4 ms·
> I am worried that the good people at SpaceX might decide to abandon ship For whom? There isn't another ship. (Literally. Ariane has nothing, ULA is on its de
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> I am worried that the good people at SpaceX might decide to abandon ship
For whom? There isn't another ship. (Literally. Ariane has nothing, ULA is on its deathbed, Blue Origin might do something in the 2030s and nobody is moving from Hawthorne to Xi'an.)
SpaceX remains a jewel of American industry and technological achievement. If you're an ambitious aerospace engineer, SpaceX is the only place where you'll see your cutting-edge work launched.
- ragebol 2y agoThere's Stoke, Relativity, Rocketlab, Firefly, Ursa Major and a whole bunch more companies (many of which I forgot to mention, sorry) that are trying to come after SpaceX. Now that SpaceX has shown reuse is possible, it's easier to convince anyone that reuse is viable. Similar to how Tesla showed that EVs could be nice and kickstarted the legacy automakers to get on this too.
- skissane 2y agoThe issue is that space launch is a lot smaller market than EVs with a lot higher unit costs. I think the majority of the companies you mention are going to fail, because the market isn’t big enough for them all. Rocket Lab is most likely to survive because they’ve already got a decent sized business even though it is primarily at the low end, but moving up the market is arguably easier than starting from scratch. The others are competing not just against SpaceX, but also Blue Origin (which despite being rather slow is still way ahead of most of the companies you mention), as well as against Rocket Lab and each other
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> There's Stoke, Relativity, Rocketlab, Firefly, Ursa Major and a whole bunch more companies (many of which I forgot to mention, sorry) that are trying to come after SpaceX These are all smallsat launchers. I have worked with a few of their teams and have mad respect for their work. But between launch cadence, fundraising and mission profile, they’re not comparable to SpaceX. > Similar to how Tesla showed that EVs could be nice and kickstarted the legacy automakers SpaceX has a global commanding position and domestic political advantage Tesla has never enjoyed. It’s fair to say it has a monopoly in commercial launch outside niche operations, e.g. dedicated smallsat.
- ragebol 2y ago> they’re not comparable to SpaceX. Not yet indeed. If SpaceX were to fail for whatever reason, eg. Musk falling out of grace with his orange buddy or whatever else, there is sort of backup now I guess. > domestic political advantage Tesla has never enjoyed Agreed, but I think SpaceX showed that reuse could be done before Musk got any political influence (and went off the rails...).
- ben_w 2y agoWhat about Rocket Lab? (Well, unless people start to get Musk vibes from Peter Beck…)
- taotau 2y agoSpaceX is the stoic incumbant by now. They have the launchpads and enough money to fight any challenging patents. If I was an up and coming rocket engineer, they would be my goto stable career choice. If I had ideas, i would shop around.