3 ms·
They should - but only if a good lawyer points that out to the courts. Remember the courts are not experts in the technical details in question (and should not
by bluGill 2y ago
They should - but only if a good lawyer points that out to the courts. Remember the courts are not experts in the technical details in question (and should not be - there are far more details that could come before the court than any human has time to learn), the job of lawyers is to quickly give them enough education to figure it out.
In "Common law" when something goes before a court in slightly different situations the second court will look at what the last one decided to see if it makes sense and if they agree. Then the third time looks at both the previous. After many many cases courts will have seen all the arguments and made decisions and so there is no need to educate the court anymore, they will just look at what was done before and decide the same thing.
Not all courts follow the "common law" above though, and I'm not clear how the other systems are different. (I've only lived in common law areas)
- lokar 2y agoWell, if the CA forum had a really clear automatic sanction, I would expect the lawyer to raise that concern.
- bluGill 2y agoOther comments have since suggested this was an emergency order where the CA didn't have their lawyer present. The courts said "don't do anything for a week while the real paperwork happens". I don't know the cases in question well enough to figure out if that is correct, but it seems reasonable. But also a week is not very long.
- hyperman1 2y agoAn answer for the civil law countries I know of: The laws tend to be more detailled to avoid the situation you describe. Also, there is still a lot of referencing old cases, but it is considered guiding, not binding.
- mistrial9 2y agohmm Isn't there an applicable standard of review for legal cases?