4 ms·
I think "almost all poems are bad poems" is more like it. My wife was talking to me the other day about how "all the poems in the New Yorker are bad." I think
by PaulHoule 2y ago
I think "almost all poems are bad poems" is more like it.
My wife was talking to me the other day about how "all the poems in the New Yorker are bad." I think the last contemporary poet that I liked was Charles Bukowski [1] but even as a (not quite super) fan I think you don't need more than a copy of Post Office (an early novel of his) and one volume of his poems because from beginning to end his poems were about drinking alcohol, taking care of his cats, loose women, and gambling at the track.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Bukowski https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Bukowski
- analog31 2y agoI used to measure my level of boredom by how tempted I was to read the poems in the New Yorker. I finally brought myself to read the fiction, at least.
- PaulHoule 2y agoThe fiction comes across as "post-woke white folks who want to read like Haruhi Murakami" which isn't too bad because it is "post-woke" (e.g. has a little bit of self-awareness)
- analog31 2y agoDamn, I've barely even caught up with woke.
- defrost 2y agoFor your interest and consideration, Twue Vogon Poetry. Written by a mining billionaire, attached to a 30 tonne rock, dropped outside central HQ, entirely serious, completely unaware, mere conventions of speeling, granma, and sensibility tossed asunder. Enjoy (?) https://www.businessinsider.com/everyone-is-laughing-at-australias-richest-persons-ode-to-mining-2012-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/everyone-is-laughing-at-aust...
- spondylosaurus 2y agoEven as a short story fan, I haven't been impressed by the New Yorker's fiction lately, but there's good stuff in the archives. And the occasional new George Saunders piece, which tend to be pretty good, if not great.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoWell if none of the good ones go viral, that's the perception being pushed.
- wwweston 2y agoBad at what? I agree most poetry is bad at hitting my subjective quality markers, at tickling my sense of sophistication and meaning. I don't even like the majority of poetry from poets that I love. I fell in love with Cummings as a teenager and checked out his collected works and realized quickly that while I found some transcendent (and worth the slog through what wasn't), I also found the majority of the work of one of the most famous 20th C poets pretty meh. Even for those who can outrace Sturgeon's Law (which I think Cummings achieved), it's an art, not or science, hit or miss. And alongside issues of quality, skill, and probability of hits there will also always be subjectivity in how a work hits each member of an audience. Still... bad for what? As well as being an art, poetry is a humanity. The two chord punk rock song is definitely doing less and less sophisticated things than a Palestrina motet or even Steve Reich's studies in subtly changing simplicity and we lose something when we can't appreciate sophistication and intricacy (with or without being able to articulate the specifics). But we also lose something when we can't appreciate simple expression even with mediocre articulation. Bad poems are probably doing something well enough alongside being bad at meeting various standards.
- cafard 2y agoI think that in general one finds that the anthologists got it right. Randall Jarrell said that a good poet is someone who spends his life standing outside in thunderstorms and is struck two or three times. [Quotation not exact, taken probably from Poetry and the Age.]
- wwweston 2y agoThat’s an apt description and poetic itself, thanks for the reference!
- lioeters 2y agoBukowski is a hilarious and uproarious poet, especially if you've experienced what life is like at the bottom of society. The despair, anger, and joy of living - it's gritty, ugly, hopeless, and yet somehow with a hint of redemption.