3 ms·
Broadly speaking, electrical grids are the largest machines in the world and are held together by systems to keep everything in harmony at a target frequency (e
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Broadly speaking, electrical grids are the largest machines in the world and are held together by systems to keep everything in harmony at a target frequency (enormous spinning mass that slows when load is added, and has to spin back up, failsafes that have to decouple parts of the grid when maintaining voltage and frequency becomes impossible with committed capacity, etc). It’s actually wild it works flawlessly most of the time and is a testament to robust systems keeping them operational. There’s always room for improvement between here and some nebulous point of diminishing returns. That cost/resiliency discovery process is constant.
In this case, there is room for improvement, at some cost to be determined from a post mortem.
- Galatians4_16 2y agoGiant flywheels exist, in some systems, which can easily start or restart backup diesel generators on the fly, though probably not for whole grids. A bit of decentralization goes a long way.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoBatteries are taking over this role. Tesla has one near Houston, TX that can have an isolated electrical path established from it to geographically close thermal generators to provide blackstart capabilities (like jumpstarting a car). “Gambit Energy” is the project. To your point, distribution and grid segmentation solves for this, but it takes time and money to deploy batteries throughout a service territory, configure orchestration and transmission grade disconnects to rapidly isolate system components, etc. I see a large order of battery storage from BYD in Chile’s future. https://www.gambit-energystorage.com/ https://www.gambit-energystorage.com/ https://www.angleton.tx.us/DocumentCenter/View/3793/Gambit-Energy-Storage-Park-FAQ?bidId= https://www.angleton.tx.us/DocumentCenter/View/3793/Gambit-E... https://www.ercot.com/files/docs/2024/01/12/Tesla%20BESS%20Grid%20Forming%20and%20Augmentation_ERCOT.pdf https://www.ercot.com/files/docs/2024/01/12/Tesla%20BESS%20G... https://www.nrel.gov/grid/black-start.html https://www.nrel.gov/grid/black-start.html
- no_wizard 2y agoAt times I wonder if Tesla, as far as the business goes, would be better off pivoting to being a battery company that happens to make cars than a car company that happens to make batteries. They've been pushing the envelope on battery tech for some time now, and finding very useful, if at times novel, uses for it.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoPerhaps if they have a CEO that focuses on the business such that BYD's CEO does. Without effective leadership, it's just an unattended machine that will not grow as fast as competitors will, although it'll continue to spit out cars and battery packs on existing lines as long as workers doing that work are happy enough to stay and quality stays "Tesla good enough” that consumers will continue to procure their products. Hot take: Bring back JB Straubel (Former Tesla CTO). That’s who is the equivalent of BYD’s CEO. A driven, yet low key engineering leader. Culture comes from the top. HN Search: BYD (sorted by date) - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=BYD&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- rob74 2y agoWell, currently the CEO is not only not doing his job at Testla, but actually doing his best to drive away Tesla's customers. And it's working, at least in Europe: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvgd9v3r69qo https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvgd9v3r69qo
- bigtimesink 2y agoMusk fanboys are always impressed by how much he does, but it's becoming clear he can't have time to be the CEO of Tesla, owner of X, CEO of the Boring Company, CEO of SpaceX, CEO of SpaceX, CEO of xAI, owner of Neuralink, Reichsleiter of the DOGE, and top-20 Diablo IV player.
- littlestymaar 2y ago
- littlestymaar 2y ago> A bit of decentralization goes a long way. Electric grid get more reliable with scale, not less (that's why parts of North Africa is interconnected with Europe, which itself is interconnected all the way to Russia). Small grids (like islands) are always a nightmare to manage for that reason.
- aeyes 2y agoNorth Africa is interconnected to Europe because Europe thought that it would be a good idea to build huge solar plants there. The project ultimately failed because long distance energy transportation is difficult and expensive, among other issues like general instability of the region. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desertec https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desertec
- littlestymaar 2y agoNo, this is independent: first of all the Spain-Morocco interconnection predates the Desertec project by half a decade, and survived after its demise, but it has never been designed to be able to carry that much electricity (it's barely capable of carrying 1.4GW): it cannot be used for significant export and is there for grid stability alone. Had you read the Wikipedia page you posted, you'd have realized that they planned to use dedicated HVDC lines under the Mediterranean to carry the power, and not the Spain-Moroco interconnection.
- rurban 2y agoBut the best and biggest batteries are natural high water dams. You pump it up and let it flow down. But you need mountains and water. Chile has a lot of those