7 ms·
Many would consider switching from Qwerty to Dvorak a bicycle skill. Typing a blog post or email can take much longer when you're learning to type in a new patt
by stephengillie 14y ago
Many would consider switching from Qwerty to Dvorak a bicycle skill. Typing a blog post or email can take much longer when you're learning to type in a new pattern. For some, the enjoyment of learning Dvorak, or the anticipation of being faster in Dvorak than Qwerty offsets the annoyance at the task's increased duration. For others, they have no such enjoyment or anticipation, and so the task is merely annoying.
People will only pick up bicycle skills where their benefit (or perceived benefit) is greater than the annoyance they deal with.
- RegEx 14y agoPersonally, I wouldn't recommend learning Dvorak to anyone employed as a programmer. I would highly recommend it to high school/college students with some free time on their hands. Going from 100WPM qwerty to 30WPM Dvorak while learning was extremely frustrating for just non-critical tasks, such as chatting with friends. I wouldn't be able to handle going so slow when I needed to actually get stuff done.
- eru 14y agoI learned Dvorak as a student, too, and wasn't any fast at qwertz before. You can learn Dvorak, even as a professional programmer, if you just reserve half an hour each day on the side for the learning, and keep using your old layout for your day job until you are comfortable.
- agscala 14y agoI don't think switching to Dvorak is worthwhile. Most people don't have the capacity to actually squeeze out the few extra wpm that Dvorak gives you, and if you do, the benefits aren't extraordinary. Plus if you use Vim, either you'll have to remember where the original keys were on the keyboard and use it solely through muscle memory, or relearn.
- RegEx 14y agoLuckily I began the transition to Dvorak before I ever heard of Vim. The process definitely would have proved more painful with an additional set of muscle memory to override.
- jcoder 14y agoTo me (Dvorak typist for > 2 years), it's not about increased wpm. I'm actually not a fast typist. It's about greater comfort at the keyboard, because ~70% of my keypresses are along the home row, compared to ~30% with QWERTY. WRT Vim, I made the switch without too much trouble. In fact, I find the j/k on the left hand and h/l on the right hand useful.
- sopooneo 14y agoAnd most of us are programmers, right? Beyond some very low threshold I can not imagine WPM factors into programmer productivity. If you are a writer then perhaps it would help.
- tomjen3 14y agoI type in dvorak. If I don't my hands hurt. And go install emacs. Its shortcuts are easier to type in dvorak.
- eru 14y ago> Most people don't have the capacity to actually squeeze out the few extra wpm that Dvorak gives you [...] For me it's not about speed, but about ergonomics.
- cs702 14y agoMany would consider switching from Qwerty to Dvorak a bicycle skill. Are you sure? I'd consider typing in Dvorak a non-standard skill that would make me less productive with ~99% of keyboards in existence! This strikes me as about as worthwhile as learning to ride a non-standard dual-wheel vehicle, as a consequence of which it becomes much harder to ride regular bicycles.
- evoxed 14y agoI'm just one data point of course but after the switch I actually type much faster in qwerty as well. No looking, somehow when I need to I just switch without thinking. It's especially helpful when running a VM or when the bootscreen is tied to qwerty only.
- cs702 14y agoHuh. That's interesting. I guess it's akin to learning a second language...? Thank you for posting this -- it's changed the way I feel about learning Dvorak.
- plorkyeran 14y agoI had similar results, and I never even learned to type very fast on Dvorak. I think the key detail is that it forced me to break all of my bad habits I'd developed, and that carried over to qwerty.
- markram 14y agoAfter using Dvorak exclusively for two months I can't touch type Qwerty at all. I think you have to use Qwerty occasionally while learning Dvorak if you want to use both (I don't).
- starpilot 14y agoBut most of your typing is probably on your personal or work computer(s). The rest of the world's keyboards don't matter.
- eru 14y ago
- cdr 14y agoHasn't Dvorak been pretty thoroughly debunked as far as claims of speed? [1] is only the first google result, I can recall seeing quite a few articles on HN. Dvorak is more unicycle than bicycle. [1] http://reason.com/archives/1996/06/01/typing-errors/print http://reason.com/archives/1996/06/01/typing-errors/print
- starpilot 14y agoNo. That 1996 article is wrong on that point, and fluffy on others. It's straightforward to calculate finger travels for typing words on various keyboard layouts [1], and Dvorak easily comes out on top. Placing e on the home row alone is probably a significant improvement. Compare the home rows: asdf jkl; aoeu htns Placement of high-frequency letters, especially vowels, reduces finger movement and eases typing. There's no magic about it. [1] www.typocheck.co.uk/dvorak/
- aangjie 14y agoOT: I haven't read this specific article, but have been on DVORAk for about a year and am happy about it. But one of the problems i have noticed in arguments for and against these kb layouts is the hand size. they vary from individual, and i can easily see someone with a bigger hand not realizing the same efficiency improvement as i did when i switched over. *-- I switched over by trying Dvorak for an hour a day instead of the QWERTY i had used for about 3-4 weeks. I was a below average QWERTY user. Touch typist, but not fast/ not a lot of typing experience.
- decklin 14y agoThat article is mainly about the strawman argument that if Dvorak is better, then free markets are bad, because they lead to the kind of network effects that gave us QWERTY. (As a happy Dvorak user, I find this argument silly.) The author is very motivated to prove the premises false, for political reasons. I don't think it's very insightful.
- SkyMarshal 14y agoDvorak = old and busted. Colemak = new hotness. http://colemak.com/ http://colemak.com/
- godDLL 14y agoSeconded, for typing in code (with all the brackets and what not) this worked out better for me.
- ibotty 14y agoprogrammer dvorak is even better... :D
- SkyMarshal 14y agoInteresting, first I've heard of that. http://www.kaufmann.no/roland/dvorak/ http://www.kaufmann.no/roland/dvorak/ http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=351059 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=351059 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dvorak_Simplified_Keyboard#Programmer_Dvorak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dvorak_Simplified_Keyboard#Pro...
- tremendo 14y agoColemak puts the colon key above the home-row, and using Shift, which for Vim is rather unfortunate. I guess you can always remap it.
- eru 14y agoDvorak is old, yes. But busted? By the way, for international users the NEO keyboard layout might be worth a look, too. I'm just too lazy to switch from Dvorak to NEO, even though it would make it easier to type German Umlaute. Also my Kinesis Advantage keyboard supports Dvorak out of the box.