3 ms·
Not in this case. the amount of the universe we can really observe is tiny. Sure we can see a lot of stars, but that is about it. We cannot directly see any
by bluGill 2y ago
Not in this case. the amount of the universe we can really observe is tiny. Sure we can see a lot of stars, but that is about it. We cannot directly see any planets outside our solar system (this might not be completely true, I'm not sure what the limits are), except by how they change the light of the star. Basically we can't even detect earth sized planets around most stars, as they are too small. If we cannot detect planet sized objects that means there is no hope of seeing lifeforms on the planet.
The limits are not just our technology levels. Many of the signs you want to life for of life are things that we know by laws of physics could not possibly reach us no matter how good the detection equipment is.
That is why SETI looks for radio waves - they are one of the few signals we can detect that could signal life. However we would never detect earth technology levels of just 120 years ago (there is some debate about what we could first detect). There are not many stars within 100 lightyears of earth, so the vast majority of our galaxy (must less the universe) still has no idea we are here. Even radio signals degrade with distance, so there is a limit to how far we can detect them or they can detect us.
In short, while there is absence of evidence, there is reason believe that we don't have enough evidence to declare anything. If we find life that will be conclusive, but the we don't before our sun dies there still won't be enough evidence to state there is none.
- happosai 2y ago> We cannot directly see any planets outside our solar system (this might not be completely true, I'm not sure what the limits are) Glad you expressed uncertainity. Indeed We can see some exoplanets directly. I also only learned this very recently. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_directly_imaged_exoplanets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_directly_imaged_exopla...
- andrewflnr 2y agoIt only happened recently, relative to SETI efforts overall.
- bluGill 2y agoThanks for the correction. Note that all those planets are very large (none of significantly smaller than Jupiter, and most are much larger). Also all are very close to earth, and the "smaller" it is the closer it is". Physics provides limits to what we will ever be able to directly observe from earth (though I'm not an astrophysicist, find one if you want to know more details, I'm confident in that statement anyway but do understand my expertise isn't here)