8 ms·
Why I Turned Down $160,000
- lninyo 14y agotFl;dFr (!)
- rorrr 14y agoContrary to the impression media and movies have created, lawyers get paid VERY LOW salaries now, at least in NY. We have overproduced so many lawyer graduates who thought they would be making 100K+ at their first job, it's just insane. Just start browsing craigslist or monster listings, it's very revealing.
- MayanAstronaut 14y agoHow did this guy get a 160k base then?
- rorrr 14y agoMy guess would be because he graduated from Stanford Law, which is currently ranked #2.
- rudyfink 14y agoLaw school graduate salary distributions are really an interesting thing. I suggest a quick gander at this chart of the distribution from 2006-2011: http://www.nalp.org/salarydistrib http://www.nalp.org/salarydistrib .
- graeme 14y agoThose curves have changed very quickly. I'm very interested to see 2012.
- rayiner 14y agoLegal salaries are bi-modal. You either work at a big firm paying the market big-firm rate ($160k+ bonus in NYC, Chicago, etc) or you work at a small firm making $45-70k. There are some weird market dynamics in the legal field. Law firms create an artificial shortage of lawyers, and thus a corresponding explosion in associate salaries, because they refuse to hire substantial amounts outside the top 15 schools or so. They'll hire anyone at Stanford and most people at Duke, but only the very top of the class at say U Washington.
- GFKjunior 14y agoExactly, I know a Columbia law grad who works in NYC. His firm hires nothing but Harvard, Columbia, and Yale grads. He said that it's not because a Berkeley or Texas grad isn't just as good it's because they have a certain culture and in case one of the new hires messes up a case no one wants to be the partner who gave that "public school kid" a chance and lost the firm a lot of money and prestige.
- rayiner 14y agoLaw is also a pretty insular and regionalistic field. E.g. at one of the most selective firms in the country (Susman Godfrey in Texas), a UT Austin grad has a much better chance than a Columbia grad. They think UT = Harvard down there. It's all very strange. In most fields such blatant regionalistic favoritism isn't so encouraged.
- btilly 14y agoIn most fields the rules do not vary so much by state and to a lesser extent a small collection of states. But in law your state law matters, and even on federal law the precedents can vary according to which circuit you are in.
- bfe 14y agoThe top tier firms still pay $160,000 as starting salary, same as since 2007, but they are hiring a lot fewer people. New law grad salaries have been more and more binodal over the last few decades, with the other local maximum at around $55,000, and an increasing share of the new grads getting stuck at the low end.
- patio11 14y agoJust start browsing craigslist or monster listings, it's very revealing. Craigslist and Monster give a very accurate impression of the legal employment market for clients who are so catastrophically incompetent that they would source legal representation from Craigslist or Monster. Similar to programming. I don't really have a dog in the fight of "Production of legal talent adequately meeting market demands for legal talent: yay or nay", but it is an observable fact that a particular type of student has a very achievable career trajectory into being a BigLaw associate at a six figure salary in their first job. You can plot out that career trajectory, to the month, the day you receive an offer of admission to one of several undergraduate institutions.
- xenophanes 14y agoPeople overestimate the opportunities for lawyers. If you go to Yale Law you're OK. Maybe even top 3. If you "only" go top a top 14 law school, you need to beat a lot of your classmates, there are quite large numbers of losers. If you do not go to a top 14 law school, it gets a lot worse, fast. And there's 200 law schools... People assume it works less strictly than that, but the legal job market recently changed so just doing well at a top school isn't enough anymore. In other words, the "particular type" of student is a narrower category than people think.
- rprasad 14y agoPeople overestimate the opportunities for Yale graduates too. I've received resume from Yale and Harvard grads for legal-related unpaid internships. The problem is not an oversupply of lawyers; there are just about enough lawyers to satisfactorily satisfy the legal needs of the market (taking attrition into account). The problem is that most lawyers are unwilling to do the solo/small-practice gig like doctors and dentists do, and consequently chase the firm and government jobs. The number of new firm and government jobs has dropped by more than half in the last 3 years, leaving a glut of "unemployed" lawyers. But that's the thing about lawyers--they're not supposed to be employed. They're "professionals", so they're supposed to be their own bosses. I wish lawyers would at least try setting up their own shingles. Most of my graduating law school class did (at least, the ones without massive loan debt), and they've all got respectable, self-supporting practices. They won't make filthy money, but they will definitely be comfortable supporting a family within the next few years.
- bretthoerner 14y ago> craigslist or monster Are you reading what you're writing?
- rorrr 14y agoYou must be new to the internets. These are the sites with jobs listings.
- rprasad 14y agoAfter graduating in the middle of Lawmageddon, craiglist was very useful in finding jobs. I managed to cobble together enough work through Craiglist to start paying off my student loans and gas. If I'd kept at it for an entire year, I could definitely have made enough to at least reach the bottom peak of the bimodal curve (~$50,000) just through craiglist-related work.
- stfu 14y agoImpressive. Jut being curious: How did the Craigslist workload break down, i.e. what kind of work did you get/became the most profitable?
- rprasad 14y agoSecond-chairing trials was the most lucrative work. This mostly involved helping the primary attorney on the matter with pretrial hearings, jury selection, presentation of evidence, and cross-examination of expert witnesses. Courtroom appearances was a distant second. For about $100-$200 a day (depending on the court and number of cases), I would appear in court on behalf of other lawyers to file various motions and paperwork.
- rudyfink 14y agoHere is a data set on post-graduation employment (full time legal) rates for different law schools-- http://www.lawschooltransparency.com/clearinghouse/?show=compare&sub=jobs http://www.lawschooltransparency.com/clearinghouse/?show=com... . Here is an explanation of where the data in that table came from-- http://www.lawschooltransparency.com/clearinghouse/ http://www.lawschooltransparency.com/clearinghouse/ .
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rprasad 14y agoIndeed, I now may make in legal-related market than I would as a lawyer doing the same work. It's very bizarre... Worse (well, not from my perspective), I work fewer hours than any lawyer I know but make more than all of them except for the ones working for BigLaw (i.e., the "premier") law firms.
- mgkimsal 14y agoYet because of the licensing and laws and regulation, most law firms are still charging > $150/hour (from what I've seen), because there's still few choices. While there's more lawyers than there have been in a while, it hasn't at all brought the pricing down. I suspect it ends up as simply more profit for the larger firms. Because there's more competition for jobs, they can pay less, but because of the regulations (barriers to entry) the prices can remain high. It seems an odd paradox, but I may be over simplifying.
- antidaily 14y agoBut my team and I expect our venture to prove even more lucrative. Best of luck.
- henrybaxter 14y agoIt's not clear to me whether the author has much experience actually working with lawyers, in law firms or otherwise. It would seem that experience, even a few years, would vastly improve the odds of building successful products and services.
- rdl 14y agoHe probably realizes that a few years of making 160-200k/yr will make dropping down to a startup salary afterward a lot harder, particularly with parents, girlfriend, etc.
- veyron 14y agoTo be honest, 160K isn't that much. Many of my friends, some just graduated in Law and others starting in other fields, are making more than that. Especially in NYC. Many hedge funds, for example, are still shelling out 300K+ salary for people 2-3 years out (considering you had to go through law school its apples to apples)
- zobzu 14y ago"practicing law is all about making money" Okay
- forgotmyuser 14y agoare you doubting this, or confirming the statement?
- its_so_on 14y agoWhere did you find that quote? (Or are you ironically summarizing / was the article changed?) The article says "Practicing law is safe and probably fairly lucrative" and "Practicing law is an honorable profession. Indeed, I think it’s probably one of the more interesting professions there is."
- zobzu 14y agoits what i got from reading the article, ie my own summary i probably wouldn't call it honorable. law is based on honorable concepts. but.. past that, stuff has been corrupted beyond recognition
- hanskuder 14y ago"Generally speaking, legal practice is fairly inefficient and anti-technological. My cofounders and I are not the first to notice; there is a veritable graveyard of failed legal technology companies." The issue, in my opinion, is that law firms have a direct incentive to be inefficient and bill more hours. Why would a firm invest in time-saving technology when it will literally mean sending smaller bills to clients? The firm would have to raise their rates or work even harder to drum up business in order to maintain revenue. This is a really unfortunate situation, but it's reality. I hope Amicus Labs has a strategy to address this.
- rayiner 14y agoTo be fair, the author is a fresh law school graduate. What does he know about whether legal practice is inefficient or not? I was a summer associate at a large New York law firm, and the level of technology was fairly typical for corporate America. We had a centralized document management system that integrated version control and generation of deltas. We had a centralized, searchable repository of every document generated for every client, which we could use to avoid duplicating effort when doing new work. We did everything via Blackberry e-mail and Outlook calendaring. Beyond the generic "you can always have better document management" I'm not sure what else there was to do. The major legal research databases (Westlaw and Nexis) have god-awful interfaces, but there isn't much law firms can do about that, since there is a huge barrier to entry in that market (the proprietary databases). The fundamental problem is that nearly everything you do for a client is a one-off. It's 90% similar to what you've done for a previous client, but that remaining 10% is not very amenable to technological automation. Can you write some software that will cross-reference an SEC disclosure against the client's big pile of haphazardly-assembled internal documentation, which are handed over in God-knows how many formats? If so, then you're going to make some serious money. If not, then well that's how that graveyard of failed legal technology companies builds up. The big recent advance in legal technology has been software to speed up document review, which leverages document search technology that has really improved (and obsoleted a large number of discovery attorneys in the process). Law firms have been quick to embrace such software, as well as services such as "in-sourced" discovery centers in places like West Virginia. To date, legal technology hasn't advanced much beyond that, largely because computer technology for working with documents hasn't evolved much beyond search.
- kamakazizuru 14y ago"In economic terms, the worst outcome (forever making $40,000 while trying to “fight the good fight” while trying to stay on top any of various loan forgiveness programs) can be pretty brutal." Interesting - when did making 40k a year become "brutal" ? There's people doing fine on much less. Sounds more like a case of "hey I made a big scary decision - so now I'm going to blog about it so that people can validate my decision for me. In the process I'm also going to point out how even in the worst case I'd be better off than 75% of the worlds population is. ".. come on...
- milesskorpen 14y agoI think 40K could be pretty brutal when you've given up years of potential wages for law school to take on 150-200k of debt. And then most of your classmates are making at least 4-5x your income. A lot of studies have found people's perception of wealth is relative, right? Making 25% what your pee/friends make would really suck.
- greedo 14y agoIt also depends on location. $40K in the midwest is livable, while on either coast, not so much.
- milesskorpen 14y agoEdit: ... what your PEERS/friends make ...
- anonlaw123 14y agoI try and keep perspective that there's way, way worse things than having over 200k debt and making 40k a year while working and living in a modern, Western, industrialized country. I think the 40k number is worth emphasizing though, not as some terrible torment but as a data point that casts light on the financials of attending law school. In terms of objectively looking at the merits of law school as an investment, a 40k salary outcome is pretty awful. The opportunity cost and direct costs (in loans) are enormous and the risk of getting the low-end outcome is pretty high. There's way, way less risky ways to make 40k, and way less costly ways to position oneself to one day have a chance at a six figure salary. "Just getting by" and "the only way you can afford your loan burden is by taking advantage of government income-based repayment and loan forgiveness programs" is not the outcome most people expect going to a decent law school, so it's important that people hear that this happens.
- endtime 14y agoWow, this is the wordiest I've ever seen someone be about their STAT-101 material. Also, "Second, while most startups do not succeed, I have reason to believe that this one—Amicus Labs—will succeed." totally fails to account for the fact that this is true of everyone with a failed startup. No one starts a company thinking it's going to fail.
- yitchelle 14y agoTotally agree - I don't know why this was explicitly stated. I mean, how many founders would do a startup in a serious manner with a vision for failure? Every founder _will_ believe that they startup will succeed.
- davidw 14y agoIt would make for good parody material: "You've heard of 'fail fast', right? We're taking it to the next level: failed out of the starting gate!". Something like that.
- crafter 14y agoOh heck, don't laugh. That's happened to me a couple of times already!
- mgkimsal 14y agoA whole ecosystem of startup-support companies built around helping you fail even faster would be good to have in the parody. "site sinker", "business buster", etc (but of course with more clever web 2.0 names).
- ank286 14y agoThis person hasn't experienced the hopelessness and defeat that comes with a failed idea. Getting a summer associate position that brings about a 160k job is "winning" the protocol for law school success. There is no such protocol path for startups. Also, Amicus Labs, which maps Legal Genome, better have a good plan for attacking the high barrier of entry into these BigLaw firms.
- grabeh 14y ago"Mapping the legal genome" brings to mind visualisation of case law in diagram form so dependent on search terms you could see a visualisation of relevant cases incorporating the precedent cases and then below them cases which have relied on them. As a lawyer, this would be interesting for me to see and would definitely be more interesting and helpful than current search methods from which it isn't immediately clear the hierarchy of case law is. Whether this is an idea which would be attractive enough to monetise successfully is another question entirely...
- jacabado 14y agoNot apropos your post, but slightly relevant. After having some involuntary contact with law, I found that I love to read laws and jurisdiction. I'm finishing my MsC in computer engineering and would love to try to pursue a career that would intersect technology and law. I've just found a LLM, a masters in Law, that doesn't requires a Law degree in the University of Edinburgh, they even have the possibility for distance learning. (http://www.law.ed.ac.uk/ahrc/teaching/llm/llminnovationtechnology/ http://www.law.ed.ac.uk/ahrc/teaching/llm/llminnovationtechn...) Can you tell me what should I expect to do with such degree? I was thinking something like paralegal work on technology related cases. Besides that, what could I do to prepare myself before entering the LLM? I'm almost completely ignorant on most Law concepts/theory. Thanks, and good luck for your startup. I had thought of something like that but for the government decrees, to increase state transparency.
- grabeh 14y agoI'm sure plenty of firms would be interested in a candidate who has a good grasp of technical concepts so why not look to convert to become a lawyer by applying for training contracts with law firms? Many firms like candidates who have done a first degree and will fund you to do the conversion course. It's obviously a very competitive space but then due to the excess of law grads, so is the paralegal space. Your course provider is best placed to advise on some good introductory texts to the subject you are studying. Some general introductory books along the lines of 'How to study law' may be of interest however. Speaking as a lawyer, many of the legal concepts you will come across are relatively straightforward, it is the subsequent process of applying them to the facts where problems arise, but if you have a logical mind (which is likely to be the case coming from a computer engineering background) then you should be ok.
- xiaoma 14y agoAccording to what I've read, the current employment prospects for law school grads in the US are the worst they've ever been. Considering that law students as a whole were far stronger undergrads than their peers, a nearly 15% unemployment rate is pretty brutal. http://chronicle.com/article/Unemployment-Among-Recent-Law/132189/ http://chronicle.com/article/Unemployment-Among-Recent-Law/1...
- repsilat 14y agoAnd at the same time legal services are still horrifyingly expensive. This is partly because law students have unreasonable amounts of debt. Somehow there's too much supply keeping jobs scarce and too much demand keeping prices high. There are a couple of factors behind this. One is the accreditation process law schools need to go through. It's backed by all of the major schools (because it protects their interests), but it's pretty expensive to get accredited. Another point is the cultural position the legal profession has. The old cliche of money-grubbing soulless lawyers has died down somewhat - if you have a bad experience with a lawyer it will resurface, but most of the time when someone says they're a lawyer (at least for me) the immediate associations are professionalism and prestige. Add to that the fact that it's about the only "safe bet" career for graduates in the humanities and there's an obvious glut of labour. I'm not sure what the solution is, but think I part of it has to be making starting up a new legal practice a more attractive and more approachable option.
- rayiner 14y ago> And at the same time legal services are still horrifyingly expensive. This is partly because law students have unreasonable amounts of debt. Somehow there's too much supply keeping jobs scarce and too much demand keeping prices high. Price is the equilibrium of supply and demand. Cost (the expense of educating each student at an accredited school) doesn't influence the price. The problem is that people are defining "supply" incorrectly. Firms don't want to hire just any of the 45,000 law students. They want to hire one of the 1,000 Harvard, Yale, or Stanford students, and then depending on the market one of the 4,000 students at the top regional schools like Duke or U Chicago. The enrollment at these top schools has grown only very slowly over the last century. The price of an associate at a big NYC firm is determined b how much it costs a top Columbia graduate to go to that firm as opposed to a competing firm. Associate salaries thus exploded in the 2000's as the demand for legal services far outstripped the enrollment at schools like Columbia, while they have effectively been cut substantially (due to reduced bonuses) in the last 5 years as the demand has dropped while enrollments have stayed constant.
- drhowarddrfine 14y agoIf I see another "Why I ..." article, I'm going to hire a lawyer and sue them.
- inthewoods 14y agoGiven that most law grads I know are buried in debt and thus really can't think about joining a start-up, I find myself wondering whether the author is unique in that he has no debt and therefore has this choice in the first place. For most people in this position, I would argue, there isn't much of a choice. He does raise good points about raising a family - start-ups can definitely give you more flexibility. But, on the other hand, going home and telling your wife that the start-up you joined has failed and you're out of a job isn't easy. Granted, that can happen at any job. This post will likely come off as way too negative, but I certainly do wish him well in his path - the legal profession could certainly use the overall.