6 ms·
Richard M Stallman: Steam Is Good For GNU/Linux
- Lockyy 14y agoA link to his actual post is always nicer than a commentary honestly. http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/nonfree-games.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/nonfree-games.html
- alainbryden 14y agoI agree. The OP is full of errors and typos.
- Munksgaard 14y ago(Game art is a different issue, because it isn't software.) Would anyone be able to explain why RMS has this stance? Game art is just bits and bytes, and are thus recreate-able by others (think of old school sprites for example), why is that so different from code?
- mhurron 14y agoIf it's not source code, he doesn't care how closed or restricted it is. It's what the computer does, not what you do with what the computer does that is his interest.
- 178 14y agoI think you got it almost right. The distinction is between Software and other Media (Images, Sounds). The Software has to be free because otherwise it could work against you (oversimplification). 'Source code' is misleading since, depending on how the artist produces the media, it technically might have source code without being user-run software (think vector grafics, MIDI with notes and synthesizer values, etc).
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoThat's fine for justifying the ability to view and modify source code for your own use, but his definition of free extends to being able to freely redistribute it. What's the difference between that and being allowed to sample or re-edit music and video and redistribute it?
- mhurron 14y agoHe's only interested in the redistribution of source code, that is where his definition of free ends. Simply license the code so you can and the art so you can't and RMS is find and dandy with it. Tight controls on artwork to make money off of is good but tight control on source code is evil. The closest he gets to extending out of his little bubble is that copyright should be 10 years only and then everything is public.
- tedunangst 14y agoI wonder what happens if your game uses SVG for its art.
- yourcelf 14y agoSee http://freedomdefined.org/Definition http://freedomdefined.org/Definition for a view (not RMS's) which extends the spirit of the Free Software definition to "Cultural Works", including art, music, etc. Creative Commons has adopted the language of "Free Culture Approved" for licenses which meet this definition. Not all CC licenses do (in particular, non-commercial or no derivatives clauses are incompatible).
- notime 14y agoI agree with RMS on some points, but I think this one is going to get him into trouble. I agree that most games contain some form of art, which means that if the software is free and the art in the game isn't free, RMS would be for paid games in GNU linux where the source is free, but you have to pay for its art (so it is non-free). And if he is going to include art, why not literature and other media as well? Old text adventures were filled with great writing, even if they were brief descriptions when viewed in part. Newer games spend a lot of money creating CGI cinematography with paid actors to do voice-overs for written dialog that is not code. Would he be ok with that part of the game being non-free and the code being open-source?
- Jach 14y agoFrom GNU.org: > Specifically, free software means users have the four essential freedoms: (0) to run the program, (1) to study and change the program in source code form, (2) to redistribute exact copies, and (3) to distribute modified versions. Not all these freedoms make sense for "non-functional work" like art. RMS outlines some of his views here: http://www.libervis.com/article/rms_on_the_ethics_of_non_free_art http://www.libervis.com/article/rms_on_the_ethics_of_non_fre... Paraphrasing, art (as opposed to software) is something contributed to society for enjoyment, software is for work. The minimal freedom of art should be shareable for non-commercial uses, with a max copyright of 10 years before people can create derivative works for commercial use. I imagine there might be (or could be) a license that asks for the "source" of art assets; that is, a .PSD file, or a blender project, or a script that generates the image. That's a lot more useful to me than the final image itself, and a lot easier to modify if I wanted.
- 178 14y agoFood for thought: If there would be such a license, one could still argue it offers not the most freedom possible. To take it to the extreme, the license could ask that all assets have to be in a format editable/compatible with FOSS :)
- lmm 14y agoRead RMS on "the java trap" for an analogous situation in software. I think there's a consensus that it's worth making it possible to release GPL works even when they're written on a platform for which no Free tools exist.
- betterth 14y agoI don't understand how someone can advocate freedom and also advocate any license at all. The act of licensing at all seems absolutely contrary to the idea of freedom. As soon as someone stands up and tells me how I can or cannot use something, freedom is gone, no?
- jiggy2011 14y ago
- JoshTriplett 14y agoRMS and the FSF take a fairly narrow view of what they push for freedom on: they only care about code. In my opinion, this stems from two issues. First, I think that as people who write code, RMS and the FSF don't immediately see value in things other than code, and in particular don't see the value in supporting a community of developers around something other than code. If you don't know how to produce something, you might not see the value in making it open, because you personally don't have the ability to contribute to it. Many non-programmers don't immediately see the value in Free Software / Open Source Software, because they don't personally have the ability to contribute to it. Second, the FSF has produced a large number of works of opinion, and they have rather specific thoughts about what they want done with those opinions, which for some reason they don't see as inconsistent with their views on software. Note that all of the essays on gnu.org/philosophy/ have a license that allows redistribution but not modification; in many different places, they've expressed the opinion that works of opinion need not have free licenses, because changing such works would change the opinions expressed. Personally, this seems entirely wrong to me. If I take a copy of CSS3 and modify it, it no longer matches the CSS3 standard. However, I could still usefully use it for other purposes, such as talking about the implications of different CSS models, or making a proposal for what I'd like to see in CSS. And if for some reason I attempted to describe my modified version as CSS3 (or CSS3.1), that would make it no different than any other random bit of factual inaccuracy or buggy code on the Internet. The same goes for a modified version of a philosophical essay, or the script or art for a game.
- mike-cardwell 14y agoAlthough the title is the same as the one from the article it links to, it is not what he says. He says there are both good and bad things about it. It's good if it stops you using Windows. He still categorises what Steam is doing as unethical. As Lockyy stated, check out what he actually said here instead: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/nonfree-games.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/nonfree-games.html
- sigzero 14y agoI do not agree with his "unethical" claim at all.
- mike-cardwell 14y agoMany people don't. One of his core opinions is that the production/distribution of any non-free software is unethical. You can agree or disagree with him, but at least he explains and backs up his arguments with logic. Do you know his arguments for this?
- bunderbunder 14y agoHis logic is perfectly valid for justifying is own feelings about it. But his reason for getting up in arms about other people doing things differently seems to just be that he's a nosy noser who can't keep his nose out of what goes on among consenting adults in situations that don't really involve him. (edit: Well, that and if he changed his tack his career would be over. Having chosen to make his living on the lecture circuit rather than getting paid to write software, he's essentially relinquished his freedom to re-examine or temper his own opinions. At least not publicly.)
- fffggg 14y agoReading your post I'm lead to believe that you haven't read (or properly understood) his philosophical stance. You say: "he's a nosy noser who can't keep his nose out of what goes on among consenting adults in situations that don't really involve him" Yet, proprietary software development and the accompanying restrictions on related freedoms impacts us all. Any time someone creates a proprietary computer program it restricts everyone's ability to freely interact with it. You may disagree with his conclusion; you may believe it is OK to claim property-like control over intangible, intellectual constructs. But you cannot say that this control does not affect others. You cannot say that it does not affect him. The very nature of copyright is to limit the freedom of all other persons with respect to a particular work.
- mrspandex 14y agoPersonally, I don't see games the same as other software. Generally, they are more like content (movies, music, etc). Especially in the world of game consoles, where the games come on read only discs. Games that are able to be "modded" of course add additional value and surely open source games would only expand the possibility, but there aren't the same concerns of my work and data being locked away in a proprietary ecosystem. If a game from 10 years ago stops working, it is disappointing, but not debilitating.
- geon 14y agoA great point. The counter argument would be the recent development with drm that requires online authentication to run, so they can't be sold and will stop working at some point, most likely within 5-10 years.
- gcp 14y agoOr games that require closed-source servers where the server software isn't provided to customers, but only to select hosting partners.
- betterth 14y ago"so they can't be sold and will stop working at some point, most likely within 5-10 years." This is incorrect, it would be more correct to say that they could stop working at some point. It's entirely possible (and has been done before) for the company to patch out the DRM before turning servers off or going defunct. The internet is also full of no-cd cracks that generally circumvent this kind of always-on protection (at the expense of breaking multiplayer) without circumventing serial code or other protections.
- user49598 14y agoIt's not about what kind of software they are considered, it's about code running on your system. In the RMS eyes, if code runs on your system, and you can't read/modify that code yourself, it's unethical.
- jiggy2011 14y ago
- MBlume 14y agoThis is another area where I prefer Raymond's open-source consequentialism to Stallman's free software deontology. Raymond actually takes the time to evaluate the harms (http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=4371 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=4371) we anticipate from closed source software, and shows why we can expect a greater harm from OS or productivity software than from games or elevator firmware.
- alwaysinshade 14y agoI think there's a bigger picture that RMS seems to be missing. Simply look in the HN feed and you'll see that Square Enix is partnering with OUYA. OnLive is partnering with OUYA. Steam is coming to Linux. This is about cutting out the middle-man and bringing content to people without the enormous barriers to entry. This is a coup in waiting and RMS is worried about whether content is free (or "nonfree" in his own words, both in terms of DRM and cost). This is greater freedom for producers of content and consumers alike, but not for tinkerers. It’s not the outcome that he wants but it could be one of the most important developments for open source platforms. He needs to step back and assess what’s more important - his rigid ideals or measurable progress for open source platforms.
- notime 14y agoOUYA is a great idea, but it remains to be seen whether it will take off. I like homebrew development, but the fact is that the tools around providing homebrew development to the everyday joe are shoddy at best. Homebrew channel on Wii comes to mind- They have a great title sequence and the popping bubbles, but the homebrew app allowing you to install new games has to be added manually on the SD card. And it is buggy and the user experience leaves much to be desired. And then after you wait 20 minutes to download a game, your kid could accidentally delete it in 5 seconds because deletion is right there with the games on the menu. But, the biggest problem is that few are savvy enough to install the Wii Homebrew channel and an SD card doesn't come with the Wii anyway. The only way OUYA is going to survive and thrive is if they can sell at Best Buy, Gamestop, etc. and if the device is easy to use, doesn't have a load of crap on it like the Roku, and is fast enough to support games people want to play. But on top of that- it better not have a sub-par interface.