2 ms·

I don’t know how people aren’t reading an implied critique in this piece. Is it a kind of writing that many HNers are unfamiliar with, or something?

• card_zero 2y ago
  Or isn't there one really? For instance: > 45-year-olds aren’t discovered, they’re uncovered, like toxic waste, or a political scandal, or the murderer at the end of an Agatha Christie book. My god, that 45-year-old was lurking among us this entire time! One way to read that is as criticism of people who think that way. It certainly seems like a complaint: the author is complaining this attitude is unfair. But whose attitude is it? Is this really the prevailing way of thinking about 45-year-olds? Or is the author just pushing paranoia to the readers?
  • dangus 2y ago
    I think you captured exactly my distaste for this article. I understand it’s about coming to terms with these feelings and uses these specific examples. But the examples used in the article seem unrealistic to begin with, as if the article insists that a plurality of people feel this way about youth and aging. I just don’t think that’s really the case.
    • Izkata 2y ago
      Of curiosity I just looked up the authors of my favorite book series - they were 43, 42, and 35 when the first book of each series was published. That first author is currently 70 and we're still waiting for the publisher that owns the rights to want another book in the series, she has a plot in mind and had revealed the premise more than a decade ago.