2 ms·
Why do people get upset about the limitations on Apple, yet happily accept that their Nintendo system will not play whatever they want to install, nor any other
by dylan604 2y ago
Why do people get upset about the limitations on Apple, yet happily accept that their Nintendo system will not play whatever they want to install, nor any other console system?
Yes, it's a powerful computing device that is probably much more capable and can be made to do more things than the intended purpose. That's fine to be curious about, and if you are feeling adventurous enough to fight against the system to get it to do more, go right ahead. However, I see no reason why Apple should be forced into helping you do that. It's not an OSS system.
- jamil7 2y agoThe first part of this comment is a bit of a straw man, but I'll bite. The reason is that the discussion is nuanced, a smartphone plays a very different role in someone's life than a Nintendo Switch. For better or worse, a smartphone has become a requirement for critical services that we all rely on.
- wtallis 2y ago> The reason is that the discussion is nuanced, a smartphone plays a very different role in someone's life than a Nintendo Switch. That doesn't really align with the arguments people actually put forth for sideloading on iPhones. "It's my device, I should be able to run whatever I want" is the most common, and doesn't leave room for the nuance you're referencing. Like it or not, most people arguing for iPhone sideloading are using arguments that also demand sideloading on game consoles. It's not at all a straw man.
- bee_rider 2y agoNintendo should have to open up their system (all consoles should), Apple just a higher priority because of how common their devices are.
- elashri 2y ago> Why do people get upset about the limitations on Apple, yet happily accept that their Nintendo system will not play whatever they want to install, nor any other console system Many people can get upset and complain about many things at the same time. For me I have a smartphone and it is essential to have one for everyday life now. Gaming devices are not playing the same role in people's life. But in principle I would agree that people should advocate for more control over all their devices.
- kaladin-jasnah 2y agoI think it's also worth noting that the Nintendo Switch and I think many of their previous consoles have been jailbroken to high heaven. So there's an overhead of maybe not being able to use Nintendo networked services, but you are able to "own" the device more. People have gotten Ubuntu running on a Nintendo Switch IIRC. This is not an optimal solution, but it is more of a solution than, for example, the (maybe I'm wrong) lack of jailbreaks for iOS that are usable (eg. tethered jailbreaks are more work to maintain).
- dylan604 2y agoAnd people have jailbroken iDevices. so what's the difference?
- kaladin-jasnah 2y agoLike I mentioned, tethered jailbreaks are not restrictive and from what I've gathered and require specific hardware and iOS versions (https://www.reddit.com/r/jailbreak/comments/1go8wy4/what_is_the_last_iphone_that_can_be_jailbroken/ https://www.reddit.com/r/jailbreak/comments/1go8wy4/what_is_...). Sure, you can maybe jailbreak the latest iOS on specific devices, but it's a lot more restrictive in selection, and various devices have various levels of being able to be untethered. Meanwhile, old Switches have a hardware vulnerability [1] and all newer ones can be jailbroken to their fullest with a modchip. Such pervasive coverage doesn't exist for iDevices to my knowledge. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/jailbreak/comments/1go8wy4/what_is_the_last_iphone_that_can_be_jailbroken/ https://www.reddit.com/r/jailbreak/comments/1go8wy4/what_is_... [1] https://switch.hacks.guide/user_guide/rcm/entering_rcm.html https://switch.hacks.guide/user_guide/rcm/entering_rcm.html [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/SwitchPirates/comments/13n1smv/please_could_i_get_some_further_clarity_on_which/ https://www.reddit.com/r/SwitchPirates/comments/13n1smv/plea...
- lapcat 2y agoWhat exactly do you want to sideload on your Nintendo system? Is there a large, frustrated demand for unauthorized Nintendo software? The game console business model is an historical anomaly. In the beginning, all console games were produced in-house by the console manufacturers. The consoles weren't "platforms" at all. However, 4 Atari programmers got wind that the games they wrote made tens of $millions for Atari while the programmers were paid only a relatively small salary. When Atari management refused to give the programmers a cut, they left and formed Activision. Thus Activision became the original third-party console game development company. Atari then sued Activision for theft of trade secrets, because the Activision founders were all former Atari programmers. The case was settled, with Atari getting a cut of Activision’s revenue but otherwise allowing Activision to continue developing console games. I suspect this was because the 4 programmers were considered irreplaceable to Atari (albeit too late, after they already quit).
- gjsman-1000 2y ago> there a large, frustrated demand for unauthorized Nintendo software? Ironically, yes, from people who don’t like paying for things. It’s a booming market on Android. And yes, I absolutely believe that saying Nintendo and Sony are allowed to make a locked down device, but Apple is not, is an arbitrary double standard, setting up a potential legal victory for Apple.
- lapcat 2y ago> Ironically, yes, from people who don’t like paying for things. It’s a booming market on Android. Can you be more specific? I'm not sure exactly what you're referring to. > And yes, I absolutely believe that saying Nintendo and Sony are allowed to make a locked down device, but Apple is not, is an arbitrary double standard, setting up a potential legal victory for Apple. What are you replying to? I didn't make any such claim in my comment. I wasn't defending the console business model, just explaining how it came about, which is very different from most computing platforms.
- gjsman-1000 2y ago
- askvictor 2y agoYou seem to be saying all people are the same. Plenty of people get upset about Nintendo (and other consoles) being locked down. Plenty more people don't care and happily buy them (and Apple devices).
- kelnos 2y agoWell, two things: 1. There are lots of people who get upset that their Nintendo won't let them install other things. There are hacker/homebrew communities that have formed around pretty much every console. 2. Phones are general-purpose computing devices. Consoles are not, even though modern consoles have hardware that is more or less the same as what you might find in a general-purpose computer. > However, I see no reason why Apple should be forced into helping you do that. It's the opposite problem: the default is to just let people do that. Apple has instead gone to the effort and work to lock down iOS to prevent sideloading. So no, Apple shouldn't be forced to help people sideload, but they should be forced to stop hindering people from sideloading.
- dylan604 2y ago> So no, Apple shouldn't be forced to help people sideload, but they should be forced to stop hindering people from sideloading. Now you sound like FBI director "we need backdoors for the good guys". By allowing a mechanism for side loading weakens the security of the device. If a good guy can use it, so can a bad guy.
- EMIRELADERO 2y agoAt the end of the day the proposition is very simple, there's no need to go into those backdoor analogies. No device manufacturer should have more control over that device's code execution than the end user of that device does after the sale.