3 ms·
People easily overlook the most important part to me of playing vinyl, and get distracted by the "it sounds better" conversation. To me, it is the physicalness
by dylan604 2y ago
People easily overlook the most important part to me of playing vinyl, and get distracted by the "it sounds better" conversation. To me, it is the physicalness of holding the vinyl, watching/reading the grooves, setting the needle, lifting the needle, rinse/repeat for each track you want to listen (assuming using singles). There's much more satisfaction when you're actively doing things to keep the music playing (even if not a DJing) rather than clicking some infinite stream where you just tune out of even paying attention to the music. Playing vinyl forces your attention. That's when you start to become a real music nerd type by learning which cut of the release a song was on, which side of the vinyl, etc.
That might not be what most people care about, and that's fine. They have infinite streaming available for those that just need background noise. But to write vinyl off as a gear acquisition syndrome just screams to me someone doesn't really get it and wants to find a way to mock someone else
- sambapa 2y agoThat sounds too easy, real music nerd types carve their own vinyls at home. Realer music nerds build machines that carve vinyls. Realerer music nerds work in mines that supply metal (no pun intended) for those machine parts etc. And I'm just a wanker with Spotify and rate your music that accelerated my taste and education in music 1000x times.
- rectang 2y agoAlbum art for 12-inch LPs is fabulous. CD packaging with jewel cases was a major step down in experience because of size and also because of the inconvenience of getting the booklets out of the case; good CD packaging experiences were exceedingly rare. Art for streaming is a different medium altogether, as it is behind a screen but potentially dynamic; it can achieve new things, but can't replicate the LP experience any more than photographs can reproduce sculptures.
- card_zero 2y agoThe Black Crowes Southern Harmony and Musical Companion is the size of a jewel case, but cardboard like an LP cover, and folds out to reveal an extra six segments as well as front and back covers. (Five have pictures, the other one holds the CD.) So that's a good effort, but fundamentally LPs are a more satisfying size for looking at.
- BoingBoomTschak 2y agoThose are details not improving the music itself; even if cool auxiliary aspects, sometimes. You can listen to full albums intently even when using a digital system. In fact, do you truly care if you have to be physically constrained into doing so? I'll sound very smug, but so be it: this is a trap very easy to fall in. Are you a "proper" christian if you only are because you fear hell? Do you care about software freedom if you had to be spoonfed baby duck software that looks and feels just like Windows to switch?
- dylan604 2y agoNothing I said implied improving the music, so I have no idea why you're trying to make the connection. The point I was making is that vinyl is about the medium. The physical nature of constantly changing the record means you're more involved. I specifically said that claiming it to be a "better sound" is not what I like about vinyl. So to be very smug, your second graph is absolutely pointless since you've missed the point of the comment you replied
- BoingBoomTschak 2y agoNo, I didn't miss anything. If you need to be forced by a physical routine to be "involved", do you truly care about music? Why?