4 ms·
I'm trying. My daughter loves Star Trek and I have had over the years extensive discussions with my older sons about how poverty is designed into our society an
by rbanffy 2y ago
I'm trying. My daughter loves Star Trek and I have had over the years extensive discussions with my older sons about how poverty is designed into our society and how eradicating it could be easy with just a couple minor adjustments.
Unfortunately, the world has been turning in the wrong direction - basic human decency is considered "woke" and "leftism". Any attempt to make a just society is called "communism" and shouted down aggressively by the people who would most benefit from it.
We need to change these things.
Something Gorbachev said on the fall of the Soviet Union stuck with me for the past couple decades, that they "failed because they tried to make a better man".
Are we that doomed?
- card_zero 2y agoYes, but no more doomed than that. It'll probably be alright.
- sithadmin 2y agoIs poverty really 'designed into our society'? It seems to me that the underlying aspects of poverty - particularly resource scarcity and insecurity - are inherent aspects of the 'state of nature', which are only escapable via the cooperative mechanisms associated with the formation of society and governance. Sure, these things aren't 100% effective at eliminating poverty, but the proposition that poverty is somehow an intentionally baked-in objective seems hyperbolic. Further, the notion that the USSR failed because "they tried to make a better man" is an absurd whitewashing of Soviet history.
- throawayonthe 2y ago[dead]
- BoxOfRain 2y ago>Further, the notion that the USSR failed because "they tried to make a better man" is an absurd whitewashing of Soviet history. Isn't he referring specifically to the notion of the 'New Soviet Man' here, the idea that a communist economic model would produce fundamentally different humans as a result? I can see why he would describe that as a flawed approach, but you're right that it'd be an odd thing to blame for the fall of the Soviet Union over the other factors which contributed to it.
- rbanffy 2y agoI don't think Gorbachev was trying to be precise on that moment. It is, however, a failure of the project that such "New Soviet Man" was not created, and it makes me ask myself what environment would be to create a person with these attitudes.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoYes, poverty really is 'designed into our society'. Huge parts of our economy are prerequisite on 'zero hour' jobs. Where you are guaranteed zero hours per week, and have to check your schedule at the start of every week. Those working these jobs often have to work multiple zero hour jobs just to survive and somehow juggle that neither job has a fixed, dependable schedule. These jobs then prevent them from being able to use their off time (because they can't schedule around their jobs) to improve their lot in life. It is designed to be chaotic and a trap paying not even enough for survival (hence needing multiple jobs) let alone get ahead.
- EndShell 2y agoZero hours contracts are likely the unintended consequence of other (employment) regulation. People / Organisations (this includes private businesses and organisation, as well as state owned organisation) will try to circumvent any limits placed on it. You seem to be of the belief that if you "tweak the nobs" just right, things will be magically be fixed, this is naive. The law of unintended consequences has been observed countless times throughout history when people have tried to do exactly that. This is extremely naive. Even Star Trek itself that you appear to be a fan of. The Earth is post scarcity, they show that the Federation isn't the benevolent force that they pretend to be (This is hinted multiple times in TNG and shown outright in DS9) and that there are others that are negatively affected by the Federation and its policies e.g the Marquis.
- throawayonthe 2y ago[dead]
- readthenotes1 2y ago"easy with just a couple minor adjustments." Liking that fictional universal star trek, all you would have to do is eradicate pride, greed, lust, anger, gluttoney, envy, and sloth. Then we could all have nice things. Or if you don't like that set - eradicate acquisitiveness, rivalry, vanity, and love of power. Then with those easy changes, we could eradicate poverty
- _DeadFred_ 2y ago'things can never be improved, and we can't hold our fellow humans accountable nor expect anything out of them'. Total bs. But helps certain groups explain away/wave away that they are crappy human beings.