3 ms·
First let me say that yet again, another blog post that contains little to no science to back up claims; instead, personal feelings and an individual's ex
by michaelt 14y ago
First let me say that yet again, another blog post that
contains little to no science to back up claims; instead,
personal feelings and an individual's experience become
the standard by which apparently all people experience
working in STEM.
"Stereotype Threat and Women’s Math Performance" by Spencer, Steele and Quinn [1] contains an interesting series of experiments.
In the first experiment, test subjects are given two math exams, an easier one (from the GRE general exam) and a harder one (from the advanced GRE mathematics exam). All test subjects had 1 semester to 1 year of calculus with at least a B grade. They observed something that has been seen in the literature before - that both genders perform equally on the easier exam, but women underperform on the harder exam.
In the second experiment, a different set of test subjects were given the harder exam. Half the subjects were told the test had been shown to produce gender differences, half that it had been shown not to produce gender differences.
Characterizing the test as insensitive to gender differences was enough to totally eliminate women's underperformance. When the same test was characterized as sensitive to gender differences, women significantly underperformed in relation to equally qualified men. (results are fig. 2 on page 13 of the PDF)
The third experiment repeats the second experiment under different conditions and gets a similar result.
The "stereotype threat" article is not a compelling
enough argument to me that there is some gender
stereotype conspiracy only found in STEM
No stereotype conspiracy is required - the threat is from the stereotype /held by the test subject/ that they will/are expected to underperform.
[1] http://www.leedsmet.ac.uk/carnegie/learning_resources/LAW_PGCHE/SteeleandQuinnStereotypeThreat.pdf http://www.leedsmet.ac.uk/carnegie/learning_resources/LAW_PG...
- peterwwillis 14y agoYeah, I read the article, as I specified in my comment. Not every study or set of experiments is foolproof, and the 'results' of ones that are done specifically on a bias, and never replicated, should not be considered some kind of universal truism. Did you have some point, or argument, or opinion, you were trying to make?
- michaelt 14y agoNever replicated? How about "Knowing Is Half the Battle Teaching Stereotype Threat as a Means of Improving Women's Math Performance" by Johns, Schmader and Martens [1] ? Participants were divided into three groups; the first group were told they were getting a problem solving test; the second group were told they were getting a math test for a study of gender differences; the third group were told the same as the second group and that anxiety could be the result of negative stereotypes that are widely known in society and have nothing to do with their actual ability to do well on the test. As figure 1 on page 4 of the PDF shows, the first group had roughly equal gender performance, in the second group women underperformed, and in the third group performance was roughly equal. Or why not "Solo status, stereotype threat, and performance expectancies: Their effects on women's performance" by Sekaquaptewa and Thompson [2] - once again, women performed worse in the stereotype threat condition that in the no threat condition. Did you have some point, or argument, or opinion, you were trying to make? Only that your statement that there is little to no science to back up the blog's claims ignores multiple peer-reviewed studies. [1] http://www.mdecgateway.org/olms/data/resource/9098/Knowing%20is%20half%20the%20battle_Week%206.pdf http://www.mdecgateway.org/olms/data/resource/9098/Knowing%2... [2] http://j.b.legal.free.fr/Blog/share/Expos%E9s%20M1/Stereotype%20threat.pdf http://j.b.legal.free.fr/Blog/share/Expos%E9s%20M1/Stereotyp...