3 ms·
The actual complaint is available here: https://peer.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/2024.02.27-First-Amended-Complaint-Date-Stamped.pdf https://peer.org/wp-cont
by Aurornis 2y ago
The actual complaint is available here: https://peer.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/2024.02.27-First-Amended-Complaint-Date-Stamped.pdf https://peer.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/2024.02.27-First...
Not a lawyer and I didn't read with a fine-tooth comb, but I didn't see any smoking gun.
The complaint shows high quantities of PFAS measured on a farm, then it jumps to a section that says those PFAS were "also found" in a sample of the fertilizer used. The catch is that the concentration of those PFAS is measured in parts per trillion (ppt). Not a lawyer, but I feel like this is an uphill battle to show that the "smoking fertilizer" that caused the breathing problems is linked to PFAS contamination in groundwater at a different site at high concentrations.
Something to keep in mind is that modern equipment is very good at finding very small quantities of compounds. When you're able to measure down to parts per trillion you can start finding some level of various compounds in basically every water sample you test.
- lazide 2y agoNear as we can tell, the levels of PFAS (depending on the compound!) or microplastics to actually be causitively fatal to a farm animal - especially on the timescales of their typical lifespan - would be mind boggling. Like drinking-from-the-outlet-of—a-teflon-factory likely wouldn’t even do it. The concern everyone has been having is that these compounds may be (evidence at current known exposure levels still iffy!) causing long term cancer risk increases or interfering with hormones. That is not even in the same ballpark of ‘dies in 3-5 years’.
- Centigonal 2y ago> the levels of PFAS (depending on the compound!) or microplastics to actually be causitively fatal to a farm animal - especially on the timescales of their typical lifespan - would be mind boggling. Like drinking-from-the-outlet-of—a-teflon-factory likely wouldn’t even do it. Counterexample: https://www.chicagotribune.com/2022/07/11/persistent-farmer-whose-cows-died-from-a-mysterious-disease-helped-unravel-the-origin-of-toxic-chemicals/ https://www.chicagotribune.com/2022/07/11/persistent-farmer-...
- lazide 2y agoPaywall :(
- Centigonal 2y agoAh, sorry. Basically the most famous lawsuit involving PFAS in the US began because a farmer's cattle were dying downstream of a DuPont/Chemours plant in West Virginia that was dumping PFOA into the water. Dupont settled for hundreds of millions of dollars after an independent scientific review found probable links between the dumping and a variety of human ailments in the area. DuPont's own internal research suggested that the material is harmful to animals. Here is Wikipedia on that lawsuit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bilott#Initial_actions_against_DuPont https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Bilott#Initial_actions_...
- lazide 2y agoThanks! So apparently drinking directly from the plant is enough. Impressive.