3 ms·
Free speech concerns in the EU go like: - You can't call people pedophiles unless it was proven in court. - You can't say black people are inferior. - You ca
by immibis 2y ago
Free speech concerns in the EU go like:
- You can't call people pedophiles unless it was proven in court.
- You can't say black people are inferior.
- You can't say Israel is doing a genocide.
and only one of these is a valid thing to be worried about IMO...
- ty6853 2y agoHow about I see an interesting street hustler in Munich and put a photo of him on my blog? If something like that is illegal I'd quickly find our two cultures are absolutely incompatible with my continued residence.
- immibis 2y agoI see - you think harassment and privacy violation is free speech. Please stay away from Europe.
- ty6853 2y agoCool so now free speech is reduced to anything not viewed as harassment. I think I will take your advice, that's dystopic and far worse than just your prior bullet points.
- tharkun__ 2y agoYou can also just ask him if it's OK to do that and they're probably going to be OK with it. And otherwise you simply ensure that you have more than IIRC 5? people in the photo because taking and publishing a photo of a group of people is not illegal. Privacy and not being harassed and free speech are of course exactly where the rubber meets the road. There is an intersection and naturally people will have differing opinions as to where the line should be drawn. One can always come up with examples where favoring free speech will lead to really bad outcomes for someone and vice versa.
- immibis 2y agoUh, it's reduced to things that are not harassment. Who said "viewed as"? Are you trying to make everything subjective, so you can argue all opinions about harassment are equally valid? This is like saying the US's gun law is "reduced" to everything "viewed as" the right to keep and bear arms. I don't think you can legally own a nuclear missile anywhere in the US, even in Texas. Which part of taking someone's picture is speech, anyway? I didn't see that in the first amendment.
- ty6853 2y agoBan on nukes is an infringement but not as egregious as the ones in Europe. In another comment I admit for instance Yemen and Idlib have a stronger right to bear arms than the US. I absolutely acknowledge this. US also has free speech issues. For instance, libel has civil penalties I disagree with. However not being able to post a photo I took of someone in public for me is completely intolerable and barbaric, and a harassment against people exercising right to free speech. Opinions differ so I'm pretty pleased with Germany doing their thing and me doing mine and never stepping foot on their soil.
- immibis 2y agoDo you find that not being able publish a book someone else wrote is an infringement on free speech? I agree that you should stay in the USA and let everyone else go to Europe.
- sepositus 2y agoWell, according to the two sources I'm familiar with, it's not necessarily the _current_ laws that are the most concerning, but rather the _direction_ things are heading.
- immibis 2y agoIn the past it was like: - You can't call people pedophiles unless it was proven in court. - You can't say black people are inferior. Since October 2023 it's like: - You can't call people pedophiles unless it was proven in court. - You can't say black people are inferior. - You can't say Israel is doing a genocide. And has remained there since. Is this what worries you?
- sepositus 2y agoHistory proves limiting free speech is a slippery slope. I can't speak for my EU friends, but for me, yes, it's very concerning to begin justifying why some speech is not OK.
- immibis 2y agoIn the USA you can't say "I want to blow up this plane" in an airport, so the slope has already begun.
- refurb 2y agoThe interesting things is how that list is growing, not shrinking.