3 ms·
The article is refuted by both reality -- the godawful messes that people have made out of XML, the complexity of the systems built on top of it, its failure to
by gruseom 18y ago
The article is refuted by both reality
-- the godawful messes that people have made out of XML, the
complexity of the systems built on top of it, its failure to
amount to more than a bloated machine format, and the exodus in
favor of more lightweight notations like JSON -- as well as by
itself: the author expects the reader to consider the
proliferation of single-shot technologies built on XML as a good
thing and not a Tower of Babel. He lists DTDs, RELAX, XML Schema,
XPointer, XQuery, XPath (edit: whoops, I snuck that one in), XSLT, and CSS and cites the "decades of
person-effort embodied in those specifications" as if it were an
argument in their favor!
I found this statement in the article interesting: "The central idea of the XML family of standards is to separate code from data." It explains why all the systems that express programming constructs in XML are such monstrosities (including XSLT, which he cites approvingly and yet which totally violates this separation). I wonder what the author would say to the people who do this kind of thing? They're not using it according to specification?
Edit: some of the arguments are out of date, too. I don't know anything about Lisp documentation in LaTeX; the open-source Lisp world tends to generate HTML documentation from s-expressions, as for example here: http://www.weitz.de/cl-ppcre/ http://www.weitz.de/cl-ppcre/.
- 11ren 18y agoDo you have references for that exodus? By Google, XML is winning 50 to 1 - but declining, and JSON is growing: http://www.google.com/trends?q=xml%2C+json&ctab=0 http://www.google.com/trends?q=xml%2C+json&ctab=0 However, a factor is that people already know about XML and don't need to search for it. e.g. HTML is declining even faster: http://www.google.com/trends?q=xml%2C+json%2C+HTML&ctab=0&geo=all&date=all&sort=0 http://www.google.com/trends?q=xml%2C+json%2C+HTML&ctab=...
- gruseom 18y agoOoh, duelling URLs, can I play? :) http://www.google.com/trends?q=xml%2C+javascript http://www.google.com/trends?q=xml%2C+javascript Do you have references for that exodus? Not really. I'm talking about what I observe in the hacker world, which is a thoroughgoing trend away from XML. Do you really see it otherwise? It's not all going to JSON of course. Most of the XML stuff is in big enterprise projects and, for some value of "count", those just don't count. Last I checked the IT pundits were declaring SOA dead, after having milked it for a decade.
- 11ren 18y agoHmmm... I don't think hackers ever went towards XML. The old C hackers hated it (too inefficient.) The nice thing I see in XML is that it abstracts out grammars (using XML Schema / DTD). For JSON, a grammar isn't used - it's a nested tuple transmission format - sort of a dynamic type systems, but without, er, types - just tuples that can contain anything. It's agile, and all you need in many cases. And JSON is a natural for web-client stuff. BTW: who said SOA is dead? SOA doesn't solve any pressing problem, but all the vendors switched to it.
- gruseom 18y agoBTW: who said SOA is dead? http://apsblog.burtongroup.com/2009/01/soa-is-dead-long-live-services.html http://apsblog.burtongroup.com/2009/01/soa-is-dead-long-live... A friend who works in banking sent this to me, mainly because the two of us had been predicting it for years. The post, incidentally, comes perilously close to saying that it's time to invent new bullshit acronyms because business people have stopped falling for "SOA". One could hardly ask for a better exposé of the IT racket.
- 11ren 18y agoThanks. It's a bit odd, because I don't think anyone thought SOA would do that much. It's been always vendor-driven. At least it's better than CORBA, the previous monstrosity in that role. But yes, with the recession, there may be an opportunity for something better and cheaper...
- gruseom 18y agowith the recession, there may be an opportunity for something better and cheaper... Maybe, but I doubt it. When it comes to big companies, there are too many people making money off software development not getting better or cheaper. There's still too much of a culture gap between the execs who write the cheques and competent hackers. This creates opportunity for the incompetent-but-slick to step in as parasites. When I say incompetent, of course, I mean incompetent at software; they're quite competent at getting execs to write cheques. And that would be fine, except they're not adding any value (or at least not any value commensurate with what's spent). In other words, the market is simply inefficient. Even when competent hackers work for such companies they are paid far less and have far less influence than the slickees. Moreover, the population of the competent is small, so they are drowned out demographically. It will take a long time before the market rationalizes. I do believe this is happening, but slowly. One economic cycle won't turn it around, but I agree with you that it may help!
- jdale27 18y agoRe: Lisp documentation in LaTeX, the author may be referring, for example, to CLtL; see http://www.cs.cmu.edu/Groups/AI/html/cltl/clm/node3.html http://www.cs.cmu.edu/Groups/AI/html/cltl/clm/node3.html
- gruseom 18y agoAh. Well, that was a book. I'll bet Steele would prefer LaTeX over XML too.