4 ms·
New York court dismisses Amazon's objections to paying state taxes
- fallentimes 18y agoThis is terrible news. If I was Amazon I'd eliminate all NY affiliates and tell them to contact their state. Lack of regulation and taxes is what makes the internet so awesome (and sometimes, awful).
- gravitycop 18y agoThat's what Overstock.com did. http://www.realtechnews.com/posts/6289 http://www.realtechnews.com/posts/6289 To get around the “Amazon Tax,” Overstock.com terminated its relationship with any New York affliates; it also filed suit against the state of New York (as did Amazon.com, separately). Meanwhile, Newegg.com simply stopped collecting it.
- snprbob86 18y agoIs there a follow up to this story? It seems like there would be some response.
- ensignavenger 18y ago"Meanwhile, Newegg.com simply stopped collecting it." That's not a bad idea, either- what's the State of New York going to do- as long as your company doesn't hold any assets in the State?
- fcjqbuvjxpxml 18y agoSo are affiliates different from advertising? If I print an ad in a newspaper and include a coupon is that a presence in the state? I hope new York isn't home to any publishing or advertising companies - this could be really bad news for them.
- steveplace 18y agoIf an affiliate claims residency (as a individual or business) in NY and AMZN gives them money, then there's NY taxes involved.
- vaksel 18y agoyeah but they are the responsibility of the affiliate
- steveplace 18y agohence the controversy
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- gravitycop 18y agoat a certain point you're a multi-billion dollar company who can deal with [taxes] 1. No matter how many billions in revenue a company commands, it might inhabit a low-margin industry. 2. The taxes are shifted to the consumers. Do you mean to imply that each of the consumers is also a multi-billion dollar company?
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 18y agoThe case in question concerns New York state, where Amazon does not (to my knowledge, based on facts in the links above) have a warehouse. Your case for wholly-owned warehouses is a reasonable one, and in fact, Amazon collects and pays sales taxes in several of those states. The New York case is materially different in that it concerns marketing affiliates, not warehouse holding companies.
- gravitycop 18y agoThe case in question concerns New York state To be clear, I believe the sales taxes in question are both state and local: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123186764434777801.html?mod=googlenews_wsj http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123186764434777801.html?mod=... The judge said New York's law doesn't broadly tax "any and all Internet sales," but instead requires companies to collect state and local sales taxes if the company generates $10,000 or more in revenue as a result of commissions paid to persons in New York for sales referrals.
- spc476 18y agoSo, is that per affiliate (i.e. if no New York affiliate generated over $10,000, then Amazon owes no taxes) or aggregated (i.e. affiliates in New York generated $500,000 total payments, and Amazon now owes tax on said $500,000)? My guess would be for the latter.