7 ms·
I find that thing where people say "I'm not going to publish anything creative ever again, it'll just be used to train AI" so depressing. It feels like such a
by simonw 2y ago
I find that thing where people say "I'm not going to publish anything creative ever again, it'll just be used to train AI" so depressing.
It feels like such a dismal excuse to avoid andding any value to the world.
- worthless-trash 2y agoIt's not an excuse, it is a reality. Why spend your personal time and effort for someone else with a deeper pocket to automatically extract value from your work. There is certainly a line where if you're popular enough and have significant google juice you'll still get organic traffic, many small bloggers can go their entire posting history without getting more than a smattering of hits and now chatgpt is taking away that.
- simonw 2y ago"Why spend your personal time and effort for someone else with a deeper pocket to automatically extract value from your work." That's the exact attitude I'm talking about. Because creating things is good! Because it's good to put value out there into the world, even if someone else might also use it.
- creata 2y agoI think it can significantly change the harm-benefit calculus. (But I'd love to be wrong.) In the past, I could be fairly confident that if someone else uses my work (and I want them to do that! that's the point of sharing!) the good that it causes will outweigh the bad that it causes. It's not like I'm helping people make missiles. But now it's entirely possible (especially if my content is unpopular, such that LLMs make a larger proportion of its readers) that the bad outweighs the good, given the negative effects that LLMs have had and continue to have on our world.
- mikrotikker 2y agoMissiles save lives too.
- petercooper 2y agoWhy spend your personal time and effort for someone else with a deeper pocket to automatically extract value from your work. People releasing their code under MIT or BSD licenses might be able to give good answers to this.
- ndarray 2y agoGood answers like "it looks cool in my CV that big company XYZ uses my MIT licensed script"
- throw10920 2y agoIt's extremely dishonest to compare someone voluntarily releasing their work under a permissive license with someone who is involuntarily having their content and effort stolen by an organization training an AI.
- petercooper 2y agoAnd I think it's erroneous to say having publicly disseminated content being read in an LLM training process is "stealing." If I read a publicly distributed, copyrighted blog post of yours, learn something, then use that knowledge later on, did I steal your content? If an author distributes something in public, the public is allowed to read it and learn from it, whether with their eyes, a screen reader, AI agent, or whatever. Any copyright violation occurs if they attempt to republish your content, not in the reading of it. However, scraping illegally obtained non-public material - such as books an author is trying to sell or blog posts behind a paywall - could well be a violation unless access is obtained legally.
- throw10920 2y ago> And I think it's erroneous to say having publicly disseminated content being read in an LLM training process is "stealing." It's clearly theft-adjacent. You're free to use "piracy" if you want, as long as it's clear that it's illegal and morally on the level of theft. > If I read a publicly distributed, copyrighted blog post of yours, learn something, then use that knowledge later on, did I steal your content? It's also extremely dishonest to compare AI to humans like this. AI are not people - morally, socially, biologically, or legally. What a human does with a piece of content is utterly irrelevant to the process of training an AI. > If an author distributes something in public, the public is allowed to read it and learn from it, whether with their eyes, a screen reader, AI agent, or whatever. Again - very dishonest to conflate a pre-trained AI agent (such as OpenAI's Operator) with the training process. > Any copyright violation occurs if they attempt to republish your content, not in the reading of it. OK, this is just factually incorrect. It is a violation of copyright law to make copies of copyrighted content, with very limited and case-by-case fair use exceptions - the claim that violation only happens in the republishing case is completely false. This entire defense is a mix between deceptive and flat-out factually incorrect statements.
- Hamuko 2y ago*value to a private corporation that'll keep all of the profits, not pay for the environmental impact and then lobby lawmakers to stay untouchable. You can still write, paint, compose and whatnot to create "value" – just don't put it on the Internet for scraping.
- xamuel 2y agoTo me, the fact that a blog post would be used to train AI is a good thing. Hell yes I want my writing to inform the future zeitgeist! I guess it helps that the things I want to write about are novel things no-one has ever written about. I could see how AI would demoralize me if I were otherwise employed writing Generic Politics Blog #84773. But as someone who writes original unique content, I'm like, hell yes, the more readers the merrier, whether they be human or AI or some unholy combination!
- ndarray 2y agoThe world is already flooded with more "artistic value" than you can ever experience in your life. This market has been over-saturated forever. And it's all free of charge because "building a portfolio" for a chance of getting paid in the future is the go-to strategy. It was only a matter of time for a new predator (AI data collection) to arrive and exploit this situation. A handful of artists trying to react to this shouldn't be alarming. Good for them. Not because more free publishing would hurt them, but because they can invest their time better than into whatever the marginal benefit of posting the 50th free artwork might be.
- throw10920 2y agoYou calling it a "dismal excuse" is an emotional hand-wavy dismissal that doesn't actually answer the fear or solve the problem. Moreover, "the world" isn't a thing that you can add value to. You can add value to other people by sharing works with friends, or you can add value to AIs that are going to be used to replace you without getting compensated for it. One of those should be obviously bad.