8 ms·
Can Digg make a run on Reddit?
- BaconJuice 14y agoNo.
- kmfrk 14y agoIndeed. blauwbilgorgel gave some good reasons why this prospect seems ridiculous: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4322197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4322197. Like outlook.com, the best thing Digg has going for it is that people really want an alternative to the incumbent who sits on most of the market, which in this case is reddit.
- huggyface 14y agoBecause a rushed product is imperfect? Digg at its highest peak was a grossly imperfect product. If project success depended upon trivia like type="text/javascript", the internet world would be a very different place.
- huggyface 14y agoThey can through algorithms, which is something that is painfully lacking on most social media sites (including HN). Give users the ability to dislike something strongly enough that anyone who voted it up is excluded from all vote counts/rankings/recommendations as provided to that user for some period of time. While this leads to a filtered world, that is exactly what users expect from sites like these. Reddit is essentially falling apart for many users (while catering to a new audience) -- in /r/all as well as individual subreddits that see a constant cycle of abandonment as people try to ontologically solve the problem -- as it is increasingly dominated by teenagers. If I could strongly express a disinterest in every fictitious Facebook picture / iPhone message conversation, and that served as a quality indicator of people whose opinions I don't respect, that would be beautiful.
- raldi 14y agoWhich subreddits do you subscribe to where you see that unwanted content?
- huggyface 14y agoWhich subreddits do you subscribe to where you see that unwanted content? It shouldn't matter what subreddits I subscribe to (and the encroachment of certain trends keeps herding people to yet new subreddits. /r/gaming -> rage comics and DAE remember. Okay, everyone to /r/games...rinse repeat. /r/atheism -> ridiculous and obviously fake caricatures for people to knock down. /r/programming -> beginner material, so what, /r/notbeginnerprogramming?) That is a hack, manual solution for machine learning of the things I am interested in. Netflix uses strong algorithms and a lot of data crunching to suggest movies I might be interested in, rather than simply forcing me to subscribe to wholesale genres (you like Action movies so here's every movie that dropped in the Action bin). The eventually winner of the social news game will be those who effectively transfer that sort of learning to this genre. Note that you can take it beyond simply finding correlation indexes between users -- analyze the linked site to determine factors like is it image heavy, what is the grade level / complexity level of the writing, discern the subject matter, etc.
- AlexanderZ 14y agoIf you think that subreddits don't matter, then you are clearly expecting from Reddit something that it was not designed to have. The most popular subreddits are swarmed with teenagers and the quality has gone downhill, that's true. But the value of Reddit is in its (less popular) subreddits.
- sp332 14y agohuggyface's point is that Reddit should hide uninteresting-for-me material and surface interesting-for-me material automatically. Subscribing to subreddits is a manual process that shouldn't be necessary.
- mtgx 14y agoIt's not even out properly yet and these articles are already starting to pop out? In its current state definitely not. If they can build even better algorithms and communities than Reddit, maybe. But that's a huge if. And they've got nothing right now. I do like its design though, which is very different from Reddit, and that means it might serve a different market.
- klein 14y agoThey are serving completely different purposes. Why would they be competing?
- captainarab 14y agoThey are both link aggregators. Although, the new Digg looks more like Pinterest or even canv.as than Reddit.
- AlexanderZ 14y agoReddit is far from being a link aggregator right now. Reddit is all about the community. I'd call Reddit a community of communities, I feel like this is what describes it the best (in its current state).
- klein 14y agoBut their algorithms for aggregating are very different. Reddit is primarily based on submitted links. Digg is primarily based on links shared on social networks.
- captainarab 14y agoTrue. However, at the end of the day, both of these sites revolve around the content "submitted" by users (either directly on the site or across social networks), and they need this content to thrive/survive. So while their purpose/methods may be very different, both sites co-exist in the same ecosystem?
- seltzered_ 14y agoIs digg trying to make a run on reddit? I finally saw the new digg, it felt more like prismatic/other news sites to me. I associate reddit more with close discussion communities, as broader-versions of forums.
- seltzered_ 14y agoIs digg trying to make a run on reddit? I finally saw the new digg, it felt more like prismatic/other news sites to me. I associate reddit more with close discussion communities, as broader-versions of forums.
- lbcadden3 14y agoNot if you have to have a FB account to login. They need other options fast.
- nirvana 14y ago... not with 504 Gateway Timeouts. I did get a chance to see it last night and it certainly looked nice, but I'd already seen all the news stories on the front page at that moment, so I haven't quite gotten the point yet. I'm not sure that FB and Twitter shares are the same as "diggs".
- Kilimanjaro 14y agoDigg is a tabloid, reddit is a community* * dysfunctional, but community nonetheless.
- schneby 14y agoNo.
- freyr 14y agoI've enjoyed Reddit for years, but I'm about at my limit. Incessant memes, novelty accounts, meta-commentary about novelty accounts, reposts, complaints about reposts, kitten pics, and a million other annoyances that trace back to karma whoring make the site difficult to tolerate. If the new Digg could successfully counteract this trend, I'd be on board.
- swalsh 14y agoThe really interesting thing about the redesign of Digg, is in a way it's kind of the first example, of the possibility of seeing gentrification ported to the internet. I don't think they will be successful, but its a really interesting concept. One of the hardest parts of any kind of community driven website is to generate the community in the first place. Of course, as the idea of eternal september demonstrates communities deteriorates in quality over time as the community grows to a broader variety of people. Its interesting then, to try to take an existing community that has settled at the lowest common denominator of content and to try to revitalize it. If you take the metaphor further, if you think of artists as the cultivators of culture in a city. And the first step of gentrification is an increase in artists (typically seeking lower rent) who is the cultivators of culture in an internet community. Money doesn't really exist on the internet... well at least the classism associated with it (and rent) so what attracts these culture cultivators back?