2 ms·
> 25% of Americans If you’re referring to people who don’t vote, they de facto support the outcome. Particularly if in a swing state. > genocidal dementia pat
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> 25% of Americans
If you’re referring to people who don’t vote, they de facto support the outcome. Particularly if in a swing state.
> genocidal dementia patient
People who voted for Trump (or threw their vote in a swing state) because of Palestine are the definition of stupid and selfish. By prioritising their interests above those they purported to represent, they will have played a (non-critical) role in the destruction of Palestine.
- tombert 2y agoIt baffled me that anyone thought that Trump was going to somehow be better than Kamala in regards to Palestine. I could understand voting for a third party, but Trump outright tried to impose a Muslim ban in his first time, and said that his son in law was going to quickly solve the Middle East conflict single-handedly; seems unlikely that he would be sympathetic to people in the Middle East.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> baffled me that anyone thought that Trump was going to somehow be better than Kamala in regards to Palestine I was in Phoenix in April 2024 when an otherwise-intelligent friend remarked on whether Trump was pro Israel. She wound up remembering his first term eventually. But at that moment I realised that the checkmate Democrats thought they had Republicans in with abortion, Republicans had Democrats in with Palestine: move to the left and you lose moderates and Pennsylvania. Move to the right (or fail to message) and you lose Michigan and your base. Message at all and you lose swing voters who don’t want to hear about foreign policy.
- maxerickson 2y agoI'm not sure they thought that Trump would be better. It seems they think that voting is a test unrelated to the likely outcomes. So you should vote "right" rather than compromising and voting for the better among the possible outcomes.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> you should vote "right" rather than compromising and voting for the better among the possible outcomes This is said well. The vote was about reaffirming an identity. Its effect on the people they purported to care for was secondary.
- tehjoker 2y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> if both sides are genocidal, there's no choice where your life gets better As I said, stupid and selfish. Not seeing the difference between bombing and explicit ethnic cleansing and relocation for the people in Gaza is modern Sykes-Picot. Note that I’m fine with that person not voting. (Almost prefer it.) It’s wild, though, to pretend it furthered the interests of the people they pretend to hold dear, versus some personal moral purity they’d prefer to preach about online. > i did vote socialist/green This is fine, even admirable, if you’re not in a swing state. If you’re in a swing state, you de facto voted for Trump and the destruction of both Gaza and the dream of a Palestinian nation-state. > if liberals want to win elections, they need to start offering a vision of a better future Sure. And never mention Israel or Palestine again, because I no longer have any desire to engage with the US elements of those movements who are, on both sides, adamant about redrawing foreign borders in respect of countries and cultures they have no direct relation to nor experience with.
- tehjoker 2y agodo you have any concept of what they were doing in Gaza? 85% of schools bombed/damaged, almost every hospital destroyed, tens of millions of tons of rubble, Trump said 1.7-1.8M remaining (meaning 400-500k dead). this is a holocaust. Democrats are not doing an "innocent war". They are hiterites with a smile on their face. The Republicans are hitlerites with a frown. Sometimes vice versa depending on the situation. I voted in PA. You guys want my vote? appeal to me and people like me.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> 85% of schools bombed/damaged, almost every hospital destroyed, tens of millions of tons of rubble, Trump said 1.7-1.8M remaining How do you think those 2mm remaining would prefer the future to go? Razed, relocated and—let’s be honest—in all likelihood ersatz enslaved somewhere in Central Asia or Africa? Safe in the knowledge someone in America made this choice for them with a false equivalence between living on their land to fight another day and being dissolved as a nation? That is the selfishness. That is the holier-than-thou imperial mindset; what matters is how one is portrayed and gets to think about oneself, not how the people one uses as puppets fare. (Sykes and Picot’s supporters thought they were helping, too!)