5 ms·
IANAL, but doesn't prior-art have to be published to count?
by aidenn0 14y ago
IANAL, but doesn't prior-art have to be published to count?
- rshm 14y agoI think you only have to prove the prior existence. It does not provide patent like protection but relieves you from the patent restrictions.
- ghshephard 14y agoI thought the entire purpose of the Patent system was that if you _don't_ publish it, and someone else does, then that other party gets the patent protection, even if you invent it. It encourages people publish their inventions/designs/processes/etc... instead of keeping them hidden in the back office.
- debacle 14y agoWe very recently moved in the US from a first-to-invent to a first-to-file system. In the former, if you can provide evidence of the genesis of the invention before the filing of the opponent's patent, then that may invalidate their patent. Samsung might be well within their rights if they say "See, we invented it first, but didn't think it was patent worthy." I don't know the particulars on the "patent worthy" consideration.
- cube13 14y ago> We very recently moved in the US from a first-to-invent to a first-to-file system. In the former, if you can provide evidence of the genesis of the invention before the filing of the opponent's patent, then that may invalidate their patent. No, you would need to prove that your documented development of the invention predates the other party's documented development of the invention. Filing date does not matter in that case.
- vidarh 14y agoThis is not to prove prior art, contrary to what the headline implies The purpose of this is to establish that Samsung did not wilfully infringe even if Apple's patents are valid (they will argue they were just in good faith continuing to evolve designs they already had that were similar), but that Apple's patents are invalid because they are dictated by function - it is logical for touch screen phones to get a large screen and reduce number of buttons, for example - and because the design elements were obvious (arguing that the existence of a wide range of similar designs, even if not published, shows that no knowledge of the iPhone was necessary for someone with ordinary knowledge of the arts to come up with something similar). Samsung has previously argued prior art previously in the form of prototype / design studies for tablets by Knight-Ridder.
- ktsmith 14y agoSamsung can also point to the LG Prada which was publicly announced three weeks before the iPhone and on sale months before the iPhone. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LG_Prada http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LG_Prada
- taligent 14y agoFirstly, it isn't about prior art so not sure why you are bringing up an LG device. Secondly, nobody is going to mistake an iPhone for an LG Prada. Nobody. But a lot of people are going to mistake an iPhone and a Samsung Galaxy S.
- incision 14y ago>But a lot of people are going to mistake an iPhone and a Samsung Galaxy S. As I've said before (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4244317 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4244317). Apple can't demonstrate 10, let alone any meaningful number of people who accidentally bought a Galaxy when they meant to pick up an iPad/iPhone. It doesn't happen.
- Someone 14y agoI do not think that is significant reason to allow their product. If I make, say, a Louis Vuitton clone, but added some part that shouted 'FAKE; NOT THE REAL THING' that every buyer could remove, there still would be a case to make for forbidding the non-clone.
- taligent 14y agoApple has evidence from Samsung that plenty of people accidentally purchased (and then returned) the Galaxy Tab thinking it was the iPad. So no reason the same wouldn't happen for the Galaxy S. So yes. It does happen.
- KirinDave 14y agoI had not heard that. Do you have a link sourcing that?
- nolok 14y agoIANAL either, but my understanding is that Apple's complaint is that Samsung stole their entire design on purpose, while Samsung's position is "we were already working on it, we didn't willfully copy your design" (and not "we invented it first, your patents are invalid").