3 ms·
> Why must everything always "scale" in order to be good? Because there's eight billion of us. A lot of things work for one person but not for everybody. The b
by pjc50 2y ago
> Why must everything always "scale" in order to be good?
Because there's eight billion of us. A lot of things work for one person but not for everybody. The big issues of land use, density, water, and transport end up forcing people into choice that perhaps nobody ultimately wants.
(this is not a reason for you or anybody else not to do it! But it's a reason against all sorts of "why doesn't everybody just X")
- 9dev 2y agoYet we've seen how centralising everything has made our world a lot less resilient. Redundancies are good, at least to a certain degree. If more people had a small vegetable patch, we didn't need as many soil-destroying farming mega-corps, and would use less aggressive fertilisers and herbicides, for example.
- itsoktocry 2y ago>Yet we've seen how centralising everything has made our world a lot less resilient. A lot less resilient compared to what?
- 9dev 2y agoCompared to a world before global economic trade relations, standardisation, and hyper-dependent supply chains.
- berkes 2y agoResilient to pests, environmental changes, etc? Biodiversity is a very good mechanism for resilience. Even on a tiny scale: if this year one of my tomato varieties doesn't produce due to heat/cold/damp, some of the others will. And if all tomatoes fail, I have beans. Or salad. And potatoes, and turnips, and carrots. Yet if all you have is one variety of potatoes, and it gets sick, it can upset an entire country, kill millions¹ You'd think the solution is obvious, but the opposite is happening. Especially the staple foods that are now feeding the billions, are rapidly dwindling in varieties. Some crops, like bananas and agave already down to effectively one genetic variety - if (when) that fails, we'll lose the ability to produce bananas or agave (tequila, etc) almost entirely. Imagine this happening to rice or grain or potatoes. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland)
- teamonkey 2y agoA lot of the reasons why scaling is necessary come down to reducing marginal costs and maximising profitability. Those are different equations to sustainability. For example, a big part of an industrial farm's "efficiency" is down to reduction of labour costs and optimisation of logistics, but the actual environmental resource usage does not scale along the same curve.
- berkes 2y agoWorse even. Many of that "efficiency" is achieved by externalizing costs. The farm can (must?) produce cheaper (or have bigger margins), by polluting both its environment and the very resources it needs to run on in the long term. It "externalizes" costs to the community around it and to a future. Pollution, depletion, animal abuse, reduced biodiversity, sped up resistance to antibiotics, etc etc. This isn't by any means "sustainable" in the literal sense: that it can continue, let alone grow, like this. We're on borrowed time already. It's very clear that the current model also cannot sustain billions. So dismissing alternatives because they cannot sustain billions is a poor argument.