5 ms·
It's not as if OEMs are being forced to make Microsoft the sole CA of machines they sell. Here's Fedora's response (Matthew Garret mjg59): "We explored the po
by bryanlarsen 14y ago
It's not as if OEMs are being forced to make Microsoft the sole CA of machines they sell.
Here's Fedora's response (Matthew Garret mjg59):
"We explored the possibility of producing a Fedora key and encouraging hardware vendors to incorporate it, but turned it down for a couple of reasons. First, while we had a surprisingly positive response from the vendors, there was no realistic chance that we could get all of them to carry it. That would mean going back to the bad old days of scouring compatibility lists before buying hardware, and that's fundamentally user-hostile. Secondly, it would put Fedora in a privileged position. As one of the larger distributions, we have more opportunity to talk to hardware manufacturers than most distributions do. Systems with a Fedora key would boot Fedora fine, but would they boot Mandriva? Arch? Mint? Mepis? Adopting a distribution-specific key and encouraging hardware companies to adopt it would have been hostile to other distributions. We want to compete on merit, not because we have better links to OEMs."
- ScottBurson 14y agoBut couldn't they have just signed the other distros' keys? (Naive question)
- jgeralnik 14y agoYes, but that would make them responsible for any malicious code that any other distro used. That would mean they would have to do security reviews of every other distro if they wanted secure boot to remain secure, which is not feasible at all.
- coopdog 14y agoSurely the answer is to sign distributions (or not) as verified as originating from a domain (eg microsoft.com), then let the user choose which os to boot in the bios (or whatever becomes). Then if you want to run an os from an untrusted domain you can, or you can just stick to whatever is sighed as coming from microsoft As far as I can see all pc manufacturers would need to do is verify the certificate of each os on an os selection screen and display the result to the user