4 ms·
The desktop really doesn't need reinventing The problem is that the devices where the traditional WIMP interface make the most sense (desktop & laptop PCs) are
by smacktoward 14y ago
The desktop really doesn't need reinventing
The problem is that the devices where the traditional WIMP interface make the most sense (desktop & laptop PCs) are on track to become a small niche in the overall computing landscape, thanks to the wild growth in mobile and tablet computing. While desktops and laptops aren't going to disappear anytime soon, they're not where the action is.
So if you're a maker of an operating environment, you can stick with an interface that's highly optimized for desktops and laptops, but that severely reduces the relevance of your work.
It's like choosing to make an operating environment today that only runs on IBM mainframes. Those mainframes exist, they're still out there, and you can still make money selling software for them; but that choice makes your product irrelevant to the vast majority of computer users today. And when you slot yourself into a niche, you can never grow larger than the niche you've slotted yourself into. If you want to be an industry leader, you have to be playing in the same space where the users are; you can't get any further back in the parade than the middle.
All the significant commercial developers of traditional WIMP environments today (which means Microsoft, Apple, and Canonical) are struggling with how to make this transition -- to stay relevant on the desktop while also extending themselves into the tablet/mobile realm. It's a big challenge, and it's not clear at this point that any of them have figured out how to do it yet. But they have to do it to stay viable as mass-market vendors.
I would imagine the pressure to make that transition is even greater on open-source projects like GNOME. If you're a commercial player stuck in a niche, that's not necessarily a bad outcome if the niche is at least profitable. But open-source development is driven more by developer ambition. Developers want to work on hot new projects that lots of people will use, not old stable projects for niche audiences. In a commercial environment you can salve their disappointment at being stuck with the boring old projects somewhat with cash and perks. That's less true in FOSS development. So the talent flees your ecosystem to go work on things that are more fun, and you slowly die by inches.
- tomrod 14y agoSo why not start a whole new project, instead of dumping the most successful of previous projects?
- bkor 14y agoI don't get what you mean. GNOME 3? A new project was started; mutter and gnome-shell. You say that starting a new project is better than dumping other projects. So I guess you want people not only to start something new, but also keep maintaining their old things? It seems a bit strange to me. In case of GNOME 3, gnome-panel and metacity are still available.
- Kerrick 14y agoThe thing is, GNOME has always been an interface that's highly optimized for desktops and laptops. If they wanted to come up with a new interface for tablets and mobile, they should have done it with a separate project.
- cloverich 14y agoTHIS!! Do people honestly see long-time LINUX users dumping their laptops / Desktops for Tablets / Smartphones? I really don't get the pull for "unified" interfaces. It doesn't make sense. I don't do the same things on my mobile devices that I do on desktop / laptops. Not. At. All. There is no reason to Unify them. The closest thing I could see is similar interfaces, with features useful on both included, but otherwise different.
- wmf 14y agoDo people honestly see long-time LINUX users dumping their laptops / Desktops for Tablets / Smartphones? GNOME/Fedora and Ubuntu are not targeting long-time Linux users. They are targeting people who have never used Linux.