3 ms·
Apple doesn't design the CPUs, they license the IP (from ARM and Imagination Technologies primarily) and put it on a SoC chip. The A5/A5X were distinguished by
by ajross 14y ago
Apple doesn't design the CPUs, they license the IP (from ARM and Imagination Technologies primarily) and put it on a SoC chip. The A5/A5X were distinguished by the very large SGX cores, but that's not really an engineering triumph -- it's just a bigger chip. Other manufacturers were first with things like dual channel memory, PoP assembly, integrating the A8 and A9 (and SGX, for that matter) cores, etc...
SoC design at that level really that innovative. You take some IP, throw it onto a floor plan and contract with a fab. Apple having their own designs is more about optimizing their production chain than it is about driving innovation.
- wmf 14y agoBut Apple "curates" the best Imagination GPU (edit: or the biggest number of GPUs) and for some reason all their competitors don't...
- ajross 14y agoNo, it's exactly the same SGX core. Apple just uses more of them. Other players in the high end space right now happen not to be PVR-based (Exynos 4 is Mali, and of course Tegra 3 is NVIDIA). Frankly if you really want to argue (and for the record I think such an argument is ridiculous), ARM and NVIDIA have much more "elegantly scalable" solutions that don't require high level brute force duplication of the core.
- koko775 14y ago> Apple doesn't design the CPUs, they license the IP [citation needed] I know someone who works on processor stuff at Apple. More detail would obviously be bad for him, but they have digital design expertise which they are actively using to design (presumably) their future generations of chips.
- ajross 14y agoI really need to cite the fact that Apple uses an ARM Cortex A9 and PVR SGX? You couldn't look that up on wikipedia?
- Steko 14y agoYou guys are just talking past each other. Apple, just like everyone else, makes modifications/optimizations to the base ARM designs. Look it up on wikipedia if you like.
- ajross 14y agoNo, that's simply wrong. There's certainly nothing on wikipedia to back that up, nor anywhere in the industry press that I'm aware of. The A9 in the iPhone 4S is 100% indistinguishable from the same core in Exynos 4 or OMAP44x0.
- mtgx 14y agoYou're right. All Cortex A9 chips are the same. What might differ is the fab process. A company could make it at 40 nm, another at 32nm and another at 28nm, so you would get further optimization from that as well. Apple's A5X SoC is 50% bigger in surface than Tegra 3. Considering the Tegra 3 SoC contains 4 CPU cores, and Apple's A5X only 2 CPU cores, plus taking into account all that extra space, I could see how A5X's GPU easily doubles Tegra 3's GPU in size, if not more. That's where the performance increase is coming from. Hopefully Nvidia and others will be smart enough to build bigger chips with in the next generations.
- Steko 14y ago"There's certainly nothing on wikipedia to back that up" Emphasis below mine: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_architecture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_architecture Fabless licensees, who wish to integrate an ARM core into their own chip design, are usually only interested in acquiring a ready-to-manufacture verified IP core. For these customers, ARM delivers a gate netlist description of the chosen ARM core, along with an abstracted simulation model and test programs to aid design integration and verification. More ambitious customers, including integrated device manufacturers (IDM) and foundry operators, choose to acquire the processor IP in synthesizable RTL (Verilog) form. With the synthesizable RTL, the customer has the ability to perform architectural level optimisations and extensions. This allows the designer to achieve exotic design goals not otherwise possible with an unmodified netlist (high clock speed, very low power consumption, instruction set extensions, etc.). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_A5 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_A5 "The A5 contains a rendition of a chip based upon the dual-core ARM Cortex-A9 MPCore CPU[10] with NEON SIMD accelerator and a dual core PowerVR SGX543MP2 GPU.[11] ... Among the customizations that Apple has done to the chip is the inclusion of an image signal processor unit (ISP) that will do advanced image post-processing such as face detection, white balance and automatic image stabilization[14] and an "earSmart" unit from Audience for noise canceling" Look I'm no expert but it's been often reported in the press about the A4 and moreso the A5 that Apple made optimizations to them. PA Semi was originally often attached to such reports but I think later reporting often cited the Intrinsity acquisition. Here's a comparison of the A5 and the reference ARM Cortex A9 design: http://www.twitpic.com/4a0ggc http://www.twitpic.com/4a0ggc
- Aloisius 14y agoApple's mobile chips are just systems-on-a-chip packages of ARM and PowerVR chips that are then fabricated by Samsung. Apple has nowhere near the engineering capability to design a full CPU from scratch. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_A4 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_A4 or http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_A5 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_A5
- wmf 14y agoApple has nowhere near the engineering capability to design a full CPU from scratch. They did after buying PA Semi, but after Agnilux and Keller they may not now. In any case it appears they didn't use that talent that way.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]