9 ms·
These are the macro effects of housing. I buy all of them. I'm a housing activist involved in local politics in Oak Park, IL (one of Chicago's two equivalents o
by tptacek 2y ago
These are the macro effects of housing. I buy all of them. I'm a housing activist involved in local politics in Oak Park, IL (one of Chicago's two equivalents of Berkeley or Brooklyn, the suburb of Evanston being the other). Some micro/local impacts of housing restriction:
* Retail business stagnation; retail is dependent on foot traffic, and SFZ residents do not understand what it takes to support the kinds of businesses (yoga studies, coffee shops, art galleries, bookshops) that they actually want to see sited near them. The result is that city plans for commercial corridors create near-blighted streets with gas stations, vacant lots, and the occasional nail salon or Domino's Pizza.
* Public safety issues; those same underutilized commercial drags are dead once the sun goes down; without people walking on the streets, nobody's watching, and you can see on a map clearly where crime gravitates.
* Escalating property taxes; lots of people want to retire in the same community they spent their adult lives in, but in an overwhelmingly SFZ muni with good schools, the top bidder on any residential lot is a family with school-aged children. Schools make up over half (in our case, 2/3) of the property tax burden, and it gets worse as the demographics shift more and more to school-aged families who move out when their kids graduate high school; housing diversity could give retirees an economically rational place to move (and remain in the tax base), but we outlaw it.
The problem with all this stuff is you start to sound like a crank, because almost every problem a typical urban muni faces will probably stem from many generations of outlawing housing.
- allturtles 2y agoWhat does SFZ mean?
- jaqalopes 2y agoTangential question: Is housing activist your occupation? And if so how did you get into that line of work?
- tptacek 2y agoI work at Fly.io as our Chief Housing Activist.
- BenFranklin100 2y agoEven worse, our housing policy is corrosive to the fundamental social contract. When I was young, I was taught that if you worked hard and kept your head down, you could have a comfortable life. You may not be Bill Gates, but you could have a successful middle class existence. Our housing policies have broken this social contract. Many younger people cannot afford to live in high opportunity but high priced cities. Those that can, often only do so because of help from family. [1] NIMBYs dominate both sides of the political spectrum, especially among older people. It will take younger people getting involved in the YIMBY movement to effect change. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43213546 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43213546
- tptacek 2y agoI think YIMBYs really like to cast NIMBYs as their evil adversaries, but the problem is systemic. Any policy change, be it "what can be built on this lot", or "what social services do we fund", or, in particular for my muni, "how do we deal with leaf collection in Autumn" will generate three cohorts of people: (i) People who don't like the change (ii) People who don't care about the change (most people) (iii) People who do like the change People who don't like the change (i), regardless of the amplitude of their dislike, will turn out and give public comment and put up yard signs. People who like the change (iii) will turn out and give public comment only if they are weirdos like me, with off-the-charts amplitude for their feelings. The net result is that the only public opinion that is legible to staff and electeds is opposite. Again: regardless of what the change is.
- floodfx 2y agoInsightful! Makes me think a bit about how negative content engages more people. Is this the same with people who don't like change? Not liking change activates people more than people who do like change?
- do_not_redeem 2y agoSounds like loss aversion to me. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_aversion
- acdha 2y agoI live in a very similar neighborhood with exactly the same problems (DC railroad suburb) and completely agree with your assessment. Your observation that you start to sound like a crank really rings true, and it’s exacerbated by the stark generational gap where every interaction is painted as an attack on long-time residents, especially ones who don’t want to recognize that, say, taxes need to go up because infrastructure costs more to maintain or that traffic is worse because they, a retiree sitting on a $2M house, haven’t been able to downsize into an apartment and so the people who actually need to commute to work have to drive from a further out suburb and transit isn’t an option because guess who reliably votes against it? We had a positively surreal debate when the “preservationists” demanded that an apartment building literally next to a metro station have a huge parking garage even though the developer thought it was overkill. That made fewer, more expensive units and then they ended up renting out unused parking spaces as storage units because the people who choose to live next to transit are often trying not to pay for a car. Actuarially, most of the people who showed up at those meetings are probably dead by now but their decisions will still be visible in 2050.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hibikir 2y agoIt is a very typical problem in the US, but it's not really the only issue. Go look at Spain, a country that has, historically, had little issue building housing: Very dense housing too by most standards. After you liberalize housing, you still run into the trouble of economic forces trying to turn housing into a sensible investment: Buy an apartment, pay your mortgage for 20 years, and then you have a pile of leveraged money on top of the basic savings! But then you run into current housing in Spain: Said primary housing has huge tax savings over anything else. Taxes at sale time overwhelm property taxes (which are very good, yet seen as unfair by owners, so they stay low), so it's also better to keep the housing underused. So ultimately you end up with a situation where the building that before had an average of 5 or 6 occupants per flat in the 1980s, is now sitting at one and a half. So you end up having to massively overbuild, as to make sure nobody that bought in a good location does anything but make money on their "investment" The US could build more, thanks to so many inner suburbs that should really be filled to the brim and 8 stories tall, but ultimately it's just kicking the can down the road until residential investment is not so important, and the price of housing lines up with its utility, not the ever-growing value of the land it sits on top of. The Georgists that want to just LVT as the one tax in the world are going too far, but I don't see long term solutions to all the problems downstream from housing if, along of making it easy to build, we don't make sure that speculating on the value of the land is actually risky.
- csomar 2y agoSpain (since it's in Europe, though you could say the same about ME countries) is an example that housing does not drive growth. Growth can drive housing and housing shortages can hamper growth but housing on its own does not drive growth.
- matt-p 2y agoI think that's a bit debatable. In Barcelona there's a shortage of housing and more would grow growth. In a random town building more houses does promote construction led economic growth even if not other growth.
- smallmancontrov 2y ago
- goosejuice 2y agoBusiness stagnation and crime are particularly bad for Oak Park and Evanston. For the walkable areas increased density seems worse for local businesses. It prices out the mom and pop shops. I suspect there's a happy median. I too am in a western Chicago burb. All this tearing down of $400k houses and replacing them with hideous cookie cutter $1.8M new builds drives me crazy. They're 5-6 bed 5-6 bath. One in particular is a $500k to $2.5M flip. That's criminal.
- davidw 2y ago> I'm a housing activist Having seen you here ... well, forever basically, that's kind of awesome to see you describe yourself that way. High fives! Myself, I'm off to Salem, Oregon on Monday to testify in favor of Governor Kotek's big housing bill this year, HB 2138.
- anal_reactor 2y ago> Public safety issues Everyone believes in the myth of "dark, dangerous alleways", but when you look at the crime distribution of almost any city, it's usually actually concentrated in the city centre. Which makes sense. Imagine you want to mug someone - would you stand in a place where you're alone and wait entire night for someone to pass by, or would you go in front of a bar, and wait ten minutes for someone who's too drunk to resist. I absolutely love walking around at night and I strongly prefer dark places without any people around me, and I feel much safer than when surrounded by people. Can't get robbed if there are no robbers around. Simple as that. So far, I have had only one dangerous situation when being out in the city alone at night. There's a place I pass by where groups of people hang out - drinking, talking, listening to the music. Seemed like a lovely spot that lightened up the neighborhood, until one evening they decided to start shooting each other right when I was passing by. BTW I really wish my city ran out of money for street lamps, because the fact that we need to keep everything lit 24/7 like a carnival is driving me crazy, and I can't wait to move to the countryside for this reason alone.
- tptacek 2y agoMaybe my data doesn't generalize, but it's true for my muni.
- steveBK123 2y agoThere's another housing problem which maybe sounds ironic but I would argue that due to land costs, and tastes.. new housing in general is "too nice" compared to old housing. That is - the size, materials, appliances and finishes of housing have all got dramatically better in my 40~ year lifetime. No one builds utility housing anymore, its all aspirational. So for example, my parents & in-laws live in SFHs worth like 300k built in 1970-1990 era. The problem is that anything of comparable size built in the same town or neighborhood since is now going for 800k (literally across the street even). There is no cash-out downgrade for them to move to a townhouse and put there underused homes on the market. They weren't building said townhouses 30-50 years ago, so all available ones are newer and thus .. too nice. Why would you move to a smaller place for same/more money which also has some monthly HOA/condo fees? My first NYC apartment didn't even have a dishwasher or full sized fridge. I didn't have an in-unit washer/dryer until I was 35, and it was small/bad. Meanwhile it's interesting seeing the expectations of GenZ moving into apartments with their first job that are finished like the nicest apartment I ever lived in. Then they complain about cost? I can still find my old crappy apartment on street easy, and its rent is only up 50% in 20 years which given wages seems fine. Kids are moving to shiny finishes new rentals in Bed-Stuy for more money rather than enduring the indignity of living north of 96th street in a 2nd floor walk up.
- cjaackie 2y agoThis is an interesting point that I’ve seen play out as you described. It was the parents of an acquaintance of mine, and they did choose the downsize option because they were getting too old for the upkeep of a whole house and niceties it brings such as having the hotel like amenities of a doorman. Then there’s the point of choosing new vs. old stock, agreed there is a higher demand, thus it demands higher cost.
- steveBK123 2y agoFurther - because it’s easy & cheap to stay in a paid off SFH indefinitely, a lot of retirees do so. Part of it is inertia and part of it is stuff like “where will the grandkids stay if I moved to a condo”. Which sure if your monthly costs are near $0 then having 2-3 spare bedrooms sit empty 360 days per year seems sensible. If they could cash out 50% of their homes value and have same/lower monthlies, then losing some spare bedrooms wouldn’t matter. Downgrading has to be both easy and cost saving for retirees to do it. Between my dad and his 3 siblings only 1 has done the downgrade-after-70 thing. And even then that aunt only did so as a gift to her son selling them the family home below market …
- UncleOxidant 2y ago> Retail business stagnation This is maybe a bit tangential, but I live in a very walkable neighborhood (by US standards, anyway). But as commercial rents are rising (even faster than rent for housing) it's driven several small businesses out of our walkable core - a bookstore faced a 30% rent increase and couldn't make it work, a donut shop shut down for similar reasons, several other small businesses facing this. It kind of seems like commercial landlords saw that it was becoming more walkable because many high-density housing projects have come in over the last 7 years and they decided to gouge their tenants. Their tenants (small businesses) can no longer make the numbers pencil out with the high rent and shut down leaving empty storefronts - or large chains move in destroying the local character. And then there's less to walk to.
- SoftTalker 2y agoRaising rents so high that tenants leave seems counterproductive. Now you have no income from the property. So why do landlords do it?
- mouse_ 2y agoline must go up forever or infinite free money scam stops working
- UncleOxidant 2y agoIt's a good question. I suspect that some of these will remain empty for several months, at least.
- germinalphrase 2y agoI have heard it said that landlords are willing to take losses on some properties (leaving them vacant) if it means they can continue to justify their other property valuations. If they drop rents, that lowers the valuation of that property - and others like it - which can have a cascading effect of their entire portfolio. Would love to be corrected here if someone has a more detailed understanding.
- 2y ago