3 ms·
Software video transcoding still trumps modern hardware-accelerated solutions
For years, AMD, Intel, and Nvidia have hyped the hardware-accelerated video transcoding capabilities of their CPUs and GPUs. Some implementations use dedicated logic, while others leverage the arrays of shader processors in modern graphics chips. Turns out all this hardware-accelerated mojo may be no better than old-school software transcoding. We've put together a detailed comparison of video transcoding on the PC that explores everything from performance to image quality to power consumption. The verdict: software transcoding consistently produces the highest-quality results. If you can live with artifacts, the QuickSync logic built into Intel's recent CPUs is easily the fastest of the hardware-accelerated solutions, though the output quality varies widely with the software used. A beta version of the OpenCL-accelerated x264 encoder produces good results on multiple hardware configurations, but it's not much faster than pure software transcoding on a modern CPU.