3 ms·
Aside from being a strong candidate for virtually defining Correlation Is Not Causation, the paragraph "Even within high-frequency trading, comparing the finge
by patio11 18y ago
Aside from being a strong candidate for virtually defining Correlation Is Not Causation, the paragraph
"Even within high-frequency trading, comparing the finger ratio only works if traders have equal access to capital and information, and similar risk limits, said Coates [who] was able to adjust the study data to minimize the influence of these factors."
gives me pause. You know, with the right correction to the data set, I can make ANYTHING look statistically significant. (Particularly when I'm allowed to try out an arbitrary number of corrections and discard the ones which fail to produce a data set that supports my hypothesis.)
- streety 18y agoStrangely the paper makes no reference to any correction. Instead stating that, "Traders had equal access to capital and information, and their risk limits were determined by their track records." The methods give no further information on any corrections applied: Subjects.During recruitment we approached potential subjects on the trading floor and invited them to participate in the study. They were given an introductory note that explained briefly that we were looking at the effects of prenatal testosterone on the shape of their right hand. No information was given about our hypothesis. Interested traders were informed that they would receive a summary of our findings; they were not offered payment. Of the traders asked to participate, all but 3 agreed. Before giving a handprint, all subjects completed a short questionnaire asking their age, years of trading, P&Lhistory,numberofolderbrothers, and whether they had broken the index or ring finger of their right hand. They also signed an informed consent form. All handprints, questionnaire data, and P&L from the bank were coded by an independent laboratory technician in Cambridge, so our analyses were conducted blindly with respect to the identity of the traders. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the School of Biological Sciences at the University of Cambridge. Five of the traders volunteering for the study could not be included because they had broken either the index or ring finger of their right hands. From the remaining49 subjects, 2were subsequently excluded because their handprints were of insufficient quality to be assessed, and 3 were excluded because they received a different compensation package from the other traders,making it difficult to compare their P&Ls (although retaining them in the study left all results significant). It would be useful to know how potential subjects were identified though. Were they just the first 52 people they bumped into in the office, randomly selected from the 200 people who work there (would be nice) or was there some pre-screening?
- trapper 18y agoI agree. There was however a nice paper showing relationships to trader performance and testosterone/cortisol ratios last year, and there have been studies showing testosterone:finger length correlations as well. Obviously more work is needed.
- marvin 18y ago..and most posts on this story seem to assume that the paper claims a correlation between digit ratio and performance. It doesn't - assuming that there is, in fact, a correlation between digit ratio and testosterone levels, it probably implies nothing more than that high testosterone levels are necessary to impress the decision-makers in trading companies. It's an interesting correlation, but it pretty much follows from high testosterone levels -> low digit ratio and high testosterone levels -> high trader salary It makes sense that small differences in some personal characteristic leads to large differences between the compensation of traders. The interesting question is whether slightly higher testosterone levels cause ten times better performance over time (or even enough of a performance improvement to justify a ten times greater salary). This seems like a ludicrous claim. But it's really funny if this is, in fact, what the market implicitly expects from its traders.
- dhimes 18y ago... and also correlations to sexual orientation (no joke) http://www.unl.edu/rhames/courses/readings/homofinger/homo_finger.html http://www.unl.edu/rhames/courses/readings/homofinger/homo_f...
- MoeDrippins 18y agoI don't think the paper hypothesizes a long ring finger CAUSES traders to be better traders, does it?