3 ms·
It's worth noting that this was a local ad in the Bay Area, near Berkeley. http://g.co/maps/6vmc6 http://g.co/maps/6vmc6 i.e. the garage sale took place in a
by danso 14y ago
It's worth noting that this was a local ad in the Bay Area, near Berkeley.
http://g.co/maps/6vmc6 http://g.co/maps/6vmc6
i.e. the garage sale took place in a highly-cultured, net-savvy area full of people who do bargain/antique shopping. Back in the late 2000s, my friends in the same area put a cheap 30 word ad in the local newspaper for a garage sale and got dozens of visitors. I don't know how much the ad cost but probably something like 50 to 60 dollars.
It's hard to gauge how much of a "success" this is when a Craigslist ad, plus some postings on large music mag forums (and I'm sure SF/Berkeley have their own large local websites) would've drawn the same attention...with a little more handiwork on the seller's end, but without costing $150.
* edit: I'd even argue that he might have drawn more people in with Craigslist and a few other nichey-type posts. I'm not a record-collector myself, but I'm guessing that there's a fair amount of them who are used to "digging" to find gems, as opposed to checking out ads/events on Facebook...antique collectors regularly scour the old-fashioned newspaper ads for garage sales because they know the type of old-fashioned people who might have undiscovered antiques are also the type to advertise in newspapers.
- brendanib 14y agoAbsolutely - there's a huge competitive advantage being in the Bay Area, and Craigslist ads can get you pretty far. In the past, I'd used Craigslist ads for selling records and seen an okay response - maybe 20-30 people or so, but nowhere near what I saw for this. The other advantage that I didn't fully realize until I started running the ads is how the activity within the Facebook Event serves as a reminder for people to show up - we see tons of ads for events every day that we want to go to, but very few of them ever make it onto our calendar the way that Facebook Events do with one click. My argument isn't that Facebook Ads are the be-all end-all marketing channel - just wanted to share my experience with them. YC folks - feel free to ping me if you want help spinning up some Facebook Ads - always down to help folks out.
- danso 14y ago> The other advantage that I didn't fully realize until I started running the ads is how the activity within the Facebook Event serves as a reminder for people to show up - we see tons of ads for events every day that we want to go to, but very few of them ever make it onto our calendar the way that Facebook Events do with one click. That's a very legit point. The various features of FB events make them "stickier" (or whatever the buzzword is) than regular advertising...the feedback options, with prospective attendees asking questions and seeing how you respond to them, is also likely to boost interest. It's not quite fair to say "Oh, this is the same as Craigslist ad postings, except you paid" just as it would be silly to ignore Airbnb because it seems just like paid Craigslist ad postings. That said, given the nature of the niche market here (though you probably know better than anyone), it's not clear that the success would easily apply to other kinds of businesses...or phases (i.e. a startup trying to get attention vs. a business having a out-of-business clearance sale).
- klawed 14y agoAlso relevant is the nature of the product being advertised - in this case, it was a specific event - not a call to visit a website or even to visit a store that holds regular business hours. Clearly, this was a very effective way of drawing customers to the event but the lessons learned hardly apply to other businesses.
- brendanib 14y agoLots of businesses can host events, IRL and online - a brick-and-mortar shop can host a sale or a meetup, an online business can host a webinar or a conference - in fact it's tough for me to think of a business that, by nature, could not host any type of event. Whether it makes sense for them to advertise on Facebook - that'll be up to them to test, but events are a pretty tried and true marketing technique.
- brendanib 14y agoYeah - I think the real challenge for startups is often that the communities and audiences for what they do, particularly early in the game, aren't often well-defined. Even when they are, they are often fragmented, and the precise interest targeting in Facebook Ads only works for Pages above a certain size threshold (unclear what exactly this is) - so if your target audience likes a few dozen smaller, scattered Pages, you can't necessarily target them directly. For some startups/companies, though, there is a pretty clearly defined audience, or a big competitor with an audience to target. If I'm Hipmunk, I can run ads targeting Kayak, Hotwire, Expedia, to go after people who I know book travel online (and then, of that subset of people, target only people who match certain demographic/geographic parameters).
- spinlock 14y agoI think this is a great idea. Like you mentioned, craigslist doesn't really do events. I just resqued a couple thousand comic books from my parent's basement and I think I'll try this out to see if I can off load them.
- brendanib 14y agoHah, yeah! My advice, unless you are a comic book expert and want to spend the time marking prices on everything, is to set a single price per item, such that on some items you'll be making more than you otherwise would, and on others you'd make a bit less.
- austenallred 14y agoI would drive for hours to find $3 vintage records, and I'm not alone -- he tapped into a cult. I'd need to see a control of posting an ad on craigslist for free to be able to conclude anything about the effectiveness of Facebook ads.
- brendanib 14y agoIn my experience Craigslist is great for capturing the older collector audience, or anyone looking to grip and flip, but Facebook Ads brought me the younger audience, who isn't otherwise dedicated enough to wake up early on a Saturday and hit 15 garage sales. There are a lot of folks that aren't willing to dedicate that kind of time to the hunt, but who still have money to spend.