4 ms·
I'm pretty sure wealth doesn't follow an exponential distribution. Power law, log normal or stretched exponential or maybe some sort of generalized Zipf.
by carlob 2y ago
I'm pretty sure wealth doesn't follow an exponential distribution. Power law, log normal or stretched exponential or maybe some sort of generalized Zipf.
- colechristensen 2y agoThis, for the sake of argument, is not an important distinction.
- carlob 2y agoI disagree, if anything we need to know what the distribution is before we make such sweeping claims. While pretty much every country has an income tax, which means that we knows fairly well who makes what, there is no equivalent for wealth. Most wealth distributions are estimates which get progressively worse as we near the top percentiles, because really big wealth is very mobile and international. So yeah before we say: "it always looks like this, it's just about what the parameters are", we need to measure it and have a clearer idea of what it looks like in different societies otherwise we won't be able to decide what the desirable parameters are like.
- j7ake 2y agoDon’t use technical terms like “exponential distribution” and then say the technical details like what distribution it is does not matter. Doing so conveys sloppy thinking while pretending to be rigorous only on the surface.