4 ms·
Twitter's arbitrariness: do we need a dist'd protocol, not a central service?
Watching various tweets going past in the light of the NBC fiasco, and several people are suggesting that we should have an email-like protocol so we can develop a Twitter-like system with multiple providers, similar to how we now have multiple email servers.
Surely this can't be too hard to design and implement - most likely the impossible challenge is the chicken-and-egg problem - how can you get people to use it.
- debacle 14y agoI think it's important to replace Twitter with an open protocol if Twitter as a platform has value. I would argue that it doesn't. Twitter, in the social sense, has value for users on both sides as a corral of content consumers and producers. Twitter, in the technical sense, offers very little - the only special consideration is that I can send an SMS message from my phone and it will appear on a website, but there are many other services that provide this functionality. The reason I use Twitter is that it's free.
- mikegreenspan 14y agoHave you checked out what we're doing at http://join.app.net http://join.app.net?
- zeruch 14y ago"do we need a dist'd protocol, not a central service?" Short answer: yes. The communication model/platform has viability, but implementation(s) would be what makes or breaks it. Obvious I know, but it bears repeating.
- ammmir 14y agoProtocols are nearly impossible to market to consumers; services and apps are what people want. Whether it'll be SMTP Lite, P2P HTTP, or whatever, doesn't matter at this point. I think what's missing is a compelling user experience that's decentralized by its nature. Even the terminology needs to be thought out: email : {Gmail, Hotmail, ...} :: ____ : {Twitter, Facebook, ...} maybe ____ is "stream" as in "what's your stream address?" The technology side is exciting, but the UX needs to be nailed before bothering with it. As for adoption, there are a ton of social networking clients out there, I'm sure you could convince a few to adopt this, maybe by starting with a niche first.
- ColinWright 14y agoAbsolutely people want a service, but to build that service - which will be done by hackers - we need to have a protocol to work to. But you're right - we need to nail the user experience.