3 ms·
Coops are basically geared toward mediocre success - because there's really no pressure to risk aiming for amazing/startup-style success. Ownership structure d
by bombcar 2y ago
Coops are basically geared toward mediocre success - because there's really no pressure to risk aiming for amazing/startup-style success.
Ownership structure doesn't change many of the business risks, but coops can avoid the "expand or die" that sometimes normal companies experience.
The largest coops are mutuals (think: insurance) and banks (think: credit union).
Others exist in farmer's coops (Land o' Lakes, Dairy Farmers of America, etc).
https://ncbaclusa.coop/blog/2022-world-cooperative-monitor-ranking-largest-cooperatives-now-available/ https://ncbaclusa.coop/blog/2022-world-cooperative-monitor-r...
The hardest part is converting an existing corporation into a coop.
The vast majority of coops are, like credit unions, relatively small and local. Instead of expanding to new areas, they often "split" into new areas, so you'd expect them to remain just below the noise threshold of the large multinationals.
- kbxogdgkdhop 2y agothe phrase you're looking for to describe "mediocre success" is "sustainable business". expand or die is a bullshit concept employed by those more concerned with a quick buck than creating something lasting
- bombcar 2y agoExactly - it's like the startup vs "lifestyle business" (we have to keep making terms for what just used to be "business") discussion. The sad part is when something on the startup track fails as a startup but is a perfectly workable "lifestyle" business; but it can't switch tracks and instead plows along until destroyed.
- ForTheKidz 2y ago> Coops are basically geared toward mediocre success - because there's really no pressure to risk aiming for amazing/startup-style success. I'm just straight-up offended at this. Co-ops are the job most people want. What you refer to as "amazing success" is dismantling our society and the people who run them appear to struggle to empathize with other humans. Granted, i'm sure coops can be equally antisocial and misanthropic. But growth surely isn't what we want to be optimizing for.
- tonymet 2y agoare there any examples?
- ForTheKidz 2y agoEnshittification is the most obvious one—we should be nationalizing efficient processes at the point they fail to yield further productivity gains. I don't really have much energy to argue with true believers today, so all I'll say is "read schumpeter dammit". For an industry allegedly founded by the dude I haven't met a single person working with VCs who's actually read the man. He would not consider today's America to have a healthy economy.
- tonymet 2y agothis doesn't sound like an example, more of a complaint
- ForTheKidz 2y agoYou didn't bother to articulate what particular claim you wanted an example on. I can't read minds, and you're wasting my time.
- tonymet 2y ago> " Co-ops are the job most people want." -- what are some examples?
- ForTheKidz 2y ago• Stable employment • Democratic workplace • You can have input in whether to optimize for longevity or short-term profit. • If you do choose to have a profit-sharing, you experience arguably proportional reward for the work you invest. • Unions are less necessary if you don't need to actively organize to engage in democratic decision structures. These are examples of qualities that I've found that appear to be desired by the majority of both my tech social-circles and certainly my non-tech-social circles. Certainly there's immense bias in my viewpoint, but I'm not the person equipped to draw together evidence that people want something they aren't even presented with, but it's something I do believe is generally true. For more historical evidence, to put aside the co-op structure (which is, in my opinion, secondary to the qualities that people want from their business), flat companies have had their moments of popularity with both Valve and Zappos. (obviously neither are co-ops, and I doubt either have labor-proportional profit-sharing now if they ever did, but it's limited evidence people are turned off by the dysfunction of hierarchical businesses.) More evidence: in the fight between workers and shareholders, shareholders had to use the courts to enforce shareholder primacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodge_v._Ford_Motor_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodge_v._Ford_Motor_Co. This indicates the natural tendency of society is to mediate between the needs of the shareholders and workers, something most naturally achieved by making the workers the shareholders. I realize little of this is likely to be as convincing as the evidence of so many for-profit companies largely not owned by workers, but there's a lot of literature discussing the perverse incentives of divorcing ownership (and investment) from labor that is far too large for a HN comment. There are, of course, very large co-ops others point out (health insurance, REI (I think?), credit unions), but I can't say I have the insight into the historical reasons why they appear in some industries and not others, in some regions (states) and not others, etc etc. FWIW, I have worked in for-profit environments where I don't own stock and I've observed genuine concern for all the qualities above. This isn't a hard and fast rule. But most of my workplaces don't show this behavior, and it's quite soured me on gambling with my time (the typical capitalist-to-worker-pitch) rather than finding a lower-return but stabler form of employment that prioritizes quality of work and life. You can get a lot of this by working at large tech companies, but they often undersell how much this affects quality of life despite enormous compensation, and also undersell the sort of dysfunction that would normally be remediable if you let the workers have true representation on the board and among stockholders.
- surgical_fire 2y ago> Coops are basically geared toward mediocre success There's something deeply wrong with a society that can label moderate success as "mediocre". I wish society gave more incentives to healthy, moderately successful, profitable companies instead of "growth and greed at all costs" success. Or, as you put it, "amazing/startup-style success". Fuck that noise.