3 ms·
> Wouldn't that be a better world? Only if your world is small enough that you can trust nobody is cheating. If everybody is doing their share to ensure there
by bluGill 2y ago
> Wouldn't that be a better world?
Only if your world is small enough that you can trust nobody is cheating. If everybody is doing their share to ensure there is always food in the store it works great. If only a few people are cheating it still works well enough. (I'm going to include the disabled in the cheating category for this discussion, because this is complex enough without trying to fit everything into the mold). As your world gets larger eventually more and more people start to realize that they can get by without working until there is no food in the store for anyone.
Note that getting food includes not just the easy stuff, but the gross stuff. If you can trust the store has what you need, you need some way to incentivize someone to get rid of the trash anyway. Money provides a good abstraction for some jobs being worth more - nearly anyone can haul trash to the dump, but because of the "gross factor" it pays more than other jobs that nearly anyone can do. Very few people can pass medical or engineering school - it is known as a hard study for good reason, so we incentivize people to go that route with more pay, if you can get everything you need, does your society have the right incentives to ensure it gets better?
History is full of societies that work similar to what you say. They all have their own ways of dealing with the above problems. One thing they all have in common is most people only contact a limited number of people and so they can crack down on cheaters because they learn who they are and so reputation matters. (the few travelers paid for their food via stories or barter, and often were looked down on anyway. Or often travelers were military and just took by force)
Again, money makes modern society possible and everyone who proposes otherwise normally just handwaves away real problems with their proposal. A few are willing to accept that downside, but when I look at those downsides I conclude I'm not and I think most will agree once they understand them.
- rbanffy 2y ago> Only if your world is small enough that you can trust nobody is cheating. If everyone has everything they need, is this a problem?
- bluGill 2y agoYour post scarcity world doesn't exist.
- rbanffy 2y agoMaybe. Global food production seems sufficient for everyone. Most humans are surviving, even if distribution is uneven, so, if we fix that, everything should work out.
- Izkata 2y ago"Need" and "want" are two very different things. Just a few years ago people were hoarding toilet paper, and that's with money as a factor limiting how much they could get at once. Sometimes there are no limits to "want".
- rbanffy 2y agoBut what if people, being sure they’d always get what they need, just didn’t engage in hoarding. And, those who still did, as many people do, got help to deal with their insecurities?