3 ms·
If there was ever a Kickstarter project (And I say this as a backer of several kick starters, check my ID) - that was destined to failure, this is it. Unrealis
by ghshephard 14y ago
If there was ever a Kickstarter project (And I say this as a backer of several kick starters, check my ID) - that was destined to failure, this is it. Unrealistic schedules, overhyped expectations, poor communication. Of course we'd all love to see something like this happen, but disruption has to happen more organically. You can't just announce that you are going to build a competitive console in eight months. These things take years - particularly given all of the obstacles (Store, Controller, Development Platform, DRM) that exist.
Most of the kick starters that I find are successful, are those which _already_ have a fully functioning prototype that people are able to use, work, play with - and the kickstarter is something that lets them do this at scale.
The kick starters that are for the R&D/Development almost never hit their targets - even for projects much less aggressive than this one.
Plus - the budget is tiny for all these sub-projects, particularly because they are going to have to pay for all these consoles out of it. It's a train wreck in the offing.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- slurgfest 14y agoYou may be right that Ouya is destined for failure. But (and I say this thinking about things other than Ouya) a game platform does not need all the things you list at the outset. That's like saying you need to create an EA in order to make games. If you can put together pieces to make hardware that will run a game successfully, you can have a start. There is a vast gulf between homebrew and EA which is not very well exploited commercially.
- ghshephard 14y agoI _completely_ agree with you - and I wish Ouya had been a lot more humble about what they were trying to accomplish. Sure, they wouldn't have gotten $5mm+ in funding, but, at the same time, they would have had a much greater chance in delivering what they were trying to accomplish. Heck, just having a controller working in 8 months would have been a huge victory, controller + API + console in 8 months is what I would have targeted. Six months after that a developer platform. Six months after that a Downloadable (free) store. Six months after that a Store-for-Pay. And Six-months after that some AAA games available, like Minecraft or FF7. These are realistic goals, and would have avoid the certain disappointment when in March, Ouya doesn't have Quality Console+Controller+Store+Free-Demos+AAA Games. Which, alas, I guarantee you it really, really won't.