day-life and the cycles get shorter and shorter. Intel had a few mis-steps here and there during that time (Pentium FDIV), but they were the king through most of my childhood. I now sit in a room with three high-end workstations. All are recent AMD processors. [0] The company he owned also designed parts and was an early user of AutoCAD, so there was a profanity-infused evening involving my Dad installing an 8087 in that iron lung of a case. [1] After about age 8, I could recite every number it displayed for a few seconds ... 64k, 128k, 192k, 256k, 320k, 384k, ... 576k, 640k [2] One that I destroyed a few months after its purchase because I wanted to see what kinds of sounds it made if I turned it on, then off as it was spinning up, then immediately back on. It turns out that given a sufficient number of cycles, the kinds of sounds it makes is "none at all". It also turns out the number of cycles impressively low, like, maybe, five? Luckily, it was new enough for warranty replacement since nobody discovered my devious act. [3] Including rewards if we caught a competitor selling a copy before the release date. [4] I continued to run the final beta version I had downloaded because it was more stable than the GOLD version on my hardware ... I finally relented after the first service pack, I think.