3 ms·
Reasonable people are sometimes lead to believe that repairability is counter to safety (i.e. "if an amature does the repair wrong, they could hurt themselves
by CivBase 2y ago
Reasonable people are sometimes lead to believe that repairability is counter to
safety (i.e. "if an amature does the repair wrong, they could hurt themselves or the owner"),
security (i.e. "if we let people know how it works, it'll be easier to hack"),
technilogical advancement (i.e. "smartphones would have to be chunky bricks with no water resistance if we designed them to be easily opened for repair"),
consumer protection (i.e. "unauthorized repair technicians are unaccountable and might do something unscrupulous to your device"),
value (i.e. "if companies have to design for repair and provide support for repair, then those costs get passed onto consumers"),
among other things. I don't find these arguments compelling and I think there is plenty of precedent for repairability being best for consumers. But they come up a lot - especially from anti-R2R lobbiests.
Our society has also been trained to be consumers, always throwing away old stuff in favor of the latest and greatest. When something breaks, the first thought is usally "how much will it cost to replace this?" instead of "how do I fix it?" Everything is treated as disposible, so there isn't much motivation for the average person to care about repair.
- p0w3n3d 2y ago+ecology (i.e. "the new device uses 1kW less energy per month so you shouldn't even try fixing the old one")
- AnthonyMouse 2y agoThey don't use that one very much because the difference in energy efficiency between a five year old device and a ten year old device is generally negligible, whereas the ecological consequences of throwing away an entire device and having to build a whole new one are something they don't want to be reminding people about by bringing it up.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoThat might be the strongest argument against it. I would really like total control of my car's ECU, but I know the most popular use of such a power would be to circumvent emissions controls and maximize MPG or HP.
- braiamp 2y agoThe funniest thing about this list, is that all those things has happened with "approved" "certified" repairs and/or replacement processes.
- m463 2y agocan't help but think each of those points is something a "<large corporation>" has carefully listed as talking points. sort of like the bathroom hand dryers that have many biased points saying they are better than paper towels.